Abstract
The cortical thickness is a characteristic biomarker for a wide variety of neurological disorders. While the structural organization of the cerebral cortex is tightly regulated and evolutionarily preserved, its thickness varies widely between 1.5 and 4.5 mm across the healthy adult human brain. It remains unclear whether these thickness variations are a cause or consequence of cortical development. Recent studies suggest that cortical thickness variations are primarily a result of genetic effects. Previous studies showed that a simple homogeneous bilayered system with a growing layer on an elastic substrate undergoes a unique symmetry breaking into a spatially heterogeneous system with discrete gyri and sulci. Here, we expand on that work to explore the evolution of cortical thickness variations over time to support our finding that cortical pattern formation and thickness variations can be explained - at least in part - by the physical forces that emerge during cortical folding. Strikingly, as growth progresses, the developing gyri universally thicken and the sulci thin, even in the complete absence of regional information. Using magnetic resonance images, we demonstrate that these naturally emerging thickness variations agree with the cortical folding pattern in $n = 9$ healthy adult human brains, in $n = 564$ healthy human brains ages 7-64, and in $n = 73$ infant brains scanned at birth, and at ages one and two. Additionally, we show that cortical organoids develop similar patterns throughout their growth. Our results suggest that genetic, geometric, and physical events during brain development are closely interrelated. Understanding regional and temporal variations in cortical thickness can provide insight into the evolution and causative factors of neurological disorders, inform the diagnosis of neurological conditions, and assess the efficacy of treatment options.
Introduction
The human cerebral cortex is a folded sheet of gray matter with a thickness that varies significantly, ranging from 1.5 mm to 4.5 mm. These variations are not random; they serve as critical biomarkers for disorders like autism, schizophrenia, and epilepsy. For decades, the prevailing view in developmental biology was that these thickness patterns were primarily dictated by a "genetic blueprint." However, a fundamental question remained: are these variations a cause or a consequence of brain development? This study investigates whether the physical forces generated during the folding process (gyrification) are sufficient to explain why gyri thicken and sulci thin, even without specific regional genetic instructions.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-modal approach to bridge the gap between theoretical physics and clinical neurology:
- Analytical Modeling: Using morphoelasticity to model a bilayered system (a growing "cortex" on an elastic "white matter" substrate), applying linear stability analysis to predict thickness changes at the onset of folding.
- Computational Simulation: Finite Element Analysis (FEA) was used to simulate non-linear cortical growth, tracking "period doubling" and thickness changes throughout the process.
- Polymer Experiments: Physical models were created using silicone rubbers of varying stiffness. Prestretching and releasing the substrate induced folding in the top layer, allowing for direct measurement of thickness variations.
- Biological Observation: Fluorescent imaging of human brain organoids and longitudinal MRI scans of human infants and adults were used to validate the mechanical models against living systems.
Datasets
The study utilized several distinct datasets to ensure findings were robust across scales and ages:
- Healthy Adults: MRI scans from $n=9$ local participants and a large-scale public dataset of $n=564$ healthy human brains (ages 7–64).
- Infant Longitudinal Study: MRI scans of $n=73$ healthy infants, tracked at birth, age one, and age two, to observe the evolution of thickness over time.
- Organoid Data: Fluorescence images of human brain organoids "on a chip" to observe early-stage folding in a controlled biological environment.
Key Insights: The Universal Pattern of Folding
A central finding of this work is that a perfectly homogeneous, uniform layer will naturally become heterogeneous once it starts to fold. Mechanical instability acts as a "symmetry breaker," forcing the material to redistribute.
Across every model—mathematical, silicone, organoid, and human—the result was consistent: gyri universally thicken, and sulci universally thin. This suggests that while genetics may set the stage, physics is a primary driver in shaping the final geometry. Furthermore, the thickness difference is not static; as growth progresses and folds become more complex, the ratio between gyral and sulcal thickness increases.
Key Results
The study confirmed that mechanical forces alone can drive the characteristic variations observed in the human brain:
- Adult Brains: In the $n=564$ dataset, the average gyral thickness (2.87 mm) was significantly larger than the sulcal thickness (2.47 mm), with a consistent ratio of approximately 1.16.
- Infant Development: At birth, the thickness ratio is relatively low. However, as folding intensifies, the temporal and frontal cortices thicken rapidly, approaching adult-like ratios by age one.
- Model Agreement: Computational and polymer models successfully predicted the thinning of sulci to less than 65% of their initial value during advanced folding, matching observations in highly folded human brain regions.
Discussion and Future Work
While the mechanical model is powerful, MRI remains a proxy for true histological thickness, and tissue contrast in neonatal scans presents technical challenges. Current models also assume isotropic growth, whereas real development involves complex, regionally varying biological processes. Future research could integrate these mechanical models with transcriptomic data to explore how physical stress influences gene expression. Applying these models to clinical cases may help in the early detection of "mechanical" abnormalities in cortical thickness, potentially improving the diagnosis of conditions like focal cortical dysplasia.
Summary updated