Force and kinetic barriers to unzipping of the DNA double helix

Simona Cocco, Rémi Monasson, John F. MarkoProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2001 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

A theory of the unzipping of double-stranded DNA is presented and is compared to recent micromanipulation experiments. It is shown that the interactions that stabilize the double helix and the elastic rigidity of single strands simply determine the sequence-dependent approximately 12-pN force threshold for DNA strand separation. Using a semimicroscopic model of the binding between nucleotide strands, we show that the greater rigidity of the strands when formed into double-stranded DNA, relative to that of isolated strands, gives rise to a potential barrier to unzipping. The effects of this barrier are derived analytically. The force to keep the extremities of the molecule at a fixed distance, the kinetic rates for strand unpairing at fixed applied force, and the rupture force as a function of loading rate are calculated. The dependence of the kinetics and of the rupture force on molecule length is also analyzed.

Introduction: The Mechanics of DNA Separation

While it has been known for decades that DNA can be denatured by heat or chemicals, modern micromanipulation experiments—utilizing optical tweezers or atomic force microscopy (AFM)—allow researchers to pull the two strands apart mechanically. Standard thermodynamic models successfully predict the "equilibrium" unzipping force, which is the approximately 12 piconewtons (pN) required to maintain unzipping in a long DNA molecule.

However, these macroscopic models fail to explain the kinetics of the process: How does unzipping actually initiate? Why does it require significantly more force to start the break than to maintain it? This paper bridges the gap between the large-scale thermodynamics of the double helix and the microscopic physics of individual base pairs.

Methods and Modeling

The authors employ two distinct modeling layers to capture the physics of DNA unzipping. First, a Thermodynamic Equilibrium Model uses a "freely-jointed chain-like" (FJCL) model to describe the elasticity of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). This establishes the baseline energy balance between the bound (dsDNA) and unbound (ssDNA) states.

Second, a Semi-Microscopic Model introduces a position-dependent rigidity. In this continuum model, which results in a Schrödinger-like equation, the "mass" term represents the strand rigidity. Crucially, DNA strands are much stiffer when locked in a double helix than when they are free. The model uses a Morse potential to represent hydrogen bonding and stacking interactions, adding an "entropic potential" term that arises from the change in rigidity as the strands separate.

Overview of mechanical configurations for DNA manipulation: (A) unzipping, (B) unzipping with torque, (C) stretching, and (D) local bubble formation.

Datasets and Validation

As a theoretical physics study, this paper validates its model against several landmark single-molecule experimental datasets:

  • Essevaz-Roulet et al. (1997): Microneedle unzipping of $\lambda$-phage DNA.
  • Rief et al. (1999): AFM stretching of poly(dG-dC) and poly(dA-dT).
  • Bonnet et al. (1998): Fluorescence studies on the dissociation of short DNA hairpins.
  • Pörschke (1971): Classical kinetic data on oligonucleotide relaxation.

Key Insights: The Rigidity Barrier and Nucleation

The most striking finding is a massive force barrier of approximately 270 pN occurring at a sub-nanometer separation (about 0.5 Å beyond the equilibrium radius). This barrier exists because the strands must "give up" their structural rigidity before they can enjoy the entropic freedom of being single-stranded.

Unzipping does not happen all at once; it starts with a "nucleation bubble" of about four base pairs. Once this small section crosses the energy barrier, the rest of the molecule can unzip at the much lower 12 pN threshold. For short DNA sequences (oligomers < 20 bp), the time it takes to spontaneously dissociate depends exponentially on length. For long molecules, the unzipping rate becomes independent of total length, dominated by the local "opening fork" physics.

Comparison between end-initiated unzipping (A) and the formation of a local nucleation bubble (D).

Key Results

  • Initiation Force: The model predicts a peak force of ~270 pN to initiate unzipping at the sub-nanometer scale, decaying to the asymptotic value of ~12 pN for large separations.
  • Stability: At zero force, a 10 bp DNA segment has a lifetime of about 1 second, while a 30 bp segment is predicted to be stable for 30,000 years.
  • Phase Boundary: The authors mapped the "phase boundary" between dsDNA and ssDNA in the torque-force plane, demonstrating how twisting the DNA (torque) lowers the force required to unzip it.
  • Rupture Regimes: The model identifies three regimes of rupture: thermal dissociation at low loading rates, a length-dependent regime at moderate rates, and a plateau at the equilibrium unzipping force for high loading rates.

Limitations and Future Work

The model currently treats DNA as a "homopolymer" with average base-pair properties. In reality, the "stick-slip" motion caused by varying GC vs. AT content creates additional "roughness" in the energy landscape. Furthermore, the predicted 270 pN peak occurs at such a small distance scale that standard unzipping experiments (which use long, flexible linkers) cannot resolve it. Future AFM experiments using extremely stiff cantilevers and sub-angstrom precision are needed to confirm this initiation barrier.

Summary updated

Abstract

A theory of the unzipping of double-stranded DNA is presented and is compared to recent micromanipulation experiments. It is shown that the interactions that stabilize the double helix and the elastic rigidity of single strands simply determine the sequence-dependent approximately 12-pN force threshold for DNA strand separation. Using a semimicroscopic model of the binding between nucleotide strands, we show that the greater rigidity of the strands when formed into double-stranded DNA, relative to that of isolated strands, gives rise to a potential barrier to unzipping. The effects of this barrier are derived analytically. The force to keep the extremities of the molecule at a fixed distance, the kinetic rates for strand unpairing at fixed applied force, and the rupture force as a function of loading rate are calculated. The dependence of the kinetics and of the rupture force on molecule length is also analyzed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cocco2001force,
  author = {Simona Cocco and Rémi Monasson and John F. Marko},
  title = {{Force and kinetic barriers to unzipping of the DNA double helix}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.151257598},
}
Figure