Five new synonyms in Epimedium (Berberidaceae) from China

Yanjun Zhang, Haishan Dang, Shengyu Li, Jianqiang Li, Ying WāngPhytoKeys 2015 · DOI

Abstract

The genus Epimedium (Berberidaceae) reaches its highest diversity in China, where many species have been described based on narrow morphological criteria. This study re-evaluates five such taxa through extensive herbarium review, field observations at type localities, and common-garden cultivation experiments. Our results demonstrate that several previously diagnostic characters, such as anther color and rhizome length, represent intra-specific variation rather than species-level distinctions. Consequently, five taxa are reduced to synonymy: E. chlorandrum under E. acuminatum; E. rhizomatosum under E. membranaceum; E. brachyrrhizum under E. leptorrhizum; E. dewuense under E. dolichostemon; and E. sagittatum var. oblongifoliolatum under E. borealiguizhouense.

Introduction

Taxonomy in high-diversity regions often suffers from "over-splitting," where environmental or developmental variations are mistaken for stable species traits. In China, which hosts 48 endemic Epimedium species, the proliferation of names complicates conservation and medicinal research. This paper addresses five specific cases of taxonomic redundancy by combining traditional herbarium work with modern field and cultivation techniques.

Methods

The authors employed a three-pronged approach to validate species boundaries:

  1. Herbarium Examination: Review of physical specimens and high-resolution images from over 15 major herbaria across China and Europe (including the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, and the Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle in Paris).
  2. Field Investigations: Observation of plants in their natural habitats across provinces like Sichuan, Guizhou, and Hubei, specifically targeting "type localities."
  3. Cultivation: Specimens were transplanted to the Wuhan Botanical Garden to observe if morphological differences (like rhizome length) persisted or converged when grown in a controlled, uniform environment.

Key Insights and Taxonomic Revisions

The "Green Anther" Fallacy

One of the most significant findings was the debunking of anther and pollen color as a stable diagnostic feature. Previously, E. chlorandrum was distinguished from E. acuminatum partly by its green anthers. The authors found that green anthers appear sporadically across several different Epimedium populations and are not a reliable way to define a species boundary.

Rhizome and Leaf Plasticity

The team discovered that rhizome morphology (compact vs. "long-creeping") can vary significantly within a single population. This invalidated the primary distinction for E. rhizomatosum and E. brachyrrhizum. Similarly, leaf hairiness (indumentum) was found to be a continuous spectrum of variation rather than a discrete trait.

Summary of New Synonyms

The paper officially designates the following five synonyms:

  • E. chlorandrum is now a synonym of E. acuminatum.
  • E. rhizomatosum is now a synonym of E. membranaceum.
  • E. brachyrrhizum is now a synonym of E. leptorrhizum.
  • E. dewuense is now a synonym of E. dolichostemon.
  • E. sagittatum var. *oblongifoliolatum is now a synonym of E. borealiguizhouense*.

Conservation and Future Work

Beyond nomenclature, the paper provides updated conservation assessments. Notably, the authors suggest that E. acuminatum be designated as Vulnerable (VU) due to heavy exploitation for traditional medicinal use, particularly in the Guizhou region.

While this morphological and field-based revision is rigorous, the authors note that future "integrative taxonomy"—combining physical traits with DNA sequencing—will be essential to further refine the relationships within these complex species groups, especially where morphological variation remains high.

Summary updated

Abstract

Five new synonyms in Chinese Epimedium are designated in the present paper. Epimediumchlorandrum is treated as a synonym of Epimediumacuminatum; Epimediumrhizomatosum as a synonym of Epimediummembranaceum; Epimediumbrachyrrhizum as a synonym of Epimediumleptorrhizum; Epimediumdewuense as a synonym of Epimediumdolichostemon; and Epimediumsagittatumvar.oblongifoliolatum as a synonym of Epimediumborealiguizhouense.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2015five,
  author = {Yanjun Zhang and Haishan Dang and Shengyu Li and Jianqiang Li and Ying Wāng},
  title = {{Five new synonyms in Epimedium (Berberidaceae) from China}},
  booktitle = {PhytoKeys},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.3897/phytokeys.49.8768},
}
Figure