Abstract
This paper addresses the flocking problem for a discrete-time Cucker–Smale (C–S) model under conditions of packet loss. Communication between agents in multi-robot systems or UAV swarms is often compromised by network congestion or external interference. The authors propose a generalized probabilistic framework to model these failures and establish sufficient conditions for "almost sure" flocking—where agents achieve velocity alignment and maintain bounded distances—even in the presence of complex or malicious packet loss.
Introduction: The Challenge of Imperfect Communication
The Cucker–Smale model is a foundational framework for understanding collective motion in biological and engineered systems. It describes how agents adjust their velocities based on a weighted average of their neighbors' states. While traditional models assume seamless information exchange, real-world applications face "packet loss"—the failure of data transmission due to environmental noise, hardware limitations, or adversarial jamming.
Existing research often simplifies packet loss as a basic Bernoulli process. This paper expands the scope by considering more sophisticated scenarios where communication failures may be non-random or even strategically timed by an attacker.
Modeling Packet Loss
The authors employ a discrete-time C–S model where the communication success between agent $i$ and agent $j$ at time $k$ is represented by a random variable $\xi_{ij}(k) \in \{0, 1\}$. The core innovation lies in Assumption 1, which defines a generalized condition based on the cumulative success rate of transmissions over time. This framework encompasses four distinct cases:
- Time-Inhomogeneous Markov Chains: Modeling fluctuating network congestion.
- Malicious Jamming: Modeling an adversary with a fixed budget for blocking packets.
- Independent Combinations: Simultaneous random noise and jamming.
- Dependent Combinations: Sophisticated attacks where jamming decisions depend on existing network noise.
Theoretical Results and Flocking Conditions
The primary contribution is the derivation of Theorem 1, which identifies the thresholds required for flocking based on the spatial decay rate $\alpha$ of the influence function.
The theorem categorizes the system's behavior into three regimes:
- $\alpha < 1$: Flocking is guaranteed regardless of initial conditions, provided the long-term packet success rate meets the defined threshold.
- $\alpha = 1$: Flocking occurs if the initial velocity variance is sufficiently small relative to the coupling strength.
- $\alpha > 1$: Flocking depends on a specific inequality involving initial positions, velocities, and the packet loss parameter. Figure 1 illustrates the function $f(z)$ used to define these boundaries; flocking is achieved when the system's state remains within the region defined by the roots $z_l$ and $z_u$.
The proof utilizes the Borel–Cantelli Lemma and spectral analysis of the graph Laplacian, specifically focusing on the Fiedler number to demonstrate energy dissipation toward a consensus state.
Insights and Implications
The study reveals that flocking is a robust emergent property. The system can recover from "bursty" losses—temporary total communication blackouts—as long as the average information flow remains sufficient over time. By bridging the gap between stochastic noise and adversarial models, this work provides a more resilient framework for designing decentralized control systems in contested environments.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the current model assumes a symmetric, undirected communication topology (where information exchange is always mutual), many practical systems use directed graphs. Additionally, the assumption of a fixed, complete network structure—where every agent attempts to communicate with every other agent—could be relaxed in future work to include distance-dependent switching topologies. Extending these findings to continuous-time models also remains a promising area for further research.
Summary updated