FOCUSING ON FILIAL PIETY: A SCOPING REVIEW STUDY FROM CULTURAL DIFFERENCES TO EDUCATIONAL PRACTICES

Yan Wang, Muhammad Daoh, Nur Muneerah Kasim, Lim Seong PekQuantum 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This scoping review re-evaluates filial piety not as an outdated relic of "blind obedience," but as a dynamic, two-dimensional psychological construct—Reciprocal vs. Authoritarian—that continues to shape family dynamics, mental health, and workplace behavior globally. By synthesizing recent literature (2020–2024), the authors highlight how modern filial piety is evolving to balance traditional duties with contemporary values of autonomy and individualism.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many Western contexts, "filial piety" is often dismissed as a monolithic, strictly Asian concept centered on hierarchy. However, as global populations age, the "sandwich generation" faces increasing pressure to care for elderly parents while navigating modern career demands.

The authors address a significant gap in the literature: the lack of a unified understanding of how filial piety manifests across different cultures and how it translates into educational and social practices today. They challenge the idea that filial piety is static, arguing instead that it is a "contextualized personality trait" that adapts to societal shifts, migration, and generational changes.

Methods

The researchers conducted a scoping review following the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses for Scoping Reviews) guidelines.

Key methodological steps included:

  • PCC Framework: Defining the scope based on Population (families), Concept (filial piety), and Context (cultural differences to educational practices).
  • Systematic Search: Querying three major databases—Web of Science (WOS), Education Resources Information Center (ERIC), and China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI).
  • Synthesis: Categorizing findings into qualitative and quantitative buckets to map out the current state of the field.

Datasets

As a scoping review, the "dataset" consists of existing peer-reviewed literature rather than raw experimental data.

  • Initial Pool: 100 articles identified.
  • Final Selection: 13 studies published between 2020 and 2024.
  • Geographic Diversity: While centered on Chinese and Overseas Chinese populations, the included studies covered the Netherlands, Vietnam, Indonesia, USA, Poland, Denmark, and China.

Key Insights and Ideas

The paper’s most critical contribution is the emphasis on the Dual Filial Piety Model (DFPM), which splits the concept into two distinct dimensions:

  • Reciprocal Filial Piety (RFP): Driven by genuine affection, gratitude, and a desire to repay care. It is associated with positive mental health, higher life satisfaction, and better parent-child intimacy.
  • Authoritarian Filial Piety (AFP): Driven by hierarchy, social obligation, and obedience. While it ensures care, it is often linked to higher psychological stress, lower self-esteem, and "maladaptation" in modern, individualistic environments.

Other "Aha!" Moments: * Universal Construct, Cultural "Skin": While the manifestation of filial piety varies (e.g., the Bible’s "Honor thy father and mother" vs. Confucian xiao), the underlying psychological motives for intergenerational care are surprisingly universal. * Workplace Impact: Filial piety isn't just for the home. In collectivist cultures, AFP can actually predict job satisfaction and turnover intention, suggesting that family-centric values bleed into professional identity. * The "Autonomy" Balance: Modern filial piety education is shifting away from "self-sacrifice" toward "harmony," where children learn to care for parents without losing their personal freedom or identity.

Key Results

  • Quantitative vs. Qualitative: Of the 13 studies, 7 were quantitative (focusing on scale validation like the Dual Filial Piety Scale) and 6 were qualitative (interviews and observations).
  • Cultural Comparisons: One study found that while Asian Americans score higher on AFP than Caucasian Americans, there was no significant difference in RFP between the two groups. This suggests that the "affectionate" side of filial piety is a cross-cultural constant.
  • Mental Health: In a study of Chinese women, filial piety acted as both a risk and a protective factor for suicidal behavior, depending on whether the individual felt they were successfully fulfilling family role obligations.
  • Predictive Power: RFP was found to be a stronger predictor of volunteerism and empathy in adolescents than AFP.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Sample Size: Only 13 studies met the strict inclusion criteria, limiting the ability to make broad generalizations.
  • Geographic Bias: Despite some international reach, the literature remains heavily weighted toward East Asian contexts.
  • Need for Longitudinal Data: Most current research is cross-sectional. The authors call for longitudinal studies to see how filial piety beliefs change as an individual moves from being a child to a caregiver to an elderly parent themselves.
  • Educational Implementation: While the paper advocates for "filial piety education," there is still a lack of concrete, tested curricula for how to teach these values in a way that respects modern autonomy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Filial piety, a foundational virtue deeply rooted in human history, remains a culturally significant yet often underappreciated concept in contemporary discourse. This study examines the practices and support mechanisms of filial piety within Chinese and overseas Chinese families, emphasizing its multifaceted nature. Grounded in the dual filial piety model, the research distinguishes between reciprocal filial piety, characterized by mutual care and emotional bonds; and authoritarian filial piety, which emphasizes obedience and hierarchical family roles. Findings reveal that filial piety norms are dynamic, evolving alongside societal, cultural, and generational shifts. While filial piety fosters family cohesion, intergenerational support, and emotional fulfillment, it may also impose psychological burdens or conflict with modern values of individualism and autonomy. Striking a balance between upholding filial duties and respecting personal freedom emerges as a critical challenge. Methodologically, this scoping review adheres to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR) guidelines. Three databases: Web of Science (WOS), Education Resources Information Center (ERIC), and China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI); were systematically searched to identify relevant literature. After screening, 13 studies met the inclusion criteria, offering insights into filial piety’s diverse manifestations and impacts. The review underscores the need for culturally sensitive approaches to filial piety, advocating for policies and educational initiatives that harmonize traditional values with contemporary lifestyles. Further research should explore cross-cultural comparisons and longitudinal effects on family well-being.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2025focusing,
  author = {Yan Wang and Muhammad Daoh and Nur Muneerah Kasim and LIM SEONG PEK},
  title = {{FOCUSING ON FILIAL PIETY: A SCOPING REVIEW STUDY FROM CULTURAL DIFFERENCES TO EDUCATIONAL PRACTICES}},
  booktitle = {Quantum},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.55197/qjssh.v6i3.561},
}
Figure