Flexible machine learning prediction of antigen presentation for rare and common HLA-I alleles

Barbara Bravi, Jérôme Tubiana, Simona Cocco, Rémi Monasson, Thierry Mora, Aleksandra M. WalczakbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces RBM-MHC, a flexible machine learning framework for predicting which peptides are presented by specific HLA-I molecules. It excels at improving predictions for rare HLA alleles, a significant challenge for existing methods, by leveraging a novel combination of Restricted Boltzmann Machines (RBMs) and a supervised classifier.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The immune system relies on T-cells recognizing foreign or abnormal peptides presented on the surface of cells by Human Leukocyte Antigen class I (HLA-I) molecules. Identifying these presented peptides is crucial for developing cancer immunotherapies (neoantigens) and vaccines. However, HLA-I is highly polymorphic, with hundreds of alleles, many of which are rare and poorly characterized. Existing prediction tools, often trained on large, common allele datasets, struggle with these rare alleles, leading to inaccurate predictions. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method that can be easily and rapidly adapted to improve predictions for both common and rare HLA-I alleles.

Methods

The core of RBM-MHC is a two-part approach:

  1. Restricted Boltzmann Machine (RBM): An unsupervised learning model that learns the underlying probability distribution of peptide sequences. This RBM learns a "representation space" for peptides, capturing their essential features. It can then assign a "presentation score" to any given peptide for a specific HLA-I allele.
  2. HLA-I Classifier: A supervised learning model that takes the RBM's representation of a peptide and, using a small number of labeled examples (peptides with known HLA-I restriction), predicts the specific HLA-I allele that would present it.

This combination allows RBM-MHC to be trained "on the fly" on custom datasets, making it highly flexible. The method also includes a novel sequence alignment routine that iteratively refines alignments based on predicted HLA classifications, further improving accuracy.

Datasets

The authors utilized several datasets for training and evaluation:

  • Immune Epitope Database (IEDB): This was the primary source for curated HLA-I ligand data, including mass spectrometry (MS) and binding affinity (BA) assays.
  • Mono-allelic cell line datasets: Datasets from specific cell lines expressing a single HLA-I allele were used for rigorous validation.
  • Cancer cell line mutation data: Datasets of missense mutations from cancer cell lines were used to test neoantigen prediction.
  • SARS-CoV-2 epitope data: In vitro binding stability data for SARS-CoV-2 peptides were used to assess prediction performance for viral epitopes.
  • Synthetic "individual" samples: These were constructed by pooling IEDB antigens from multiple HLA-I alleles to simulate real-world multi-allelic scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Flexibility is Key for Rare Alleles: The paper strongly emphasizes that the ability to rapidly train models on new, specific datasets is crucial for accurately predicting presentation by rare HLA alleles, where large, general datasets are insufficient.
  • RBM Representation Space is Powerful: The low-dimensional representation learned by the RBM is not just for scoring but also enables visualization of binding motifs and even the discovery of alternative binding modes within a single HLA allele.
  • Semi-Supervised Learning Advantage: By combining an unsupervised RBM with a supervised classifier trained on minimal labels, RBM-MHC achieves high accuracy without requiring massive labeled datasets, which are often unavailable for rare alleles.
  • Alignment Refinement Matters: The iterative alignment refinement process, where alignment is informed by HLA classification and vice-versa, significantly boosts performance, especially in multi-allelic settings.

Key Results

  • High Accuracy on Mono-allelic Data: RBM-MHC achieved comparable or superior performance (AUC ~0.97) to state-of-the-art methods like NetMHCpan4.0 on mono-allelic datasets, particularly for rare HLA-C alleles.
  • Improved Rare Allele Prediction: The method demonstrated a clear advantage for HLA alleles with limited representation in existing databases, where NetMHCpan's performance degraded with distance from its training data.
  • Effective Neoantigen Prediction: RBM-MHC successfully predicted experimentally validated cancer neoantigens, ranking them among the top candidates.
  • SARS-CoV-2 Epitope Discovery: The method identified promising SARS-CoV-2 epitopes for HLA-C alleles that were not top-ranked by existing tools.
  • Accurate HLA Classification: In multi-allelic settings, RBM-MHC achieved excellent HLA classification performance (AUC ~0.991) using only 10% labeled data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Dependency: The performance of RBM-MHC, like any machine learning model, is dependent on the quality and quantity of the training data. While flexible, it still benefits from relevant data.
  • HLA Class II Extension: The current work focuses on HLA-I. The authors suggest extending the approach to HLA class II presentation as a future direction.
  • Quantitative Insights: The authors propose further investigating how the probabilistic framework of RBM-MHC can be exploited to gain more quantitative insights into endogenous antigen presentation.
  • Custom Sample Specificity: The method's ability to be trained on custom samples could be valuable for understanding sample-specific antigen presentation complexities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Summary The recent increase of immunopeptidomic data, obtained by mass spectrometry or binding assays, opens unprecedented possibilities for investigating endogenous antigen presentation by the highly polymorphic human leukocyte antigen class I (HLA-I) protein. We introduce a flexible and easily interpretable peptide presentation prediction method, RBM-MHC. We validate its performance as a predictor of cancer neoantigens and viral epitopes and we use it to reconstruct peptide motifs presented on specific HLA-I molecules. By benchmarking RBM-MHC performance on a wide range of HLA-I alleles, we show its importance to improve prediction accuracy for rarer alleles.
BibTeX
@misc{bravi2020flexible,
  author = {Barbara Bravi and Jérôme Tubiana and Simona Cocco and Rémi Monasson and Thierry Mora and Aleksandra M. Walczak},
  title = {{Flexible machine learning prediction of antigen presentation for rare and common HLA-I alleles}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.04.25.061069},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure