TL;DR
This paper introduces a new way to measure how "tree-like" a dataset is using a "hyperbolicity vector." They then develop an algorithm, HCCROOTEDTREEFIT, that leverages this measure to find better tree approximations of data, especially for the l1 error. This is important because it leads to more accurate representations of hierarchical data, which is crucial for fields like phylogenetic analysis and geometric machine learning.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Fitting tree structures to datasets is a fundamental problem with applications ranging from understanding evolutionary relationships (phylogenetics) to building efficient machine learning models (geometric graph neural networks). Many existing methods assume data is "generic" and doesn't have any special structure. However, real-world data often exhibits hierarchical or "tree-like" properties. The challenge is to develop methods that can effectively exploit these properties to create better tree fits, especially when considering the l1 norm of the distortion (which measures the total error across all pairs of points). Existing methods often struggle with this l1 error or don't have theoretical guarantees for it.
Methods
The paper introduces a novel concept: the hyperbolicity vector. Instead of just a single scalar value for hyperbolicity (like Gromov's $\delta$), they define a vector that captures the "tree-likeness" of all possible quadruples of points. They then define the average hyperbolicity as the l1 norm of this vector. This allows for a more nuanced understanding of a dataset's geometric structure.
The core algorithmic contribution is HCCROOTEDTREEFIT. This algorithm is built upon a hierarchical correlation clustering (HCC) approach. The key idea is to iteratively merge clusters based on a "highly connected" criterion, which is related to minimizing "bad triangles" (triples of points where only two of the three possible edges exist). This HCC algorithm, called HCCTRIANGLE, is then used to find an ultrametric fit (HCCULTRAFIT), which is subsequently transformed into a rooted tree fit. The paper provides theoretical guarantees for the l1 distortion of this tree fit, showing it's bounded by the average hyperbolicity of the input data.
Datasets
The paper evaluates their methods on:
- Common unweighted graph datasets: C-ELEGAN, CS PHD, CORA, and AIRPORT. These are standard datasets used in graph neural networks and are known to have some geometric considerations.
- Synthetic datasets: Generated from balanced trees and a tree dataset called DISEASE. These are designed to be "tree-like" and have low hyperbolicity.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Hyperbolicity Vector: Moving beyond a single scalar measure of hyperbolicity to a vector provides a richer characterization of a dataset's geometric structure, particularly its "tree-likeness."
- Average Hyperbolicity as a Proxy: The l1 norm of the hyperbolicity vector (average hyperbolicity) serves as a powerful proxy for how well a dataset can be represented by a tree metric, especially concerning l1 distortion.
- HCC for Tree Fitting: Hierarchical correlation clustering, when adapted to consider "bad triangles," provides an effective algorithmic framework for finding good ultrametric and tree fits.
- Real-world data is less tree-like than expected: Experiments reveal that commonly used datasets, even those assumed to be hierarchical, are significantly less "tree-like" than synthetic, truly tree-like datasets. This suggests a need for more refined geometric notions in machine learning.
Key Results
- Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides an algorithm (HCCROOTEDTREEFIT) that achieves an l1 distortion bounded by the average hyperbolicity of the data, with a growth function of O(n³). This bound is shown to be asymptotically tight.
- Empirical Performance: HCCROOTEDTREEFIT performs competitively with or better than existing methods like TREEREP and Gromov's algorithm, particularly for the l1 error. It is also efficient, running in O(n² log n) time.
- Data Set Characterization: Experiments highlight that common datasets exhibit significantly higher l1 errors (meaning poorer tree fits) compared to synthetic tree-like data. This indicates that these datasets are not as inherently tree-like as might be assumed.
Limitations and Future Work
- l∞ Distortion: While the algorithm excels at l1 distortion, it is noted that it is suboptimal for l∞ distortion (maximum distortion), as expected due to the nature of the l1 optimization.
- Refined Geometric Notions: The findings suggest that for applications like geometric graph neural networks, more sophisticated geometric concepts beyond simple tree-like assumptions might be necessary for datasets that are not truly tree-like.
- Practicality of LP-based methods: The paper mentions that LP-based algorithms for tree fitting exist but are computationally expensive. It would be interesting to analyze their performance under the new "tree-like" assumptions.
Summary updated