Flying Into the Wind: Insects and Bio-Inspired Micro-Air-Vehicles With a Wing-Stroke Dihedral Steer Passively Into Wind-Gusts

Diana A. Olejnik, Florian T. Muijres, Matej Karásek, Leonardo Honfi Camilo, Christophe De Wagter, Guido C. H. E. de CroonFrontiers Robotics AI 2022 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

Insects can fly through windy conditions with remarkable agility, a feat this paper attributes to a passive aerodynamic mechanism: wing-stroke dihedral. By combining CFD simulations of fruit flies with experiments on a bio-inspired flapping robot, the researchers demonstrate how this dihedral angle passively steers flyers into wind gusts, enhancing stability and robustness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tiny flying insects navigate a world filled with unpredictable wind gusts, which can exert significant forces and torques on their small bodies, leading to large accelerations. While insects possess sophisticated active control systems, this paper investigates whether they also leverage passive stabilization mechanisms to cope with these challenging conditions. Specifically, the authors explore if a particular wing-beat characteristic, the "wing-stroke dihedral," plays a role in passively steering insects into wind gusts, similar to how a boat might naturally orient itself into a current. Understanding this could lead to more robust and stable flapping-wing micro-air vehicles (MAVs).

Methods

The study employs a multi-pronged approach:

  • Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): The researchers used CFD simulations to model the airflow around fruit flies flying in sideways wind conditions. They systematically varied parameters like sideways speed and wing-stroke dihedral angle to analyze the resulting aerodynamic forces and torques.
  • Robotic Experiments: A bio-inspired, tailless flapping-wing MAV, the DelFly Nimble, was modified with a mass displacement mechanism to alter its center of mass. This allowed for the introduction of a positive wing-stroke dihedral, mimicking the insect behavior. Free-flight tests were conducted in a controlled wind tunnel to observe the robot's response to various wind speeds and configurations.
  • Aerodynamic Modeling: Based on the CFD and experimental results, the authors developed simplified mathematical models to describe the pitch, yaw, and roll torques generated by the interaction of wing-stroke dihedral, sideways speed, and aerodynamic forces.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on CFD simulations and experimental data collected by the authors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wing-Stroke Dihedral as a Passive Stabilizer: The core insight is that a positive wing-stroke dihedral, a slight upward angle of the wings during the stroke, acts as a passive mechanism to steer flying objects into wind gusts. This is a crucial finding for understanding insect flight and designing more stable MAVs.
  • Yaw Torque Generation: The interaction between sideways wind speed and wing-stroke dihedral generates a passive yaw torque that consistently steers the flyer into the wind. This effect is more pronounced with a larger dihedral angle.
  • Roll Torque Dynamics: Roll torques are more complex, exhibiting non-linear behavior with wind speed. At low speeds, they can be destabilizing, causing the flyer to roll away from the wind. However, at higher speeds, these torques become stabilizing, rolling the flyer into the wind.
  • Trade-off Between Maneuverability and Stability: The study suggests a potential trade-off in insects between maneuverability and gust-rejection capabilities. Highly maneuverable insects like hoverflies might sacrifice some gust-rejection ability for agility.
  • Bio-Inspired Design for MAVs: The research demonstrates that introducing a positive stroke dihedral, potentially through mass asymmetry (like a rearward abdomen), can significantly enhance the passive stability of flapping-wing MAVs in windy conditions.

Key Results

  • CFD Simulations: Showed that body pitch torques scale nearly linearly with stroke dihedral. In sideways flight, roll and yaw torques increased with sideways speed, while pitch torques were less affected.
  • Aerodynamic Models: The developed models accurately captured the observed pitch, roll, and yaw torque dynamics, with high R² values (e.g., R² = 0.994 for pitch, 0.865 for yaw, 0.927 for roll).
  • Robotic Experiments:
    • A symmetrical robot without yaw control was highly susceptible to wind gusts, drifting and oscillating.
  • Introducing a backward mass displacement (creating a positive dihedral) significantly improved stability.
  • With a 4 cm mass displacement, the robot could achieve a stable forward flight into a 1.5 m/s wind gust within 2 seconds, compared to 30 seconds for the symmetrical configuration.
  • The 4 cm displacement configuration also showed the lowest power consumption, suggesting increased efficiency due to improved lift.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simplified Models: The authors acknowledge that their simplified models for torque dynamics ignore some higher-order dynamics.
  • Experimental Constraints: The robotic experiments were conducted with a limited number of configurations and wind speeds due to practical constraints.
  • Over-compensation and Overturning: While the study focuses on stabilization, the authors note that precise tuning of flight platform design is still required to avoid over-compensation and potential overturning, especially with active control systems.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the risk of overturning and its dependence on flight platform design. They also propose exploring adjustable mass-shift systems for MAVs to dynamically switch between stable and maneuverable modes. Additionally, a more extensive experimental campaign is needed to establish precision and uncertainty bounds.

Summary updated

Abstract

Natural fliers utilize passive and active flight control strategies to cope with windy conditions. This capability makes them incredibly agile and resistant to wind gusts. Here, we study how insects achieve this, by combining Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) analyses of flying fruit flies with freely-flying robotic experiments. The CFD analysis shows that flying flies are partly passively stable in side-wind conditions due to their dorsal-ventral wing-beat asymmetry defined as wing-stroke dihedral. Our robotic experiments confirm that this mechanism also stabilizes free-moving flapping robots with similar asymmetric dihedral wing-beats. This shows that both animals and robots with asymmetric wing-beats are dynamically stable in sideways wind gusts. Based on these results, we developed an improved model for the aerodynamic yaw and roll torques caused by the coupling between lateral motion and the stroke dihedral. The yaw coupling passively steers an asymmetric flapping flyer into the direction of a sideways wind gust; in contrast, roll torques are only stabilizing at high air gust velocities, due to non-linear coupling effects. The combined CFD simulations, robot experiments, and stability modeling help explain why the majority of flying insects exhibit wing-beats with positive stroke dihedral and can be used to develop more stable and robust flapping-wing Micro-Air-Vehicles.
BibTeX
@article{olejnik2022flying,
  author = {Diana A. Olejnik and Florian T. Muijres and Matej Karásek and Leonardo Honfi Camilo and Christophe De Wagter and Guido C. H. E. de Croon},
  title = {{Flying Into the Wind: Insects and Bio-Inspired Micro-Air-Vehicles With a Wing-Stroke Dihedral Steer Passively Into Wind-Gusts}},
  journal = {Frontiers Robotics AI},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/frobt.2022.820363},
}
Figure