Flow-Induced Motion and Energy Conversion of the Cir-T-Att Oscillator in a Flow Field with a High Reynolds Number

Danjie Ran, Jijian Lian, Xiang Yan, Fang Liu, Nan Shao, Xu Yang, Lingfan LiJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how high Reynolds numbers affect the flow-induced motion and energy harvesting capabilities of a novel "Cir-T-Att" oscillator. The researchers found that increasing the Reynolds number generally enhances oscillation intensity and the range of efficient energy generation, with the maximum power output reaching 10.43 W and the upper limit of power output reaching 17.80 W under specific high Reynolds number conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Harnessing energy from ocean currents is a promising avenue for renewable energy, and flow-induced motion (FIM) of submerged structures offers a potential method. While FIM oscillators have been explored, a significant gap exists in understanding how high Reynolds numbers (a measure of fluid flow turbulence and inertia) impact their performance. Historically, research has been limited to lower Reynolds numbers due to experimental constraints. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically studying the effects of a wide range of high Reynolds numbers on the motion, fluid forces, and energy conversion efficiency of a specific oscillator design, the Cir-T-Att oscillator.

Methods

The researchers conducted experiments in a recirculating water channel. They used a Cir-T-Att oscillator, a type of structure designed for efficient energy harvesting from water flow. To control the Reynolds number (Re), they varied the characteristic width (D) of the oscillator and the flow velocity (U). A key aspect of their methodology was the use of a controllable magnetic damping system, allowing them to precisely adjust the total damping ratio (ζtotal) of the system by varying excitation voltages. This enabled them to study the oscillator's response across different damping levels. They measured displacement using a magnetic induction transducer and fluid forces using a torque sensor. Data analysis involved examining amplitude and frequency ratios, lift coefficients, spectral content (using FFT), active power output, and the upper limit of power output.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from their custom-built test rig.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Reynolds Number is Crucial: Contrary to some earlier assumptions, this study strongly demonstrates that the Reynolds number significantly influences not just the oscillation amplitude and frequency but also the overall energy conversion characteristics of the Cir-T-Att oscillator.
  • VIV-Galloping Transition Matters: The transition between different flow regimes, particularly the VIV (Vortex-Induced Vibration) and Galloping branches, plays a critical role in determining the oscillator's performance and energy output. Higher Reynolds numbers appear to widen the range of these beneficial branches.
  • Damping is a Double-Edged Sword: While higher damping can sometimes lead to more stable oscillations, the study shows that there's an optimal damping level for maximum power output, and exceeding it can hinder performance.
  • Larger Oscillators, More Power (Up to a Point): Generally, increasing the oscillator's characteristic width (D) at higher Reynolds numbers leads to higher power generation, likely due to the increased interaction with the flow and the ability to withstand higher damping ratios.

Key Results

  • Amplitude and Frequency: As the Reynolds number increased, the oscillation intensity generally strengthened, and the range of the upper VIV branch widened.
  • Fluid Force (Lift Coefficient): In the VIV branches, the lift coefficient (C₁) showed an increasing trend with Re. However, as Re further increased and the oscillator entered VIV-Galloping transition branches, C₁ tended to decrease.
  • Active Power: The active power output generally increased with Reynolds number within the VIV upper branch. The maximum active power recorded was 10.43 W at Re = 14.67 × 10⁴ (for D=0.16m, ζtotal=0.468).
  • Upper Limit of Power Output: The maximum upper limit of power output reached 17.80 W at Re = 15.21 × 10⁴ (for D=0.16m, ζtotal=0.678).
  • Efficiency: The maximum power output efficiency (ηUL) reached 42.11% at D=0.1m, ζtotal=0.246, and Re=6.49 × 10⁴.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Blocking Ratio: The authors note that for very large characteristic widths (D > 0.14 m), an excessive blocking ratio (the ratio of the oscillator's diameter to the channel width) can deform the water surface and negatively impact oscillation stability and intensity.
  • Experimental Range: While the study covers a significant range of high Reynolds numbers, further exploration at even higher values might reveal additional phenomena.
  • Oscillator Design: The study focuses on the Cir-T-Att oscillator. Future work could investigate how these Reynolds number effects manifest in other FIM oscillator designs.
  • Turbulence Modeling: The paper focuses on experimental results. Further numerical studies could complement these findings by providing detailed insights into the turbulent flow structures at high Reynolds numbers.

Summary updated

Abstract

The present study aims to systematically investigate the effects of a high Reynolds number on the flow-induced motion and energy conversion of the Cir-T-Att oscillator. Experiments are conducted in six Reynolds number ranges (2.89 × 104~6.51 × 104 < Re < 7.71 × 104~15.21 × 104) in regimes of TrSL2, TrSL3 and TrBL0. The system total damping ratio (ζtotal) is adjusted by varying excitation voltages (VB) with a controllable magnetic damping system. The VB is varied from 0 V to 165 V, corresponding to 0.082 ≤ ζtotal ≤ 1.153. The amplitude, frequency, fluid force, spectral content, active power, and upper limit of power output are analyzed. The results show that the Reynolds number affects both amplitude and global response characteristics. The active power increases with an increasing Reynolds number within the upper branch. The maximum power output of the Cir-T-Att oscillator reaches 10.43 W, appearing at Re = 14.67 × 104 (D = 0.16 m, ζtotal = 0.468, Ur = 6.34), while the maximum upper limit of power output is 17.80 W at Re = 15.21 × 104 (D = 0.16 m, ζtotal = 0.678, Ur = 6.57).
BibTeX
@article{ran2023flow,
  author = {Danjie Ran and Jijian Lian and Xiang Yan and Fang Liu and Nan Shao and Xu Yang and Lingfan Li},
  title = {{Flow-Induced Motion and Energy Conversion of the Cir-T-Att Oscillator in a Flow Field with a High Reynolds Number}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11040795},
}
Figure