Fitness Cost of the Field-Evolved Resistance to Sulfoxaflor and Multi-Insecticide Resistance of the Wheat Aphid Sitobion miscanthi (Takahashi)

Xinan Li, Saige Zhu, Qiuchi Li, Yulin Sun, Yanbo Wang, Xujun Tian, Ran Xiao, Xiangrui Li, Yunhui Zhang, Haifeng Gao, Xun ZhuInsects 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the fitness costs and multi-insecticide resistance profiles of a field-evolved, sulfoxaflor-resistant wheat aphid population. The findings reveal that while resistance to sulfoxaflor comes with a significant fitness penalty, it also confers moderate resistance to pyrethroids, raising concerns about integrated pest management strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Insecticide resistance is a major threat to global food security, undermining the effectiveness of pest control strategies. Sulfoxaflor, a newer class of insecticide, is crucial for managing sap-feeding pests, including the economically important wheat aphid Sitobion miscanthi. However, the development of resistance to such insecticides, especially in field populations, poses a significant challenge. Understanding the fitness costs associated with resistance is vital for predicting resistance evolution and designing sustainable management plans. This paper addresses the critical need to characterize the resistance spectrum and fitness consequences of field-evolved sulfoxaflor resistance in S. miscanthi, particularly given that sulfoxaflor hasn't been extensively used in China for this pest.

Methods

The researchers employed two primary methodologies:

  • Insecticide Bioassays: A leaf-dip method was used to determine the toxicity of various insecticides to both a sulfoxaflor-susceptible (SS) and a sulfoxaflor-resistant (SulR) S. miscanthi population. This allowed for the calculation of median lethal concentrations (LC50) and relative resistance ratios (RR) for seven different insecticides.
  • Two-Sex Life Table Approach: This standard ecological technique was used to assess the biological fitness of the two aphid populations. By tracking individuals throughout their life cycle, researchers could quantify parameters such as developmental duration, longevity, fecundity, survival rates, and reproductive rates. The relative fitness (Rf) was calculated by comparing the net reproductive rates (R0) of the resistant and susceptible populations.

Datasets

The study utilized two field-collected populations of Sitobion miscanthi:

  • Sulfoxaflor-susceptible (SS) population: Collected from Hefei, Anhui province, China.
  • Sulfoxaflor-resistant (SulR) population: Collected from Kunming, Yunnan province, China.

These populations were reared on wheat seedlings under controlled laboratory conditions and were not previously exposed to pesticides.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Field-Evolved Resistance is Real: The study confirms the existence of S. miscanthi populations in the field that have evolved high resistance to sulfoxaflor, even without widespread, long-term use of this specific insecticide in the region.
  • Cross-Resistance Concerns: The sulfoxaflor-resistant population exhibited not only high resistance to sulfoxaflor but also moderate resistance to two pyrethroid insecticides (beta-cypermethrin and bifenthrin). This suggests a potential for multi-resistance development, complicating control strategies.
  • Fitness Cost is Significant: The development of sulfoxaflor resistance comes at a substantial biological cost. The resistant aphids showed a prolonged developmental period, lower survival rates, and reduced reproductive performance compared to their susceptible counterparts.
  • Pyrethroid Use May Drive Sulfoxaflor Resistance: The authors hypothesize that the widespread and consistent use of pyrethroids in China might have inadvertently selected for resistance mechanisms that also confer resistance to sulfoxaflor, or vice versa, due to shared metabolic pathways or other genetic links.

Key Results

  • The SulR population showed a relative insecticide resistance ratio (RR) of 199.8 for sulfoxaflor, indicating high resistance.
  • Moderate resistance was observed for beta-cypermethrin (RR = 14.5) and bifenthrin (RR = 42.1).
  • Low resistance was found for chlorpyrifos (RR = 5.7).
  • No significant resistance was detected for abamectin, imidacloprid, or thiamethoxam.
  • The SulR population had a relative fitness (Rf) of 0.73, meaning its overall reproductive capacity was reduced by 27% compared to the SS population.
  • Specific developmental stages (L4, pre-adult) and pre-reproductive periods were significantly longer in the SulR population.
  • Fecundity was significantly lower in the SulR population, with approximately 4.18 fewer offspring per aphid.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mechanism of Resistance: While the study demonstrates the existence of resistance and its fitness cost, the underlying molecular mechanisms (e.g., target-site mutations, enhanced metabolic detoxification) are not fully elucidated. The authors suggest that metabolic resistance might be a significant factor, but further investigation is needed.
  • Cross-Resistance Complexity: The observed cross-resistance patterns are not universal across all insect species, highlighting the need for species-specific resistance management strategies.
  • Field Validation: While the study uses field-evolved resistance, further field validation of these findings and the efficacy of different insecticide rotation strategies would be beneficial.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors emphasize the need for more thorough investigation into the field-evolved resistance of S. miscanthi to sulfoxaflor and its associated mechanisms. Understanding these complex interactions is crucial for developing effective and sustainable pest management programs.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sulfoxaflor belongs to a new class of insecticides that is effective against many sap-feeding pests. In this study on <i>Sitobion miscanthi</i> (Takahashi) (i.e., the predominant wheat pest), a highly sulfoxaflor-resistant (SulR) population was obtained from a field. Its resistance to the other seven insecticides and its biological fitness were analyzed using a leaf-dip method and a two-sex life table approach, respectively. Compared with the relatively susceptible (SS) population, the SulR population was highly resistant to sulfoxaflor, with a relative insecticide resistance ratio (RR) of 199.8 and was moderately resistant to beta-cypermethrin (RR = 14.5) and bifenthrin (RR = 42.1) but exhibited low resistance to chlorpyrifos (RR = 5.7). Additionally, the SulR population had a relative fitness of 0.73, with a significantly prolonged developmental period as well as a lower survival rate and poorer reproductive performance than the SS population. In conclusion, our results suggest that <i>S</i>. <i>miscanthi</i> populations that are highly resistant to sulfoxaflor exist in the field. The possibility that insects may develop multi-resistance between sulfoxaflor and pyrethroids is a concern. Furthermore, the high sulfoxaflor resistance of <i>S</i>. <i>miscanthi</i> was accompanied by a considerable fitness cost. The study data may be useful for improving the rational use of insecticides and for exploring novel insecticide resistance mechanisms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023fitness,
  author = {Xinan Li and Saige Zhu and Qiuchi Li and Yulin Sun and Yanbo Wang and Xujun Tian and Ran Xiao and Xiangrui Li and Yunhui Zhang and Haifeng Gao and Xun Zhu},
  title = {{Fitness Cost of the Field-Evolved Resistance to Sulfoxaflor and Multi-Insecticide Resistance of the Wheat Aphid Sitobion miscanthi (Takahashi)}},
  booktitle = {Insects},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/insects14010075},
}
Figure