Flexible design of progressive addition lenses for effective sizing of viewing zones using ellipse, hyperbola, parabola, and circle parametric equations

Lefei Ma, Huazhong Xiang, Xinming Zhang, Hui Cheng, Zexi Zheng, Jiabi Chen, Jianfeng Liang, Dawei Zhang, Songlin ZhuangOptica 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a flexible "direct design" method for Progressive Addition Lenses (PALs) that uses conic sections—ellipses, hyperbolas, parabolas, and circles—to map optical power across a lens. By adjusting these geometric parameters and a novel offset value, designers can precisely control the width of far- and near-vision zones while minimizing the "swim effect" caused by peripheral astigmatism.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Presbyopia—the age-related loss of near-focusing ability—affects nearly a quarter of the global population. Progressive Addition Lenses (PALs) are the standard solution, providing a seamless transition from distance vision at the top to near vision at the bottom.

However, designing these lenses is an optimization nightmare. "Direct" design methods often struggle to create wide, clear viewing zones without introducing significant peripheral astigmatism (blurriness at the edges). Most existing research focuses on the "meridian line" (the vertical path the eye follows), but there is a lack of flexible frameworks for distributing power across the rest of the lens surface to suit individual patient needs.

Methods

The authors propose a two-step mathematical framework to generate the lens surface:

  1. The Meridian Power Law: They define the change in optical power along the vertical meridian using a trigonometric (sine-squared) function. This ensures the transition between the distance and near zones is mathematically "smooth" (satisfying the Laplace equation), which reduces visual discomfort.
  2. Conic Power Contours: To extend this power from the meridian to the edges of the lens, they use the general equation for conic sections. By varying the conic coefficient ($k$), they can choose between four shapes:
  3. Hyperbola ($k < -1$)
    • Parabola ($k = -1$)
    • Ellipse ($k > -1$)
    • Circle ($k = 0$)

They also introduced an offset parameter ($\Delta x$). This allows the designer to shift the power distribution vertically, effectively "stretching" or "shrinking" the widths of the distance ($W_D$) and near ($W_N$) viewing zones to match a wearer's specific lifestyle.

Datasets

This study did not use external datasets. Instead, the researchers established a set of theoretical design parameters (Table 1) including a 2.00 Diopter (D) addition power and a refractive index of 1.56. They used these to simulate four distinct lens types, which were then manufactured and verified.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometry Dictates Comfort: The choice of conic section is not just aesthetic; it fundamentally changes the wearer's experience. The study found that hyperbolic contours create the highest peripheral astigmatism (1.36 times the addition power), which can cause vertigo or a "swimming" sensation.
  • The Ellipse Advantage: Elliptical equations proved superior for creating larger, stable "fixed focus" areas for distance vision.
  • The Circle for Near Work: Circular equations excelled at maximizing the width of the near-vision zone, making them ideal for patients who do heavy reading or close-up work.
  • Personalization via Math: By adjusting the $q$ parameters (which set the distribution size) and the $\Delta x$ offset, the method allows for "bespoke" lens design. A pilot who needs wide distance vision and a jeweler who needs a wide near zone can now have their lenses optimized using the same underlying mathematical framework.

Key Results

The team simulated their designs using ROTLEX Free-Form Verifier software and manufactured physical prototypes using a Satisloh VFT-orbit CNC machine.

  • Precision: The manufactured lenses were highly accurate, with sphere (SPH) and addition (ADD) powers within 0.04D and 0.05D of theoretical values, respectively—well within international standards (GB10810.1-2005).
  • Zone Widths:
    • The Elliptical lens achieved the widest distance zone ($W_D = 31.42$ mm).
  • The Circular lens achieved the widest near zone ($W_N = 13.01$ mm).
  • Astigmatism Control: Lenses designed with elliptical, circular, and parabolic equations kept maximum peripheral astigmatism below the addition power (1.0x ADD), a key threshold for wearer adaptation.

Limitations and Future Work

The current study focuses on the posterior (back) surface of the lens while assuming a spherical inner surface. The authors acknowledge that the next step is transitioning to an aspherical inner surface. This would allow for even more complex optimizations to reduce tangential errors and further sharpen peripheral vision in real-world use cases. Additionally, while the math is sound, large-scale clinical trials with human subjects would be needed to confirm subjective "wearer preference" between the four conic types.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study addresses the critical issue of optical power distribution in progressive addition lenses (PALs). We introduce a novel approach by defining the addition vertex power curve along the meridian line as a trigonometric function. Four distinct conic equations (ellipse, hyperbola, parabola, and circle) are proposed to extend power distribution evenly across the lens surface. An offset parameter is introduced for controlling viewing area widths. The elliptical equations offer the best results for larger fixed focus areas, while circular equations excel for smaller areas. This personalized method caters to individual patient needs, providing optimized PAL designs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ma2025flexible,
  author = {Lefei Ma and Huazhong Xiang and Xinming Zhang and Hui Cheng and Zexi Zheng and Jiabi Chen and Jianfeng Liang and Dawei Zhang and Songlin Zhuang},
  title = {{Flexible design of progressive addition lenses for effective sizing of viewing zones using ellipse, hyperbola, parabola, and circle parametric equations}},
  booktitle = {Optica},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.37190/oa/195988},
}
Figure