Flexible Multi-Objective Transmission Expansion Planning with Adjustable Risk Aversion

Jing Qiu, Junhua Zhao, Dongxiao WangEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel framework for transmission expansion planning (TEP) that explicitly incorporates risk aversion, moving beyond traditional deterministic reliability measures. By quantifying and allowing adjustable risk preferences, the approach helps grid planners make more robust decisions when integrating intermittent renewable energy sources like wind power.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources, particularly wind power, presents significant challenges for power system operation and planning. Wind power's inherent intermittency and geographic dispersion often lead to transmission bottlenecks and system reliability issues. Traditional TEP methods, which often rely on deterministic reliability criteria, struggle to adequately capture the stochastic nature of these uncertainties (wind output, load variations, component failures) and the associated risks. This can lead to overly conservative or insufficient expansion plans. The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a flexible, multi-objective TEP framework that allows planners to explicitly consider and adjust their risk tolerance when making expansion decisions, thereby balancing cost and reliability in the face of uncertainty.

Methods

The core of this paper is a multi-objective transmission expansion planning (TEP) framework that incorporates a novel "risk value after risk aversion" component. Instead of a fixed reliability criterion, this framework quantifies risk based on probabilistic reliability and allows for adjustable risk aversion through a "risk attitude factor" (RAF), denoted by k. A higher k signifies greater risk aversion.

Key methodological contributions include:

  • Probabilistic Risk Component: A risk component is introduced to capture the stochastic nature of power systems, including variations in load, wind power output, and component availability. This is formulated using a concept inspired by Conditional Value-at-Risk (CVaR).
  • Adjustable Risk Aversion: The framework explicitly defines a "risk value after risk aversion" that can be tuned by the decision-maker using the risk attitude factor (k). This allows for a flexible selection of expansion plans based on individual risk preferences.
  • Incentive-Based Demand Response (IBDR) Integration: The economic value of IBDR is modeled and integrated into the cost objective, allowing for its utilization as a resource to manage uncertainties and reduce costs.
  • Multi-Objective Evolutionary Algorithm (MOEA/D): A relatively new multi-objective evolutionary algorithm, MOEA/D, is employed to efficiently find Pareto optimal solutions, illustrating the trade-offs between overall cost and risk.

The paper also models uncertainties using probability density functions (PDFs) for wind power (Weibull distribution), load forecast errors (Gaussian distribution), component availability (binomial distribution), and IBDR costs (Gaussian distribution). Monte Carlo simulations are used to generate scenarios for these uncertainties.

Datasets

The proposed approach is numerically verified on three standard power system test cases:

  • Garver's six-bus system
  • IEEE 24-bus RTS system
  • 2383-bus Polish system

Network data for these systems, including forced outage rates (FORs) of generating units and transmission lines, are referenced from existing literature ([34-36]). Load profiles are based on data from the National Transmission Network Development Plan 2016 for New South Wales, Australia ([37]).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Risk Aversion is Crucial for Renewables: The study strongly suggests that simply aiming for deterministic reliability is insufficient when integrating high levels of wind power. A flexible risk-aversion strategy is essential for managing the inherent uncertainties and achieving a better balance between cost and reliability.
  • IBDR as a Key Enabler: Incentive-based demand response (IBDR) plays a significant role in enhancing system economic efficiency and reliability, particularly when coupled with risk-averse planning. It helps absorb wind power and mitigate costs.
  • Trade-offs are Inevitable: The research clearly demonstrates the inherent conflict between minimizing cost and minimizing risk. The multi-objective framework and the Pareto frontier visualization are critical for understanding and navigating these trade-offs.
  • Tailoring Plans to Risk Appetite: The ability to adjust the risk attitude factor (k) allows planners to select solutions that align with their specific risk tolerance, moving beyond a one-size-fits-all approach. This is particularly important for planning against low-probability, high-impact events.

Key Results

  • Cost-Effective Risk Hedging: Case studies show that the proposed risk-averse TEP approach can effectively reduce costs and hedge against reliability risks, especially with increasing wind power penetration. For instance, in the Garver's six-bus system, Case 3 (proposed approach with DR and risk aversion) achieved the lowest total cost (256.44 M$) and lowest EENS (0.0156%) compared to deterministic approaches.
  • Improved Reliability: The risk-averse approach leads to more reliable systems, as evidenced by lower Expected Energy Not Supplied (EENS) values, even when facing higher wind power penetration.
  • Scalability: The MOEA/D algorithm demonstrated reasonable computational performance across different system sizes, from a 6-bus system to a 2383-bus system, suggesting its applicability to real-world grid planning.
  • Polish System Performance: For the 2383-bus Polish system, the risk-averse approach (Case 3) showed a substantial reduction in maximum risk value (approximately 41%) compared to a non-risk-averse approach (Case 4) while maintaining a similar risk level. It also demonstrated better resilience to wind uncertainty.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While MOEA/D is efficient, contingency analysis based on Monte Carlo simulations accounts for a significant portion of the computation time. The authors suggest that parallel computing could further accelerate convergence.
  • Severity Function: The paper notes that the severity function used for corrective control actions is not unique and can be adapted if more accurate financial loss evaluation equations become available.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further research could explore more sophisticated risk assessment models, advanced uncertainty quantification techniques, and the integration of other operational flexibility resources. The flexibility of the proposed framework also opens avenues for exploring different risk preferences and their impact on long-term planning decisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents a multi-objective transmission expansion planning (TEP) framework. Rather than using the conventional deterministic reliability criterion, a risk component based on the probabilistic reliability criterion is incorporated into the TEP objectives. This risk component can capture the stochastic nature of power systems, such as load and wind power output variations, component availability, and incentive-based demand response (IBDR) costs. Specifically, the formulation of risk value after risk aversion is explicitly given, and it aims to provide network planners with the flexibility to conduct risk analysis. Thus, a final expansion plan can be selected according to individual risk preferences. Moreover, the economic value of IBDR is modeled and integrated into the cost objective. In addition, a relatively new multi-objective evolutionary algorithm called the MOEA/D is introduced and employed to find Pareto optimal solutions, and tradeoffs between overall cost and risk are provided. The proposed approach is numerically verified on the Garver’s six-bus, IEEE 24-bus RTS and Polish 2383-bus systems. Case study results demonstrate that the proposed approach can effectively reduce cost and hedge risk in relation to increasing wind power integration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qiu2017flexible,
  author = {Jing Qiu and Junhua Zhao and Dongxiao Wang},
  title = {{Flexible Multi-Objective Transmission Expansion Planning with Adjustable Risk Aversion}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10071036},
}
Figure