Fluid Accumulation Prevention Method in Gas Wellbore Based on Drift Model

Yijie Hu, Xue-lei Hao, Lei Zhong, Chao Zhang, Jie ZhengProcesses 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel drift model-based approach to predict the critical gas velocity needed to prevent liquid loading in inclined gas wellbores. By accurately modeling gas-liquid interactions and flow dynamics, their method significantly improves prediction accuracy compared to existing models, offering a more reliable tool for optimizing gas production and preventing costly downtime.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the later stages of natural gas extraction, especially from low-permeability fields like shale and tight gas, a common and significant problem is "wellbore liquid loading." This occurs when free water and condensed hydrocarbons accumulate in the wellbore, hindering normal gas production. Initially, high gas flow rates can carry these liquids to the surface, but as pressure drops and production declines, the gas loses its ability to lift the liquids. This accumulation can lead to reduced flow, increased operational costs, and even well shut-in. Accurately predicting when this liquid loading will occur is crucial for implementing timely preventive measures. Existing models often struggle with the complex gas-liquid two-phase flow dynamics, particularly in inclined wellbores where gravity plays a more significant role.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of a new gas critical liquid-carrying velocity model. The authors establish the criterion for critical liquid-carrying as the point where the shear stress between the liquid film and the pipe wall becomes zero. This signifies the transition from liquid being carried upwards to potentially falling back.

Their model builds upon the "drift model," which accounts for the relative velocity between gas and liquid phases, the void fraction (porosity), and the distribution of velocities across the wellbore's cross-section. They achieve this by:

  • Momentum Balance Equations: Developing equations that describe the forces acting on both the gas core and the liquid film within the inclined wellbore.
  • Geometric Relationships: Defining how the gas and liquid phases are distributed geometrically within the pipe, considering liquid film thickness and pipe diameter.
  • Shear Stress Calculation: Incorporating interfacial shear stress between the gas and liquid, and shear stress between the liquid and the pipe wall.
  • Liquid Droplet Entrainment: Accounting for how liquid breaks into droplets and gets carried by the gas flow, using Wallis's correlation.
  • Porosity and Drift Velocity: Utilizing the drift model framework to define porosity and drift velocity, which are critical for characterizing flow patterns in inclined wells. They fit empirical parameters for these based on experimental data.

Datasets

The paper uses field data to validate its proposed model. While specific details about the dataset's origin or size are not explicitly enumerated as a "dataset," the authors state that field data were used to compare their model against four existing liquid-loading prediction models. They also refer to data from previous studies ([26-29]) for comparative analysis and error evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Zero Shear Stress as the Critical Point: Identifying the zero shear stress between the liquid film and the pipe wall as the definitive criterion for critical liquid-carrying is a key conceptual advancement. This provides a more precise physical basis for predicting liquid loading onset.
  • Drift Model for Inclined Wells: Adapting and extending the drift model to specifically address the complexities of inclined wellbores is crucial. The paper highlights how gravity's influence in inclined sections necessitates a more nuanced approach than models designed for vertical wells.
  • Integrated Approach: The model's strength lies in its integration of multiple factors: relative phase velocities, porosity, velocity distribution, and interfacial shear. This holistic view captures the complex interplay of forces that determine liquid transport.
  • Improved Accuracy and Stability: The proposed model demonstrates superior accuracy and stability compared to existing methods, as evidenced by lower misjudgment rates and errors. This suggests it's more reliable for real-world applications.

Key Results

The proposed model was compared against four existing liquid-loading prediction models using field data. The evaluation metrics were:

  • Misjudgment Rate: The proposed model achieved a misjudgment rate of 2.99%.
  • Mean Relative Percentage Error (MRPE): The proposed model had an MRPE of 3.83%.
  • Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE): The proposed model achieved a MAPE of 4.12%.

These figures are presented as being significantly better than the other models tested, with the paper stating the proposed model "outperforms others." Figure 7 further illustrates this, showing the proposed model with the lowest Average Percentage Error (APE) and Average Absolute Percentage Error (AAPE) among the compared models.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Simplified Gas-Liquid Mechanism: The model primarily considers the basic gas-liquid two-phase flow mechanism. It doesn't fully account for other factors that can influence liquid accumulation, such as gas quality variations, temperature fluctuations, and pipeline wear.
  • Limited Field Data: The field data used for validation is limited to a specific type of gas field. The generalization ability of the model to other types of gas fields or extreme conditions needs further verification.
  • Data Uncertainty: In practical applications, uncertainties in input data and model assumptions can affect the accuracy and stability of numerical calculations.

For future work, the authors suggest:

  • Incorporating More Complex Factors: Developing more comprehensive models that include a wider range of factors like varying gas compositions, changing liquid properties, and detailed temperature/pressure distributions within the wellbore.
  • Dynamic Prediction Models: Exploring dynamic prediction models that utilize real-time data and machine learning to adapt to changing wellbore conditions.
  • Expanding Data Collection: Conducting experiments and collecting data from a broader range of gas fields, development stages, and operating conditions to enhance the model's universality and accuracy.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wellbore liquid loading is a major issue in the later stages of gas well development, particularly for low-permeability gas fields such as shale gas and tight gas, severely affecting the normal production of gas wells. Accurately predicting the onset of wellbore liquid loading and implementing preventive measures are crucial for ensuring the normal production of gas fields. Therefore, based on the gas–liquid-carrying mechanism in gas wellbores and the flow patterns of gas–liquid two-phase flow in inclined wells, the criterion for gas critical liquid-carrying is determined by the shear stress between the liquid film and the pipe wall being zero. By considering the relative velocity between gas and liquid phases, porosity, and the distribution of velocity across the cross-section through the gas–liquid momentum balance equations, a gas critical liquid-carrying velocity model based on the drift model is established. Field data are used to compare the proposed model with four existing liquid-loading prediction models using the misjudgment rate, mean relative percentage error, and mean absolute percentage error as evaluation metrics for model accuracy. The results show that the proposed model outperforms the other models, with a misjudgment rate of 2.99%, mean relative percentage error of 3.83%, and mean absolute percentage error of 4.12%.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2025fluid,
  author = {Yijie Hu and Xue-lei Hao and Lei Zhong and Chao Zhang and Jie Zheng},
  title = {{Fluid Accumulation Prevention Method in Gas Wellbore Based on Drift Model}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/pr13113456},
}
Figure