TL;DR
This paper presents a theoretical framework and simulation results showing that upward curvature in the unfolding rate versus force (or denaturant concentration) plots is a direct indicator of a protein's energy landscape being "strongly multidimensional." This multidimensionality explains why proteins can switch between different unfolding pathways as external forces change, a phenomenon observed in experiments and now explained structurally.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Proteins fold and unfold through complex pathways. While theoretical models suggest that single-domain proteins can fold via multiple, parallel pathways, experimentally demonstrating this has been challenging. Specifically, when researchers measure how fast a protein unfolds (unfolding rate, $k_u$) as they apply an external force (like pulling on it with optical tweezers) or change the concentration of a denaturant, they sometimes observe an upward curve in a plot of the logarithm of the unfolding rate versus the force/denaturant. This upward curvature is puzzling because simple models of protein folding, which assume a one-dimensional energy landscape, predict a downward curvature. The authors aim to explain this observed upward curvature and its implications for protein folding pathways.
Methods
The authors employ a combination of theoretical analysis and molecular simulations.
- Theoretical Framework: They develop a rigorous mathematical proof showing that upward curvature in the $\log k_u(f)$ plot (where $f$ is force) implies a "strongly multidimensional" (SMD) energy landscape. This means the protein's free energy depends on many conformational degrees of freedom beyond just the end-to-end extension. They derive criteria for a "weakly multidimensional" (WMD) landscape, which would predict downward curvature.
- Molecular Simulations: They use coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations (specifically, the self-organized polymer with side-chains, SOP-SC model) of the src SH3 domain. These simulations allow them to:
- Calculate unfolding rates ($k_u$) at various applied forces.
- Track the structural changes during unfolding.
- Identify different unfolding pathways.
- Characterize the "transition state ensemble" (TSE) – the collection of protein structures at the point of highest energy during unfolding.
- Data Analysis: They use maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) to fit the simulated and experimental unfolding rate data to single and double exponential models. They also employ a "committor probability" ($P_{fold}$) method to identify the TSE, which is independent of a predefined reaction coordinate.
Datasets
The paper uses data from:
- Simulations: Molecular dynamics simulations of the src SH3 domain under varying forces.
- Experiments:
- Single-molecule pulling experiments on src SH3 domain (reported in Ref. [16]).
- Denaturant-induced unfolding data for the titin I27 domain (reported in Ref. [8]).
No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Upward Curvature = Multidimensionality: The most significant insight is the direct link established between upward curvature in $\log k_u$ vs. perturbation plots and a strongly multidimensional energy landscape. This provides a theoretical basis for interpreting experimental observations.
- Pathway Switching: The multidimensionality of the landscape allows for a "switch" in unfolding pathways as the applied force changes. At low forces, one pathway might be dominant, while at higher forces, another becomes more favorable.
- TSE Movement: The simulations reveal that the transition state ensemble (TSE) is not static but shifts dramatically as the force increases, reflecting the change in dominant unfolding pathways.
- Limitations of 1D Models: The paper strongly argues against interpreting parameters from simple 1D models (like the Bell model or double-exponential fits) as direct measures of transition state locations in SMD landscapes. The extracted parameters ($x_L, x_H$) do not correspond to physically meaningful distances to transition states in these cases.
- Malleability of Landscapes: A single point mutation (V61A in SH3) can shift the force at which this pathway switch occurs, demonstrating that protein energy landscapes are not fixed but can be tuned.
Key Results
- Theoretical Proof: The authors rigorously proved that upward curvature in $\log k_u(f)$ implies a strongly multidimensional (SMD) energy landscape.
- Simulation Validation: Simulations of src SH3 domain reproduce the experimentally observed upward curvature in $\log k_u(f)$ plots, confirming the SMD nature of its landscape.
- Structural Basis for Pathway Switch: Simulations reveal that at low forces, the RT-loop detaches from the protein core (ARTL pathway), while at high forces, the $\beta4-\beta5$ strands rupture first ($\Delta\beta4\beta5$ pathway). This represents a clear switch in the dominant unfolding route.
- TSE Characterization: The TSE structures were determined at different forces, showing significant changes in their composition and conformation, consistent with the pathway switch. For example, at 15 pN, the RT-loop is disconnected from the core, while at 45 pN, interactions between $\beta4$ and $\beta5$ strands are broken.
- Mutation Effect: The V61A mutation in SH3 shifts the pathway switch to lower forces, consistent with experimental observations and highlighting the landscape's malleability.
- I27 Prediction: Based on their theory and observations in SH3, they predict that the titin I27 protein, which shows upward curvature in denaturant unfolding, will also exhibit a force-dependent pathway switch when unfolded by mechanical force.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The paper acknowledges that while the double-exponential model fits the data well, inferring the nature of the TSE from these fits is problematic for SMD landscapes.
- The simulations use a coarse-grained model (SOP-SC), which may not capture all atomic-level details, although it reproduces the qualitative behavior of the $\log k_u(f)$ plot.
- The denaturant perturbation is an approximation to linear coupling, whereas force is an exact linear coupling.
- Future Work:
- The authors suggest experimental studies, such as Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments, to measure flux through different pathways and confirm their findings.
- They propose blocking specific pathways (e.g., with disulfide bridges) to experimentally verify the role of different routes.
- They explicitly predict a force-dependent pathway switch in the unfolding of titin I27 and its mutants, which can be tested with laser optical trapping experiments.
- Further investigation into the "catch bond" behavior observed in some SMD landscapes is suggested.
Summary updated