Flexible Embedded Metal Meshes by Sputter-Free Crack Lithography for Transparent Electrodes and Electromagnetic Interference Shielding

Mehdi Zarei, Mingxuan Li, Elizabeth E. Medvedeva, Sooraj Sharma, Jungtaek Kim, Zefan Shao, Scott Walker, Melbs LeMieux, Qihan Liu, Paul W. LeuACS 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel, sputtering-free method to create flexible, transparent silver meshes embedded in PET. This technique uses crack lithography and reactive ion etching to form precise patterns, enabling high optical transparency and excellent electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding, outperforming existing crack lithography methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern electronic devices, from displays to communication systems, increasingly require materials that are both optically transparent and capable of blocking electromagnetic interference (EMI). Achieving this balance is a significant challenge, as many materials that offer good EMI shielding are opaque, and highly transparent materials often provide poor shielding. Existing methods for creating transparent conductive electrodes and EMI shielding materials, such as sputtering and photolithography, can be costly, time-consuming, and not well-suited for flexible substrates. Specifically, crack lithography, while promising for its simplicity, often relies on sputtering to deposit conductive films, which can lead to poor adhesion and issues with lift-off, especially for narrow, high-aspect-ratio features. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a sputtering-free, flexible fabrication process for metal meshes that excel in both transparency and EMI shielding.

Methods

The core of this work is a novel fabrication process that leverages "crack lithography" without the need for sputtering. Here's a breakdown:

  1. Crack Template Formation: A waterborne acrylic emulsion polymer (Carboset CA-600) is spin-coated onto a flexible PET substrate.
  2. Crack Induction: Heating and evaporation during the curing process induce stress in the polymer film, causing it to crack. The width and spacing of these cracks are controlled by the polymer thickness and curing temperature.
  3. Pattern Transfer (RIE): Reactive Ion Etching (RIE) is used to transfer these self-formed cracks into the PET substrate, creating precise, high-aspect-ratio trenches. This step is crucial as it avoids issues with delamination of the template and allows for direct filling of the trenches.
  4. Silver Ink Filling: A highly conductive silver ink is then applied to fill the etched trenches.
  5. Curing and Finishing: The silver ink is cured at a low temperature (below 110 °C), followed by removal of excess ink and a final hard curing step.

This process eliminates the need for sputtering, which is a significant advantage for cost, complexity, and adhesion. The RIE step is key to creating well-defined trenches that can be uniformly filled with the silver ink.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the fabrication and characterization of novel materials rather than training machine learning models on existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sputter-Free Crack Lithography: The most significant innovation is the elimination of sputtering. This simplifies the process, reduces costs, and crucially, improves adhesion of the silver mesh to the PET substrate by embedding it within the etched trenches.
  • RIE for Precise Pattern Transfer: Using RIE to transfer the cracks into the PET substrate allows for precise control over trench dimensions and aspect ratios, which is critical for achieving uniform filling and high performance.
  • Tunable Crack Morphology: The study demonstrates that controlling the spin speed and curing temperature of the acrylic emulsion allows for fine-tuning of crack width, spacing, and depth, directly impacting the final mesh properties.
  • Embedded Structure for Durability: Embedding the silver mesh within the PET substrate provides superior mechanical robustness compared to surface-deposited films, as evidenced by bending tests.
  • Balancing Transparency and Shielding: The developed method achieves an impressive balance between high visible light transmission (up to 93.7%) and significant EMI shielding efficiency (up to 42 dB), outperforming many existing flexible transparent materials.

Key Results

The flexible embedded Ag meshes fabricated using this method demonstrated remarkable performance:

  • Transparent Electrodes:
    • Visible transmission of 91.3% with a sheet resistance of 0.54 Ω/sq (figure of merit σ<sub>DC</sub>/σ<sub>OP</sub> = 7500).
  • Visible transmission of 93.7% with a sheet resistance of 1.4 Ω/sq (figure of merit σ<sub>DC</sub>/σ<sub>OP</sub> = 4070).
  • These figures of merit are reported as the highest among crack lithography approaches in the literature.
  • Transparent EMI Shielding:
    • Shielding efficiency (SE) of 42 dB with 91.3% visible transmission.
  • SE of 37.4 dB with 93.7% visible transmission.
  • This performance is claimed to be the highest among all flexible transparent EMI shielding fabrication approaches in the literature.
  • Mechanical Durability: The samples showed good resilience under bending tests, with only a modest increase in sheet resistance after 800 cycles.
  • Adhesion Strength: The silver ink exhibited strong adhesion to the PET substrate, withstanding an average stress of 2.7 MPa without delamination.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The RIE process has a limitation on etching time, as over-etching can damage the PET substrate and create defects that trap ink, reducing transparency.
  • While the process is described as facile, achieving optimal crack interconnection for all samples required careful control of parameters, and some samples (6-9) were unsuitable due to poorly interconnected cracks.
  • The study focused on specific frequency bands (8-18 GHz) for EMI shielding.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that these metal meshes have potential applications in transparent electrodes, EMI shielding, solar cells, and organic light-emitting diodes.
  • Further optimization of the RIE process and ink formulation could potentially lead to even higher performance metrics.
  • Exploring a wider range of frequencies for EMI shielding and investigating performance in other optoelectronic devices would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

A facile and novel fabrication method is demonstrated for creating flexible poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET)-embedded silver meshes using crack lithography, reactive ion etching (RIE), and reactive silver ink. The crack width and spacing in a waterborne acrylic emulsion polymer are controlled by the thickness of the polymer and the applied stress due to heating and evaporation. Our innovative fabrication technique eliminates the need for sputtering and ensures stronger adhesion of the metal meshes to the PET substrate. Crack trench depths over 5 μm and line widths under 5 μm have been achieved. As a transparent electrode, our flexible embedded Ag meshes exhibit a visible transmission of 91.3% and sheet resistance of 0.54 Ω/sq as well as 93.7% and 1.4 Ω/sq. This performance corresponds to figures of merit (σ<sub>DC</sub>/σ<sub>OP</sub>) of 7500 and 4070, respectively. For transparent electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding, the metal meshes achieve a shielding efficiency (SE) of 42 dB with 91.3% visible transmission and an EMI SE of 37.4 dB with 93.7% visible transmission. We demonstrate the highest transparent electrode performance of crack lithography approaches in the literature and the highest flexible transparent EMI shielding performance of all fabrication approaches in the literature. These metal meshes may have applications in transparent electrodes, EMI shielding, solar cells, and organic light-emitting diodes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zarei2024flexible,
  author = {Mehdi Zarei and Mingxuan Li and Elizabeth E. Medvedeva and Sooraj Sharma and Jungtaek Kim and Zefan Shao and Scott Walker and Melbs LeMieux and Qihan Liu and Paul W. Leu},
  title = {{Flexible Embedded Metal Meshes by Sputter-Free Crack Lithography for Transparent Electrodes and Electromagnetic Interference Shielding}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acsami.3c16405},
}
Figure