Flow regimes and types of solid obstacle surface roughness in turbulent heat transfer inside periodic porous media

Vishal Srikanth, Dylan Peverall, Andrey KuznetsovarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The focus of this paper is to systematically study the influence of solid obstacle surface roughness in porous media on the microscale flow physics and report its effect on macroscale drag and Nusselt number. The Reynolds averaged flow field is numerically simulated for a flow through a periodic porous medium consisting of an in-line arrangement of square cylinders with square roughness particles on the cylinder surface. Two flow regimes are identified with respect to the surface roughness particle height: fine and coarse roughness regimes. The effect of the roughness particles in the fine roughness regime is limited to the near-wall boundary layer around the solid obstacle surface. In the coarse roughness regime, the roughness particles modify the microscale flow field in the entire pore space of the porous medium. In the fine roughness regime, the heat transfer from the rough solid obstacles to the fluid inside the porous medium is less than that from a smooth solid obstacle. In the coarse roughness regime, there is an enhancement in the heat transfer from the rough solid obstacle to the fluid inside the porous medium. Total drag reduction is also observed in the fine roughness regime for the smallest roughness particle height.

Introduction

Engineers frequently utilize surface roughness to enhance heat transfer in high-performance heat exchangers and chemical reactors. However, in porous media—where fluid navigates a complex network of solid obstacles—the microscale interaction between roughness and turbulent flow remains poorly understood. Most research focuses on laminar flow or smooth obstacles. This study addresses this gap by investigating whether roughness aids heat transfer through increased surface area and mixing, or hinders it by increasing drag and creating stagnant "dead zones" of hot fluid.

Methodology

The researchers employed numerical simulations to model the flow through an "infinitely spanning" porous medium. They used a 2D Representative Elementary Volume (REV) consisting of an in-line arrangement of square cylinders with smaller square roughness particles (Figure 1).

Schematic of the computational domain showing the periodic boundary conditions and the geometric parameters for smooth and rough obstacles.

Key aspects of the methodology include:

  • RANS Simulation: The Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations were solved using the realizable $k-\epsilon$ model, chosen for its accuracy in predicting boundary layer separation and recirculation.
  • Parameter Variation: The study varied roughness height ($k_s$), spacing ($w$), porosity ($\phi$), and Reynolds number ($Re$).
  • Validation: The numerical model was validated against high-fidelity Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) data. As shown in Figure 3, the RANS model accurately captures the velocity and temperature profiles across different sections of the pore space.
Validation of the realizable $k-\epsilon$ model against DNS data for normalized velocity and temperature profiles at various locations within the porous medium.

Key Insights: Fine vs. Coarse Roughness

The study identifies two distinct regimes based on the roughness height relative to the obstacle diameter ($d$):

  1. Fine Roughness Regime ($k_s \le 0.01d$): Roughness elements are submerged within the boundary layer. They do not significantly alter the global flow but create micro-vortices that act as an insulating layer, reducing heat transfer by 1.2% to 6%. Interestingly, this regime can lead to a total drag reduction (up to 2.7%) because the recirculating fluid "cushion" reduces viscous skin friction more than the particles increase pressure drag.
  2. Coarse Roughness Regime ($k_s \ge 0.05d$): These larger elements protrude into the main flow, "tripping" it and causing intense mixing. This entrains cooler fluid into the cavities, boosting heat transfer by 44% to 80%, albeit at the cost of significantly increased pressure drag (up to 80%).

Conclusion

The spacing of roughness particles also plays a critical role: close spacing leads to "sheltering" where flow bridges over gaps, while wider spacing promotes "tripping" as flow dives into the cavities. These effects are further amplified by decreasing porosity or increasing the Reynolds number.

While this 2D RANS study provides foundational insights, future work should explore 3D geometries and more complex obstacle arrangements (e.g., staggered) using higher-fidelity methods like Large Eddy Simulation (LES) to capture non-isotropic turbulence effects more accurately.

Summary updated

Abstract

The focus of this paper is to systematically study the influence of solid obstacle surface roughness in porous media on the microscale flow physics and report its effect on macroscale drag and Nusselt number. The Reynolds averaged flow field is numerically simulated for a flow through a periodic porous medium consisting of an in-line arrangement of square cylinders with square roughness particles on the cylinder surface. Two flow regimes are identified with respect to the surface roughness particle height: fine and coarse roughness regimes. The effect of the roughness particles in the fine roughness regime is limited to the near-wall boundary layer around the solid obstacle surface. In the coarse roughness regime, the roughness particles modify the microscale flow field in the entire pore space of the porous medium. In the fine roughness regime, the heat transfer from the rough solid obstacles to the fluid inside the porous medium is less than that from a smooth solid obstacle. In the coarse roughness regime, there is an enhancement in the heat transfer from the rough solid obstacle to the fluid inside the porous medium. Total drag reduction is also observed in the fine roughness regime for the smallest roughness particle height. The surface roughness particle spacing determines the fractional area of the solid obstacle surface covered by recirculating, reattached, and stagnating flow. As the roughness particle spacing increases, there are two competing factors for the heat transfer rate: increase due to more surface area covered by reattached flow, and decrease due to the decrease in the number of roughness particles on the solid obstacle surface. Decreasing the porosity and increasing the Reynolds number amplify the effect of the surface roughness on the microscale flow.
BibTeX
@misc{srikanth2022flow,
  author = {Vishal Srikanth and Dylan Peverall and Andrey Kuznetsov},
  title = {{Flow regimes and types of solid obstacle surface roughness in turbulent heat transfer inside periodic porous media}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2210.16455},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.16455},
}
Figure