Force-dependent switch in protein unfolding pathways and transition-state movements

Pavel I. Zhuravlev, Michael Hinczewski, Shaon Chakrabarti, Susan Marqusee, D. ThirumalaiProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a theoretical framework and simulation results showing that upward curvature in the unfolding rate versus force (or denaturant concentration) plots is a direct indicator of a protein's energy landscape being "strongly multidimensional." This multidimensionality explains why proteins can switch between different unfolding pathways as external forces change, a phenomenon observed in experiments and now explained structurally.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Proteins fold and unfold through complex pathways. While theoretical models suggest that single-domain proteins can fold via multiple, parallel pathways, experimentally demonstrating this has been challenging. Specifically, when researchers measure how fast a protein unfolds (unfolding rate, $k_u$) as they apply an external force (like pulling on it with optical tweezers) or change the concentration of a denaturant, they sometimes observe an upward curve in a plot of the logarithm of the unfolding rate versus the force/denaturant. This upward curvature is puzzling because simple models of protein folding, which assume a one-dimensional energy landscape, predict a downward curvature. The authors aim to explain this observed upward curvature and its implications for protein folding pathways.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of theoretical analysis and molecular simulations.

  • Theoretical Framework: They develop a rigorous mathematical proof showing that upward curvature in the $\log k_u(f)$ plot (where $f$ is force) implies a "strongly multidimensional" (SMD) energy landscape. This means the protein's free energy depends on many conformational degrees of freedom beyond just the end-to-end extension. They derive criteria for a "weakly multidimensional" (WMD) landscape, which would predict downward curvature.
  • Molecular Simulations: They use coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations (specifically, the self-organized polymer with side-chains, SOP-SC model) of the src SH3 domain. These simulations allow them to:
  • Calculate unfolding rates ($k_u$) at various applied forces.
  • Track the structural changes during unfolding.
  • Identify different unfolding pathways.
  • Characterize the "transition state ensemble" (TSE) – the collection of protein structures at the point of highest energy during unfolding.
  • Data Analysis: They use maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) to fit the simulated and experimental unfolding rate data to single and double exponential models. They also employ a "committor probability" ($P_{fold}$) method to identify the TSE, which is independent of a predefined reaction coordinate.

Datasets

The paper uses data from:

  • Simulations: Molecular dynamics simulations of the src SH3 domain under varying forces.
  • Experiments:
    • Single-molecule pulling experiments on src SH3 domain (reported in Ref. [16]).
  • Denaturant-induced unfolding data for the titin I27 domain (reported in Ref. [8]).

No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Upward Curvature = Multidimensionality: The most significant insight is the direct link established between upward curvature in $\log k_u$ vs. perturbation plots and a strongly multidimensional energy landscape. This provides a theoretical basis for interpreting experimental observations.
  • Pathway Switching: The multidimensionality of the landscape allows for a "switch" in unfolding pathways as the applied force changes. At low forces, one pathway might be dominant, while at higher forces, another becomes more favorable.
  • TSE Movement: The simulations reveal that the transition state ensemble (TSE) is not static but shifts dramatically as the force increases, reflecting the change in dominant unfolding pathways.
  • Limitations of 1D Models: The paper strongly argues against interpreting parameters from simple 1D models (like the Bell model or double-exponential fits) as direct measures of transition state locations in SMD landscapes. The extracted parameters ($x_L, x_H$) do not correspond to physically meaningful distances to transition states in these cases.
  • Malleability of Landscapes: A single point mutation (V61A in SH3) can shift the force at which this pathway switch occurs, demonstrating that protein energy landscapes are not fixed but can be tuned.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Proof: The authors rigorously proved that upward curvature in $\log k_u(f)$ implies a strongly multidimensional (SMD) energy landscape.
  • Simulation Validation: Simulations of src SH3 domain reproduce the experimentally observed upward curvature in $\log k_u(f)$ plots, confirming the SMD nature of its landscape.
  • Structural Basis for Pathway Switch: Simulations reveal that at low forces, the RT-loop detaches from the protein core (ARTL pathway), while at high forces, the $\beta4-\beta5$ strands rupture first ($\Delta\beta4\beta5$ pathway). This represents a clear switch in the dominant unfolding route.
  • TSE Characterization: The TSE structures were determined at different forces, showing significant changes in their composition and conformation, consistent with the pathway switch. For example, at 15 pN, the RT-loop is disconnected from the core, while at 45 pN, interactions between $\beta4$ and $\beta5$ strands are broken.
  • Mutation Effect: The V61A mutation in SH3 shifts the pathway switch to lower forces, consistent with experimental observations and highlighting the landscape's malleability.
  • I27 Prediction: Based on their theory and observations in SH3, they predict that the titin I27 protein, which shows upward curvature in denaturant unfolding, will also exhibit a force-dependent pathway switch when unfolded by mechanical force.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The paper acknowledges that while the double-exponential model fits the data well, inferring the nature of the TSE from these fits is problematic for SMD landscapes.
  • The simulations use a coarse-grained model (SOP-SC), which may not capture all atomic-level details, although it reproduces the qualitative behavior of the $\log k_u(f)$ plot.
  • The denaturant perturbation is an approximation to linear coupling, whereas force is an exact linear coupling.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest experimental studies, such as Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments, to measure flux through different pathways and confirm their findings.
  • They propose blocking specific pathways (e.g., with disulfide bridges) to experimentally verify the role of different routes.
  • They explicitly predict a force-dependent pathway switch in the unfolding of titin I27 and its mutants, which can be tested with laser optical trapping experiments.
  • Further investigation into the "catch bond" behavior observed in some SMD landscapes is suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although it is known that single-domain proteins fold and unfold by parallel pathways, demonstration of this expectation has been difficult to establish in experiments. Unfolding rate, [Formula: see text], as a function of force f, obtained in single-molecule pulling experiments on src SH3 domain, exhibits upward curvature on a [Formula: see text] plot. Similar observations were reported for other proteins for the unfolding rate [Formula: see text]. These findings imply unfolding in these single-domain proteins involves a switch in the pathway as f or [Formula: see text] is increased from a low to a high value. We provide a unified theory demonstrating that if [Formula: see text] as a function of a perturbation (f or [Formula: see text]) exhibits upward curvature then the underlying energy landscape must be strongly multidimensional. Using molecular simulations we provide a structural basis for the switch in the pathways and dramatic shifts in the transition-state ensemble (TSE) in src SH3 domain as f is increased. We show that a single-point mutation shifts the upward curvature in [Formula: see text] to a lower force, thus establishing the malleability of the underlying folding landscape. Our theory, applicable to any perturbation that affects the free energy of the protein linearly, readily explains movement in the TSE in a β-sandwich (I27) protein and single-chain monellin as the denaturant concentration is varied. We predict that in the force range accessible in laser optical tweezer experiments there should be a switch in the unfolding pathways in I27 or its mutants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhuravlev2016force,
  author = {Pavel I. Zhuravlev and Michael Hinczewski and Shaon Chakrabarti and Susan Marqusee and D. Thirumalai},
  title = {{Force-dependent switch in protein unfolding pathways and transition-state movements}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1515730113},
}
Figure