Flavoured jets with exact anti-$k_t$ kinematics and tests of infrared and collinear safety

Fabrizio Caola, R. P. Grabarczyk, Maxwell L. Hutt, Gavin P. Salam, L. M. Scyboz, Jesse ThalerarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We propose extensions of the anti-$k_t$ and Cambridge/Aachen hierarchical jet clustering algorithms that are designed to retain the exact jet kinematics of these algorithms, while providing an infrared-and-collinear-safe definition of jet flavour at any fixed order in perturbation theory. Central to our approach is a new technique called Interleaved Flavour Neutralisation (IFN), whereby the treatment of flavour is integrated with, but distinct from, the kinematic clustering. IFN allows flavour information to be meaningfully accessed at each stage of the clustering sequence, which enables a consistent assignment of flavour both to individual jets and to their substructure. We validate the IFN approach using a dedicated framework for fixed-order tests of infrared and collinear safety, which also reveals unanticipated issues in earlier approaches to flavoured jet clustering. We briefly explore the phenomenological impact of IFN with anti-$k_t$ jets for benchmark tasks at the Large Hadron Collider.

Introduction: The Challenge of Jet Flavor

In high-energy particle physics, jets are the experimental signatures of quarks and gluons. The anti-$k_t$ algorithm has become the standard for jet reconstruction at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) due to its "conical" jet shapes and resilience to soft radiation. However, standard anti-$k_t$ is flavor-blind; it clusters energy without regard to the underlying quantum numbers. Assigning a flavor (e.g., $b$-quark, $c$-quark, or gluon) to these jets is crucial for many analyses, such as Higgs boson studies or searches for new physics, but doing so in a theoretically consistent way is notoriously difficult.

A jet configuration where a gluon splits into a quark-antiquark pair, posing a challenge for flavor assignment.

The Problem: Infrared and Collinear Safety

A fundamental requirement for any jet algorithm used in precision calculations is Infrared and Collinear (IRC) safety. An algorithm is IRC safe if the resulting jets do not change when a very soft particle is added or when a particle is replaced by two collinear ones. While standard algorithms are kinematically IRC safe, defining an IRC-safe flavor is harder. For instance, a soft gluon splitting into a $q\bar{q}$ pair at a wide angle can change the flavor of a nearby jet if one of the quarks is clustered into it.

Previous attempts to solve this, such as the flavor-$k_t$ algorithm, often modified the jet boundaries based on flavor, leading to non-circular jets that are difficult to compare with experimental data. Other algorithms like CMP or GHS appeared safe but, as this research demonstrates, harbor hidden instabilities at higher orders of perturbation theory.

Interleaved Flavour Neutralisation (IFN)

The authors introduce Interleaved Flavour Neutralisation (IFN) to address these issues. The core innovation is to decouple flavor assignment from kinematic clustering while keeping them "interleaved." The kinematic clustering proceeds exactly as in the standard anti-$k_t$ or Cambridge/Aachen algorithms, ensuring the desired jet shapes and energies are preserved.

At each step of the clustering, the IFN logic checks for "neutralisation" partners. If a flavored particle is about to be clustered, the algorithm searches globally for an anti-particle that can "neutralise" its flavor. This process is recursive: it ensures that the neutralising partner itself isn't better suited to neutralise something else first.

The IFN procedure: (a) initial particles, (b) identification of neutralisation partners, (c) neutralisation of flavor, and (d) final kinematic clustering.

Rigorous Validation and Results

The IFN approach was validated using a custom automated framework designed to test IRC safety up to very high orders ($\alpha_s^6$). This testing revealed that several previous state-of-the-art algorithms fail IRC safety in subtle ways, particularly when dealing with initial-state radiation from colliding protons.

Key findings include:

  • Kinematic Fidelity: In $WH$ production simulations, IFN-based jets matched the standard anti-$k_t$ $p_t$ spectrum perfectly, unlike the flavor-$k_t$ algorithm which showed significant deviations at high energies.
  • Improved Flavor Purity: In $Z+j$ tests, IFN significantly reduced the fraction of "multi-flavored" jets, providing a cleaner separation between quark and gluon jets.
  • Theoretical Stability: IFN passed all rigorous IRC safety checks, confirming its robustness for precision QCD calculations.

Conclusion

Interleaved Flavour Neutralisation provides a path forward for using flavored jets in precision physics without sacrificing the experimental advantages of the anti-$k_t$ algorithm. By interleaving flavor logic with standard clustering, IFN ensures both theoretical stability and experimental practicality. Future work will focus on the experimental implementation of these algorithms, potentially leveraging machine learning to handle the challenges of identifying low-energy flavored hadrons in a detector environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose extensions of the anti-$k_t$ and Cambridge/Aachen hierarchical jet clustering algorithms that are designed to retain the exact jet kinematics of these algorithms, while providing an infrared-and-collinear-safe definition of jet flavour at any fixed order in perturbation theory. Central to our approach is a new technique called Interleaved Flavour Neutralisation (IFN), whereby the treatment of flavour is integrated with, but distinct from, the kinematic clustering. IFN allows flavour information to be meaningfully accessed at each stage of the clustering sequence, which enables a consistent assignment of flavour both to individual jets and to their substructure. We validate the IFN approach using a dedicated framework for fixed-order tests of infrared and collinear safety, which also reveals unanticipated issues in earlier approaches to flavoured jet clustering. We briefly explore the phenomenological impact of IFN with anti-$k_t$ jets for benchmark tasks at the Large Hadron Collider.
BibTeX
@misc{caola2023flavoured,
  author = {Fabrizio Caola and R. P. Grabarczyk and Maxwell L. Hutt and Gavin P. Salam and L. M. Scyboz and Jesse Thaler},
  title = {{Flavoured jets with exact anti-$k\_t$ kinematics and tests of infrared and collinear safety}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2306.07314},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07314},
}
Pileup and Infrared Radiation Annihilation (PIRANHA): a paradigm for continuous jet groomingJournal of High Energy Physics · 2023
XCone: N-jettiness as an exclusive cone jet algorithmJournal of High Energy Physics · 2015
Resolving boosted jets with XConeJournal of High Energy Physics · 2015
Energy correlation functions for jet substructureJournal of High Energy Physics · 2013
Jet maximization, axis minimization, and stable cone findingPhysical · 2015
Fuzzy jetsJournal of High Energy Physics · 2016
Figure