Fluorosubstitution of the Molecular Core in Chiral Esters with Short Terminal Carbon Chains: Influence on Physical Properties

Aleksandra Deptuch, Marcin Piwowarczyk, Małgorzata Jasiurkowska-Delaporte, Jung-Eun Kim, Magdalena Urbańska, Maciej Skolarczyk, T. Jaworska–Gołąb, Monika MarzecCrystals 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how adding fluorine atoms to the core structure of chiral liquid crystals affects their physical properties. Researchers found that fluorination influences phase transition temperatures, slows down molecular dynamics in certain phases, and can even facilitate crystallization, offering insights for designing new liquid crystal materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Chiral liquid crystals (LCs) are crucial for advanced display technologies, particularly those requiring bistable or tristable switching for greyscale capabilities. Antiferroelectric smectic C (SmCA) phases are highly desirable for this, but their precise alignment and behavior can be tricky. Modifying the molecular structure of these LCs is a key strategy to fine-tune their properties. This paper specifically addresses how introducing fluorine atoms into the rigid core of chiral LC molecules, compared to their non-fluorinated counterparts, impacts their structural, electro-optic, and dielectric characteristics, as well as their solid-state behavior (polymorphism and crystallization). Understanding these structure-property relationships is vital for designing LCs with optimized performance for next-generation displays.

Methods

The researchers employed a comprehensive suite of experimental techniques to characterize the liquid crystalline compounds 4HH (non-fluorinated) and 4FF (difluorinated). These included:

  • Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC): To identify phase transitions and measure their associated enthalpy changes.
  • Polarizing Optical Microscopy (POM): To visualize the textures of different LC phases and observe phase transitions, often coupled with electro-optic measurements.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To determine structural parameters like smectic layer spacing and unit cell dimensions of crystal phases.
  • Simultaneous XRD-DSC: A powerful technique combining XRD and DSC to study phase transitions and structural changes concurrently, especially useful for investigating metastable phases.
  • Frequency Domain Dielectric Spectroscopy (FDDS): To probe molecular dynamics and relaxation processes within the LC phases.
  • Electro-optic measurements: To determine parameters like tilt angle, spontaneous polarization, and switching times.

The study also utilized specialized analysis software (e.g., TOApy for POM image analysis) and standard crystallographic data analysis tools.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fluorine's Impact on Phase Transitions: The introduction of fluorine atoms significantly alters phase transition temperatures. Specifically, the clearing point (transition to the isotropic liquid phase) and the SmC* to SmCA transition occur at lower temperatures in the fluorinated compound (4FF) compared to its non-fluorinated analog (4HH).
  • Facilitated Crystallization: Fluorosubstitution appears to promote crystallization. 4FF exhibits a richer polymorphism in the solid state and its crystallization process is more straightforward compared to 4HH, which shows evidence of a monotropic hexatic SmXA phase and more complex cold crystallization behavior.
  • Slowing Down Molecular Dynamics: The fluorinated compound (4FF) exhibits slower dynamics for certain collective molecular motions, specifically the Goldstone mode in the SmC* phase and the PH phason in the SmCA phase. This is evidenced by lower frequencies observed in dielectric spectroscopy.
  • Structural Differences in Crystal Phases: While both compounds exhibit polymorphism in the solid state, the unit cell parameters reveal distinct crystal structures for 4HH and 4FF, indicating that fluorination leads to significant structural rearrangements in the solid phase.
  • Correlation between Crystallization and Dynamics: The faster crystallization in 4FF is hypothesized to correlate with the lower frequency of the PH process, suggesting a link between molecular dynamics and crystallization kinetics.

Key Results

  • Phase Transition Temperatures: Iso → SmC transition for 4HH is at 130.4 °C, while for 4FF it's at 115.7 °C. SmC → SmCA transition for 4HH is at 104.8 °C, and for 4FF it's at 92.8 °C.
  • Crystallization: 4HH exhibits a monotropic SmXA phase on cooling, which is absent in 4FF. 4FF shows a more complex crystal phase sequence (Cr4, Cr3, Cr2, Cr1) compared to 4HH (Cr2, Cr1).
  • Electro-optic Properties: The tilt angle is slightly lower in 4FF (around 41°) compared to 4HH (around 43.5°). Spontaneous polarization is also generally lower in 4FF.
  • Dielectric Properties: The Goldstone mode and PH phason frequencies are lower for 4FF than for 4HH.
  • Crystal Structure: Unit cell parameters for the crystal phases of 4HH and 4FF were determined, revealing differences in their crystal packing.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Crystal Structure Determination: While unit cell parameters were determined, the full crystal structures of all phases were not solved, limiting a complete understanding of molecular packing.
  • Metastable Phases: The study identified several metastable crystal phases, particularly in 4FF, which are only observed under specific (fast) cooling/heating conditions. Further investigation into the precise nature and stability of these phases could be beneficial.
  • Intra-molecular Vibrations: The authors suggest that intra-molecular vibrations might play a role in crystallization kinetics and propose studying this further using FT-IR spectroscopy on related compounds.
  • Correlation with Other Compounds: The paper hints at broader trends by comparing findings to other similar compounds and suggests future work to analyze a series of compounds with varying fluorination and chain lengths to solidify these correlations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Comparative study of chiral liquid crystalline (S)-(1)-4’-(1-methylheptylcarbonyl) biphenyl-4-yl 4-[4-(2,2,3,3,4,4,4-heptafluorobutoxy)butyl-1-oxy] benzoate (4HH) and (S)-4’-(1-methylheptyloxycarbonyl)biphenyl-4-yl 4-[4-(2,2,3,3,4,4,4-heptafluorobutoxy) butyl-1-oxy]-2,3-difluorobenzoate (4FF) is performed by complementary methods. For 4HH melting of the low-temperature crystal phase and subsequent cold crystallization (from antiferroelectric smectic CA* phase to the high-temperature crystal phase) are reported, crystallization kinetics is examined and a monotropic hexatic SmXA* phase is observed on cooling. For 4FF rich polymorphism in the solid state is investigated mainly by simultaneous X-ray diffraction and differential scanning calorimetry measurements. Influence of fluorosubstitution on structural, electro-optic and dielectric properties of the smectic phases is reported. Unit cell parameters of crystal phases of 4HH and 4FF are determined. The reported results show that the double fluorosubstitution slows down the Goldstone mode and PH phason in the smectic phases and facilitates crystallization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{deptuch2022fluorosubstitution,
  author = {Aleksandra Deptuch and Marcin Piwowarczyk and Małgorzata Jasiurkowska-Delaporte and Jung-Eun Kim and Magdalena Urbańska and Maciej Skolarczyk and T. Jaworska–Gołąb and Monika Marzec},
  title = {{Fluorosubstitution of the Molecular Core in Chiral Esters with Short Terminal Carbon Chains: Influence on Physical Properties}},
  booktitle = {Crystals},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/cryst12081028},
}
Figure