Five- and 10-year survival rates after surgery for biliary atresia: a report from the Japanese biliary atresia registry

Masaki Nio, Ryoji Ohi, Takeshi Miyano, Morihiro Saeki, Kazuo Shiraki, Kōichi TanakaJournal of Pediatric Surgery 2003 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages the comprehensive Japanese Biliary Atresia Registry (JBAR) to analyze long-term survival rates following surgery for biliary atresia. It reveals that while overall survival rates have improved, the impact of surgical modifications on preventing complications like cholangitis is not statistically significant, and the age of operation remains a critical factor for long-term prognosis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Biliary atresia is a serious congenital condition where bile ducts are blocked, leading to liver damage and failure if untreated. The Kasai operation, a surgical procedure to bypass the blockage, is the standard treatment. However, its long-term efficacy and the impact of various surgical modifications on outcomes have remained subjects of ongoing investigation and debate. Specifically, understanding the survival rates over extended periods (5 and 10 years) and identifying factors that influence these outcomes are crucial for improving patient care. This paper addresses this by using a large, nationwide registry to provide robust data on these long-term results.

Methods

The study utilizes data from the Japanese Biliary Atresia Registry (JBAR), a nationwide registry established in 1989 by the Japanese Biliary Atresia Society. JBAR collects data through initial and annual follow-up questionnaires from participating institutions. The researchers analyzed data from 1,381 patients registered between 1989 and 1999. They evaluated epidemiological data, associated anomalies, types of obstruction, surgical procedures, and short- and long-term outcomes. For survival analysis, they focused on patients registered in or before 1994, analyzing 5-year survival for 735 patients and 10-year survival for 108 patients. Statistical analysis included chi-square tests for categorical variables and Student's t-tests for continuous variables, with a significance level of P < .05.

Datasets

The primary dataset for this study is the Japanese Biliary Atresia Registry (JBAR). This registry contains data on 1,381 patients with biliary atresia registered between 1989 and 1999 from 93 institutions across Japan. The data includes initial patient information, diagnosis, treatment details, and ongoing follow-up data on surgical revisions, liver transplantation, complications, and patient development.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of a National Registry: JBAR demonstrates the immense value of a centralized, long-term registry for tracking rare diseases and evaluating surgical outcomes across a large population. Its success in minimizing lost-to-follow-up cases (only 19 out of 735 for 5-year survival) is a testament to its robust system.
  • Age is Still a Critical Factor: Despite advancements, the age at which surgery is performed remains a significant determinant of long-term survival. Early diagnosis and intervention are strongly emphasized as crucial for better outcomes.
  • Surgical Modifications Show Limited Impact on Complications: While various modifications to the Roux-en-Y procedure (like adding an intestinal valve) were introduced to prevent cholangitis, the study found no statistically significant difference in the rate of jaundice disappearance or the incidence of cholangitis compared to the original Roux-en-Y. This suggests that while these modifications might have theoretical benefits, their practical impact on preventing these specific complications is not clearly demonstrated in this dataset.
  • Liver Transplantation is a Lifesaver, but Doesn't Erase the Need for Early Surgery: While liver transplantation (LTx) significantly improves survival rates, especially in the long term, the study highlights that it doesn't negate the importance of the initial Kasai operation. The data shows improved survival with LTx, but the overall 5-year survival rate didn't show a statistically significant improvement when considering all patients, suggesting that LTx is more of a rescue therapy for those who don't achieve long-term success with the Kasai procedure.

Key Results

  • Incidence: The incidence of biliary atresia in Japan was estimated at 1 in 9,640 live births.
  • Sex Distribution: A female predominance was observed with a sex ratio of 1:0.59 (863 girls to 507 boys).
  • Associated Anomalies: 19.6% of patients had congenital anomalies, with polysplenia being the most common (33 cases).
  • Type of Obstruction: Type III atresia at the porta hepatis was the most common (84.1%), followed by type I (11.9%) and type II (2.5%).
  • Age at Operation: While the impact on immediate bile flow wasn't clear until 90 days, surgery after 90 days led to worsened bile flow.
  • Surgical Procedures: The original Roux-en-Y procedure was the most common, used in over 50% of patients since 1995.
  • Survival Rates:
    • Overall 5-year survival rate was 75.3% (553 of 734).
  • Overall 10-year survival rate was 66.7% (72 of 108).
  • 5-year survival rates without LTx ranged from 52.7% to 62.0% for different registration years.
  • 5-year survival rates with LTx ranged from 69.4% to 78.3%.
  • 10-year survival rates were 66.7% with LTx and 52.8% without LTx.
  • Impact of Factors on 5-Year Survival (Without LTx): Age at operation and type of obstruction had a significant impact. Preoperative direct bilirubin and surgical modifications did not.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that not all patients with biliary atresia may have been registered, potentially affecting the precise incidence calculation.
  • While the study compared different surgical procedures, it did not assess the severity or outcome of cholangitis, making it difficult to definitively conclude the uselessness of certain modifications.
  • The impact of LTx on the overall 5-year survival rate was not statistically significant, possibly due to the increasing availability and use of LTx over time, which might have been used more in sicker patients.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that a longer follow-up study of the JBAR patients is needed to further elucidate the real role of the Kasai operation in biliary atresia. Continued monitoring and analysis of this registry will be crucial for understanding long-term trends and refining treatment strategies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{nio2003five,
  author = {Masaki Nio and Ryoji Ohi and Takeshi Miyano and Morihiro Saeki and Kazuo Shiraki and Kōichi Tanaka},
  title = {{Five- and 10-year survival rates after surgery for biliary atresia: a report from the Japanese biliary atresia registry}},
  journal = {Journal of Pediatric Surgery},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1016/s0022-3468(03)00178-7},
}
Figure