Flexible Multiscale Pore Hybrid Self-Powered Sensor for Heart Sound Detection

Boyan Liu, Liuyang Han, Lyuming Pan, Wanqing Li, Jingjing Zhao, Ying Dong, Xiaohao WangSensors 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel flexible, self-powered sensor for detecting heart sounds. By creating a unique "bi-nano-micro porous" structure in a piezoelectric polymer and incorporating an electret effect, the sensor achieves significantly enhanced sensitivity and a high piezoelectric coefficient, paving the way for more advanced wearable health monitoring.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional methods for detecting heart sounds, like stethoscopes, are often bulky and not ideal for continuous, wearable monitoring. While flexible sensors exist, many require external power sources or are affected by environmental factors like humidity. Existing flexible piezoelectric sensors, while self-powered, often struggle with sensitivity and limited frequency bandwidth, especially when using materials like PVDF. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a highly sensitive, flexible, and self-powered sensor specifically for accurate heart sound detection, including the potential for identifying pathological sounds.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the sensor's fabrication and material design. The researchers developed a "bi-nano-micro porous" structure within a P(VDF-TrFE) piezoelectric polymer film. This was achieved through a two-step process:

  • Electrospinning: This technique was used to create a base layer of P(VDF-TrFE) nanofibers, forming a porous structure with diameters ranging from 100 nm to 10 µm.
  • Acid Etching (with ZnO nanoparticles): ZnO nanoparticles were initially incorporated to act as templates for creating nanoscale pores and to promote the desired β-phase in the P(VDF-TrFE) for better piezoelectric properties. Subsequent etching with concentrated HCl removed the ZnO nanoparticles, leaving behind the nanoscale pores.

To further enhance performance, a dual ferro-electret hybrid approach was employed:

  • Corona Poling: This process ionizes air within the porous structure, creating space charge dipoles. These charges are then trapped by surrounding PDMS (polydimethylsiloxane) layers, which act as electret layers. This creates a hybrid sensing mechanism combining the piezoelectric effect of the P(VDF-TrFE) with the electret effect.

The sensor is constructed as a sandwich structure: two PDMS electret layers encapsulating the bi-nano-micro porous P(VDF-TrFE) piezoelectric film. Electrodes are then applied, and corona polarization is performed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the sensor's performance evaluation using controlled stimuli and real human heart sounds.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Effect of Multiscale Pores: The combination of both microscale (from electrospinning) and nanoscale (from etching) pores is crucial. Microscale pores contribute to fiber deformation and signal output, while nanoscale pores provide a "geometric strain confining effect," enhancing stress localization and thus output voltage.
  • Electret Enhancement: The addition of the electret effect through corona poling significantly boosts the sensor's piezoelectric coefficient by combining molecular dipoles with space charge dipoles. This hybrid approach is key to achieving high sensitivity.
  • Material Choice Matters: P(VDF-TrFE) was chosen over PVDF due to its inherent β-phase structure at room temperature, simplifying fabrication and ensuring consistent piezoelectric properties.
  • Scalable Fabrication: The electrospinning and etching processes are amenable to large-scale production, making the sensor potentially cost-effective.

Key Results

  • High Piezoelectric Coefficient: The developed sensor achieved an equivalent piezoelectric coefficient ($d_{33}$) of 3312 pC/N. This is significantly higher than common piezoelectric materials (e.g., PZT at ~200 pC/N) and even PVDF (~20 pC/N). It's approximately 13 times higher than a basic electrospun sensor and 1.5 times higher than a sensor with only microscale pores and corona poling.
  • Improved Dynamic Response: The multiscale pore hybrid sensor demonstrated a much wider and higher dynamic stimulus response compared to a sensor with only microscale pores, particularly at higher frequencies.
  • Accurate Heart Sound Detection: The sensor successfully detected both physiological and pathological heart sounds, showing comparable performance to a commercial SS17L heart sound sensor. It could distinguish features like S1 and S2 sounds and identify pathological conditions like transient S2 splits, fixed S2 splits, aortic regurgitation, and atrial septal defects.
  • Long-Term Stability: The sensor exhibited good stability over 2500 cycles, with output voltage fluctuations within ±8% of the average.
  • Flexibility and Self-Powering: The sensor is flexible, lightweight, and self-powered, making it ideal for wearable applications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low-Frequency Response: The authors acknowledge that the low-frequency response of the sensor was not ideal and needs improvement for future iterations.
  • Further Optimization: While the results are promising, further optimization of pore size distribution, electret charge density, and material composition could lead to even higher performance.
  • Clinical Validation: While the sensor demonstrated the ability to detect pathological heart sounds, extensive clinical trials would be necessary to validate its diagnostic capabilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

This research introduces an idea of producing both nanoscale and microscale pores in piezoelectric material, and combining the properties of the molecular β-phase dipoles in ferroelectric material and the space charge dipoles in order to increase the sensitivity of the sensor and modulate the response frequency bandwidth of the material. Based on this idea, a bi-nano-micro porous dual ferro-electret hybrid self-powered flexible heart sound detection sensor is proposed. Acid etching and electrospinning were the fabrication processes used to produce a piezoelectric film with nanoscale and microscale pores, and corona poling was used for air ionization to produce an electret effect. In this paper, the manufacturing process of the sensor is introduced, and the effect of the porous structure and corona poling on improving the performance of the sensor is discussed. The proposed flexible sensor has an equivalent piezoelectric coefficient d<sub>33</sub> of 3312 pC/N, which is much larger than the piezoelectric coefficient of the common piezoelectric materials. Experiments were carried out to verify the function of the flexible sensor together with the SS17L heart sound sensor (BIOPAC, Goleta, CA, USA) as a reference. The test results demonstrated its practical application for wearable heart sound detection and the potential for heart disease detection. The proposed flexible sensor in this paper could realize batch production, and has the advantages of flexibility, low production cost and a short processing time compared with the existing heart sound detection sensors.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2021flexible,
  author = {Boyan Liu and Liuyang Han and Lyuming Pan and Wanqing Li and Jingjing Zhao and Ying Dong and Xiaohao Wang},
  title = {{Flexible Multiscale Pore Hybrid Self-Powered Sensor for Heart Sound Detection}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/s21134508},
}
Figure