Focality-Oriented Selection of Current Dose for Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation

Rajan Kashyap, Sagarika Bhattacharjee, Ramaswamy Arumugam, Rose Dawn Bharath, Kaviraja Udupa, Kenichi Oishi, John E. Desmond, Shen‐Hsing Annabel Chen, Cuntai GuanJournal of Personalized Medicine 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new metric, the Dose-Target Determination Index (DTDI), to quantify how precisely transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) targets a specific brain region while minimizing current spread to others. They demonstrate that DTDI is crucial for optimizing tDCS, especially in older adults and males, suggesting personalized current doses based on age and sex are necessary for effective stimulation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is a promising non-invasive brain stimulation technique used to treat various neurological and psychiatric disorders. However, a major challenge is that the electrical current injected into the brain doesn't stay confined to the intended target region of interest (ROI). Instead, it spreads out, potentially stimulating unintended areas and reducing the effectiveness at the target. This "focality" problem makes it difficult to determine the optimal current dose for an individual, as a higher dose might not necessarily lead to better stimulation of the target ROI and could even increase stimulation in unwanted areas. Previous approaches often assumed a linear relationship between current dose and electric field intensity, which may not hold true for all individuals, particularly as they age.

Methods

The researchers extended their previously developed i-SATA (Systematic Approach for tDCS Analysis) toolbox to work within the MNI (Montreal Neurological Institute) reference space, creating i-SATA(MNI). This allows for the analysis of current density distribution across brain regions in a standardized anatomical space.

The core of their method involves:

  1. Realistic Simulation: Using the ROAST (Realistic Volumetric Approach-based Simulator for Transcranial Electric Stimulation) toolbox, they simulated tDCS montages (electrode placements) on individual brain MRIs.
  2. Current Density Calculation: i-SATA(MNI) then processed these simulations to calculate the average current density within each brain region (ROI).
  3. DTDI Calculation: They introduced the Dose-Target Determination Index (DTDI). DTDI is calculated as the ratio of the average current density in the target ROI to the average current density in the brain region with the highest current density. A DTDI close to 1 indicates high focality (target ROI receives the most current), while a DTDI close to 0 indicates poor focality.
  4. Statistical Analysis: They performed a three-way mixed ANOVA to analyze the variation in DTDI across different current doses (1, 2, and 3 mA), age groups (young, mid, and older adults), and sexes.

Datasets

The study utilized T1-weighted magnetic resonance images (MRIs) from 90 healthy individuals (45 males and 45 females) recruited from the Cambridge Centre for Ageing and Neuroscience (Cam-CAN) study. These participants were divided into three age groups:

  • Young adults (20 ≤ x < 40 years)
  • Mid adults (40 ≤ x < 60 years)
  • Older adults (60 ≤ x < 80 years)

Each age group consisted of 15 males and 15 females. The dataset was chosen to allow for the evaluation of age and sex differences in tDCS focality.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Focality is Key: The paper strongly emphasizes that simply increasing the tDCS current dose doesn't guarantee better stimulation of the target ROI. Focality—how well the current is confined to the target—is a critical factor.
  • DTDI as a Universal Metric: The DTDI offers a standardized, objective way to quantify tDCS focality, making it easier to compare results across individuals and studies.
  • Age Matters Significantly: The study reveals a clear trend of decreasing focality with increasing age, particularly in individuals over 40. This suggests that older brains may be more susceptible to current spread.
  • Sex Differences Emerge: Males, especially older males, showed a more pronounced decrease in focality compared to females.
  • Non-Linearity in Older Adults: Unlike younger individuals where current distribution might be more linear, older adults exhibit a more non-linear relationship between current dose and current density distribution, making them more sensitive to dose selection.
  • Higher Doses Can Help Older Adults: Counterintuitively, for older adults, a higher current dose (e.g., 3 mA) might actually enhance focality, suggesting a need for tailored dosing strategies.

Key Results

  • The i-SATA(MNI) toolbox successfully extended tDCS current density analysis to the MNI reference space.
  • For a standard head model and young/mid-adults, DTDI remained relatively constant across different current doses (1-3 mA), indicating a linear relationship.
  • However, in older adults, DTDI showed significant variations with current dose, often decreasing as the dose increased, indicating reduced focality.
  • Statistical analysis (three-way mixed ANOVA) confirmed significant main effects of age and sex on DTDI, as well as a significant interaction between age and dose.
  • Specifically, older adults (≥ 40 years) showed significantly lower DTDI values compared to younger adults.
  • Post-hoc analysis revealed that in older adults, increasing the current dose from 1 mA to 3 mA significantly increased DTDI (improved focality) for both males and females.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the findings on the relationship between tDCS dose, sex, and age might be limited by the relatively small sample size (90 participants).
  • Biomarker for Nonlinearity: They suggest that future research should focus on identifying biomarkers that can predict which individuals will exhibit a nonlinear response to tDCS, allowing for even more precise dose selection before stimulation.
  • Factors Contributing to Hotspots: The paper notes that the exact neuroanatomical factors contributing to "hotspots" (areas where current clusters) are not fully understood and warrant further investigation, especially in aging brains.
  • Generalizability: While the study used a specific frontal montage (F3-RSO), future work could explore other montages and target ROIs to further validate the DTDI.
  • Clinical Validation: While the DTDI provides a computational estimate, further clinical studies are needed to directly correlate DTDI-guided dose selection with actual therapeutic outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Background:</b> In transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), the injected current becomes distributed across the brain areas. The objective is to stimulate the target region of interest (ROI) while minimizing the current in non-target ROIs (the 'focality' of tDCS). For this purpose, determining the appropriate current dose for an individual is difficult. <b>Aim:</b> To introduce a dose-target determination index (DTDI) to quantify the focality of tDCS and examine the dose-focality relationship in three different populations. <b>Method:</b> Here, we extended our previous toolbox i-SATA to the MNI reference space. After a tDCS montage is simulated for a current dose, the i-SATA(MNI) computes the average (over voxels) current density for every region in the brain. DTDI is the ratio of the average current density at the target ROI to the ROI with a maximum value (the peak region). Ideally, target ROI should be the peak region, so DTDI shall range from 0 to 1. The higher the value, the better the dose. We estimated the variation of DTDI within and across individuals using T1-weighted brain images of 45 males and females distributed equally across three age groups: (a) young adults (20 ≤ x ˂ 40 years), (b) mid adults (40 ≤ x ˂ 60 years), and (c) older adults (60 ≤ x ˂ 80 years). DTDI's were evaluated for the frontal montage with electrodes at F3 and the right supraorbital for three current doses of 1 mA, 2 mA, and 3 mA, with the target ROI at the left middle frontal gyrus. <b>Result:</b> As the dose is incremented, DTDI may show (a) increase, (b) decrease, and (c) no change across the individuals depending on the relationship (nonlinear or linear) between the injected tDCS current and the distribution of current density in the target ROI. The nonlinearity is predominant in older adults with a decrease in focality. The decline is stronger in males. Higher current dose at older age can enhance the focality of stimulation. <b>Conclusion:</b> DTDI provides information on which tDCS current dose will optimize the focality of stimulation. The recommended DTDI dose should be prioritized based on the age (>40 years) and sex (especially for males) of an individual. The toolbox i-SATA(MNI) is freely available.
BibTeX
@article{kashyap2021focality,
  author = {Rajan Kashyap and Sagarika Bhattacharjee and Ramaswamy Arumugam and Rose Dawn Bharath and Kaviraja Udupa and Kenichi Oishi and John E. Desmond and Shen‐Hsing Annabel Chen and Cuntai Guan},
  title = {{Focality-Oriented Selection of Current Dose for Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation}},
  journal = {Journal of Personalized Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jpm11090940},
}
Figure