Flipped classroom is an approach of basic medical education for undergraduate students

Xiang Ren, Lin lin Sui, You Fei Guan, Ying Kong, Bo Liu, Yan fang Ding, Hai Ying, Xiu li Wang, Hui Kong, Li KongResearch 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers at Dalian Medical University demonstrate that "flipping" the classroom—moving lectures to online digital platforms and using class time for active problem-solving—significantly boosts student performance in foundational medical subjects like histology and biochemistry. The study found that students in the flipped model not only achieved higher average scores but were nearly twice as likely to reach "excellent" grade tiers compared to those in traditional lecture-based tracks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional medical education has long relied on a passive "lecture-first" model where students receive information in the classroom and apply it later during solo study. However, this often fails to engage "digital native" students and doesn't effectively cultivate the independent, critical thinking skills required in modern medicine.

While the "flipped classroom" concept (pre-class study followed by in-class interaction) has gained traction, its effectiveness when paired with specific "elaborate" online course resources in basic medical sciences remained under-investigated. The authors sought to provide empirical evidence on whether this model actually improves learning outcomes in complex, high-volume subjects like Histology, Embryology, and Biochemistry.

Methods

The study enrolled 180 undergraduate medical students at Dalian Medical University, randomly allocating them into two groups:

  • Common Teaching Group (n=93): Followed the traditional lecture-based format.
  • Flipped Teaching Group (n=87): Used a "digital-first" approach. Students accessed "elaborate course" network resources—including a digital teaching website, an online video classroom, and virtual experimental platforms—to learn the material before class. In-class time was then dedicated to teacher-student cooperation to solve specific problems and discuss difficult concepts.

Performance was evaluated through a multi-modal approach: paper tests (40%), online tests (20-30%), and lab/experimental tests (30-40%).

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset generated from the 180 participating students. Evaluation metrics included:

  • Quantitative Scores: Total scores and sub-scores for paper, online, and laboratory examinations in Histology/Embryology and Biochemistry.
  • Qualitative Feedback: A student questionnaire (Table 1) measuring agreement, interest, and perceived burden of the flipped model.

No external benchmark datasets were used, as the study focused on internal academic performance metrics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Excellent" Rate Jump: One of the most striking findings was the shift in grade distribution. In Histology, the "excellent" rate (scores > 90) jumped from 36.56% in the traditional group to 50.57% in the flipped group. In Biochemistry, it rose from 27.78% to 43.52%.
  • Subject-Specific Strengths: The flipped model didn't just improve general knowledge; it specifically bolstered areas where students usually struggle. In Biochemistry, the flipped group saw significant gains in paper test scores ($p < 0.01$), suggesting the model helps with the retention of complex theoretical concepts.
  • Enhanced Experimental Logic: In lab settings, students in the flipped group demonstrated superior "hands-on" ability and logical thinking. The authors attribute this to the virtual experimental platforms that allowed students to "pre-run" experiments before entering the physical lab.
  • Teacher as Supervisor, Not Just Orator: The paper highlights a fundamental shift in the educator's role. In a flipped classroom, teachers must have a deeper "professional foundation reserve" because they are answering unpredictable student questions in real-time rather than following a set script.

Key Results

  • Histology & Embryology: The flipped group achieved a significantly higher total score (86.70 ± 10.01) compared to the common group (83.87 ± 11.22, $p < 0.05$). Significant improvements were specifically noted in online and lab test components.
  • Biochemistry: The performance gap was even wider here. The flipped group averaged 91.70 ± 10.01, while the common group averaged 85.87 ± 14.87 ($p < 0.01$).
  • Student Sentiment: Survey results were overwhelmingly positive. Over 63% of students were highly satisfied with the digital resources, and 55% strongly agreed that the flipped model improved their learning interest.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several hurdles to widespread adoption:

  • Resource Intensity: Developing high-quality "elaborate" digital courses requires significant time, technology, and institutional investment.
  • Student Habits: Many students are conditioned by years of passive learning. Transitioning them to a model where they bear more responsibility for initial content mastery is a psychological and behavioral challenge.
  • Teacher Workload: The model demands more from educators in terms of supervising extracurricular activities and providing timely, individualized feedback.

Future research could explore how to better integrate these models across more diverse subject areas and how to incentivize more faculty members to join the "resource construction" phase of digital education.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background: With the development of medical education, new teaching method, such as flipped teaching model, was paid attention in the process. However, the sharing elaborate courses was used in the flipped teaching model in basic medicine has not been well investigated. Therefore, the aim of this study was to evaluate students’ learning effect of the histology and biochemistry between traditional teaching methods and flipped teaching method in the basic medicine classes to provide a scientific evidence of a new model establishment in the medical students’ education.Methods: 180 medical students at the Dalian Medical University were enrolled in the process. Hyperthyroidism was chosen for the content of this study. The participants were randomly allocated into the common teaching model group with the traditional lecture-based manner or the flipped teaching model group with the sharing elaborate courses manner. There are paper test, online test and lab test for histology and embryology after learning. The scores including total score, paper test score, online test score and lab test score were compared in two differernt teaching model and students were required to complete the questionnaire to evaluate the teaching model.Results: The scores of total, online and lab test with flipped teaching model were higher than those in common teaching model in histology and embryology. Additionally, the scores of total, paper and lab test with flipped teaching model were higher than those in common teaching model in biochemistry.The feedback of all items in the questionnaires were much positive. More students agreed and accepted the flipped teaching method could help to improve their performance.Conclusions: The medical students at Dalian Medical University can benefit from the flipped classroom teaching model, and a flipped classroom teaching model may well serve some subject areas such as histology and biochemistry. The flipped classroom approach can serve as a potentially exciting new modality for teaching model in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2020flipped,
  author = {Xiang Ren and Lin lin Sui and You Fei Guan and Ying Kong and Bo Liu and Yan fang Ding and Hai Ying and Xiu li Wang and Hui Kong and Li Kong},
  title = {{Flipped classroom is an approach of basic medical education for undergraduate students}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-18325/v1},
}
Figure