Fixed-time Integral Sliding Mode Control for Admittance Control of a Robot Manipulator

Yuzhu Sun, Mien Van, Stephen McIlvanna, Seán F. McLoone, Dariusz CeglarekarXiv 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel control strategy, Fixed-time Integral Sliding Mode Control (FTISMC), for robot manipulators to enable safer and more efficient human-robot collaboration. By combining the compliance of admittance control with the robustness of ISMC and ensuring convergence within a guaranteed, fixed time, the proposed controller allows robots to safely interact with humans in uncertain environments, achieving faster and more accurate tracking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Physical human-robot collaboration (pHRC) is a rapidly growing field, enabling robots to work alongside humans in tasks like object handling. A critical challenge in pHRC is ensuring that robots can safely and effectively comply with human forces at the point of contact, rather than treating them as disruptive disturbances. Traditional control methods often struggle to balance robust trajectory tracking in uncertain environments with the necessary compliance. Furthermore, many existing control techniques lack guaranteed convergence times, making it difficult to predict system behavior. This paper addresses the need for a control system that can achieve both robust tracking and compliant interaction with humans, while also guaranteeing that the system's response occurs within a predictable, fixed timeframe, regardless of initial conditions.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of a Fixed-time Integral Sliding Mode Controller (FTISMC) for admittance control. Here's a breakdown of the key techniques:

  • Admittance Control Foundation: The system starts with an admittance control framework, which allows the robot to exhibit compliant behavior by translating external forces into desired motion. This is crucial for safe human interaction.
  • Integral Sliding Mode Control (ISMC): To enhance robustness against uncertainties and external disturbances, ISMC is employed. ISMC differs from traditional Sliding Mode Control (SMC) by eliminating the "reaching phase," ensuring that the system is robust from the outset.
  • Fixed-Time Convergence: The novelty lies in integrating "fixed-time" stability principles into the ISMC. This means the system's tracking error will converge to zero within a predetermined, finite time, irrespective of the initial state. This is achieved by designing specific sliding surfaces and control laws that leverage properties described in Lemmas 1, 2, and 3.
  • Non-Singular Sliding Surface: A significant challenge in fixed-time control is the potential for singularity issues when calculating derivatives. The authors introduce a "non-singular fixed-time sliding surface" to overcome this, making the controller more practical for real-world applications.
  • Fixed-Time Backstepping Control (BSP): A fixed-time backstepping controller is used as the nominal controller. This component is responsible for stabilizing the system in the absence of uncertainties, ensuring global fixed-time convergence.
  • Combined Approach: The proposed controller effectively combines these elements: admittance control for compliance, ISMC for robustness, and fixed-time principles for guaranteed and fast convergence, all while avoiding singularity issues.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is performed through simulations using a defined two-link robot manipulator model and simulated external human forces.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Guaranteed Convergence Time is Key for Safety: The ability to guarantee a fixed convergence time for the robot's response is a significant step towards predictable and safe human-robot interaction. This removes the uncertainty associated with traditional finite-time or asymptotic convergence.
  • Synergy of Admittance and Robust Control: Merging admittance control (for compliance) with robust control techniques like ISMC is essential for effective pHRC. This allows the robot to be both forgiving of human actions and resilient to environmental uncertainties.
  • Overcoming Singularity in Fixed-Time Control: The development of a non-singular sliding surface is a crucial practical advancement. It addresses a common theoretical hurdle in fixed-time control, making the proposed method more applicable.
  • Decoupled Design for Simplicity: The approach allows for separate design of the nominal controller and the reaching controller. This modularity simplifies the overall design process and preserves the benefits of each component.

Key Results

The paper validates the proposed FTISMC controller through simulations on a two-link robot manipulator. Key findings include:

  • Superior Tracking Performance: The FTISMC controller demonstrated significantly smaller tracking errors compared to PID, CTC, and various ISMC configurations (ISMC+PID, ISMC+CTC, ISMC+BSP).
  • Faster Convergence: The proposed controller achieved the shortest convergence time for the tracking error, a direct benefit of the fixed-time design.
  • Effective Compliance: The simulations showed that the robot could comply with external human forces, resulting in a reference trajectory that deviates from the desired trajectory when forces are applied, and then re-converges once forces are removed.
  • Smoother Control Input: The FTISMC controller generated smoother and more efficient control inputs for the robot's joints compared to other methods.
  • Quantitative Improvement: Table 1 shows Root Mean Square Errors (RMSE) for two joints, with the FTISMC+BSP achieving RMSE values in the order of $10^{-5}$ and $10^{-4}$, significantly outperforming other methods. For instance, Joint 1 RMSE was $5.7841 \times 10^{-5}$ for FTISMC+BSP, compared to $2.0901 \times 10^{-4}$ for ISMC+BSP.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The current work relies on simulations. Real-world implementation on platforms like the Baxter robot is needed to validate effectiveness and evaluate performance in actual operating conditions.
  • The paper mentions that the 'sign' function in the controller can lead to chattering, suggesting boundary layer methods or second-order super-twisting methods as potential solutions.
  • The paper assumes bounded uncertainties, which is a common assumption but might not hold in all extreme scenarios.
  • Future Work:
    • Develop and integrate a fixed-time force observer for external human forces.
  • Incorporate safety constraints into the system.
  • Test the system on a physical robotics platform (e.g., Baxter robot) to assess real-world performance and effectiveness.
  • Explore adaptive techniques to estimate or adapt to the bound of uncertainties, potentially eliminating the need for explicit parameter selection.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel fixed-time integral sliding mode controller for admittance control to enhance physical human-robot collaboration. The proposed method combines the benefits of compliance to external forces of admittance control and high robustness to uncertainties of integral sliding mode control (ISMC), such that the system can collaborate with a human partner in an uncertain environment effectively. Firstly, a fixed-time sliding surface is applied in the ISMC to make the tracking error of the system converge within a fixed-time regardless of the initial condition. Then, a fixed-time backstepping controller (BSP) is integrated into the ISMC as the nominal controller to realize global fixed-time convergence. Furthermore, to overcome the singularity problem, a non-singular fixed-time sliding surface is designed and integrated into the controller, which is useful for practical application. Finally, the proposed controller is validated for a two-link robot manipulator with uncertainties and external human forces. The results show that the proposed controller is superior in the sense of both tracking error and convergence time, and at the same time, can comply with human motion in a shared workspace.
BibTeX
@misc{sun2022fixed,
  author = {Yuzhu Sun and Mien Van and Stephen McIlvanna and Seán F. McLoone and Dariusz Ceglarek},
  title = {{Fixed-time Integral Sliding Mode Control for Admittance Control of a Robot Manipulator}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2208.05065},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.05065},
}
Figure