Fisher Information Nonparametric Embedding

Kevin M. Carter, Raviv Raich, William G. Finn, Alfred O. Hero2009

TL;DR

This paper introduces Fisher Information Non-parametric Embedding (FINE), a novel framework for analyzing high-dimensional data that doesn't fit neatly into Euclidean spaces. By leveraging information geometry and approximating the Fisher Information Distance, FINE embeds complex data distributions into a lower-dimensional Euclidean space, enabling effective visualization, clustering, and classification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world datasets, like those from flow cytometry or document collections, are high-dimensional and don't naturally reside on a simple Euclidean manifold. Traditional manifold learning techniques often assume a Euclidean structure, which can be suboptimal or even misleading for such data. The challenge is to find a way to represent and analyze these complex, non-Euclidean data distributions effectively for tasks like clustering and classification, without prior knowledge of their underlying statistical model or parameterization.

Methods

FINE tackles this by:

  • Statistical Manifolds: Viewing data distributions as points on a statistical manifold, where the "distance" between distributions is measured by the Fisher Information Distance (FID).
  • Fisher Information Distance Approximation: Since the exact FID is often intractable without knowing the manifold's parameterization, FINE approximates it using non-parametric methods. This involves estimating probability density functions (PDFs) using Kernel Density Estimation (KDE) and then calculating divergences like the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence or Hellinger distance, which approximate FID.
  • Geodesic Approximation: For points that are not close on the manifold, FINE approximates the geodesic distance by treating the manifold as a graph and summing the distances between connected points.
  • Multi-Dimensional Scaling (MDS): Once a dissimilarity matrix (based on the approximated FID) is computed, classical MDS (cMDS) or Laplacian Eigenmaps are used to embed the data into a low-dimensional Euclidean space. This allows for visualization and subsequent analysis using standard machine learning techniques.

Datasets

  • Simulated Data: A "swiss roll" manifold of Gaussian distributions with constant covariance was used to demonstrate the reconstruction of the underlying manifold.
  • Flow Cytometry Data: Data from 23 patients with Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) and 20 patients with Mantle Cell Lymphoma (MCL), each represented by thousands of cells with 5 parameters.
  • 20 Newsgroups Dataset: A subset of the 20 Newsgroups dataset, focusing on four domains (comp, rec, sci, talk), was used for document classification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Information Geometry for Non-Euclidean Data: The paper highlights that information geometry provides a powerful framework for understanding relationships between probability distributions, which is crucial when Euclidean geometry fails.
  • Non-Parametric FID Approximation is Key: The ability to approximate the Fisher Information Distance without knowing the underlying statistical model or manifold parameterization is the core innovation, making the method broadly applicable.
  • FINE Enables Traditional ML: By embedding data into a low-dimensional Euclidean space, FINE makes it amenable to standard machine learning algorithms (like SVMs) that rely on Euclidean representations.
  • Visualization of Complex Data: FINE can reveal underlying structures and clusters in high-dimensional, non-Euclidean data that are invisible in traditional 2D scatter plots.

Key Results

  • Flow Cytometry: FINE successfully separated CLL and MCL patient data in a 2D embedding, revealing natural clusters that were difficult to discern using traditional scatter plots. This demonstrates its utility in biomedical applications for disease classification and patient comparison.
  • Document Classification: FINE, using Laplacian Eigenmaps and Hellinger distance, showed superior class separation for the 20 Newsgroups dataset compared to Principal Component Analysis (PCA). Classification rates using FINE with a linear SVM outperformed PCA, especially at lower dimensions, and were competitive with diffusion kernels, particularly at low sample sizes.
  • Simulated Data: FINE successfully reconstructed the underlying "swiss roll" manifold from sampled Gaussian distributions, demonstrating its ability to capture the intrinsic geometry of the data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Kernel Density Estimation Limitations: The paper acknowledges that KDE's mean squared error decreases slowly with high dimensionality, which could be an issue for very high-dimensional data. However, they state that density estimation is secondary to divergence estimation for their purposes.
  • Choice of Metric: The paper notes that the choice of metric (KL divergence, Hellinger distance) for approximating FID can be problem-dependent.
  • Future Work:
    • Exploring different classification methods (k-NN, various SVM kernels) to maximize performance.
  • Constraining dimensionality reduction to a sphere to allow for diffusion kernels in low-dimensional space.
  • Investigating the effect of out-of-sample extension.
  • Applying FINE to new domains like internet anomaly detection and face recognition.
  • Determining optimal non-linear kernels for specific problems.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problems of clustering, classification, and visualization of high-dimensional data when no straightforward euclidean representation exists. In this paper, we propose using the properties of information geometry and statistical manifolds in order to define similarities between data sets using the Fisher information distance. We will show that this metric can be approximated using entirely nonparametric methods, as the parameterization and geometry of the manifold is generally unknown. Furthermore, by using multidimensional scaling methods, we are able to reconstruct the statistical manifold in a low-dimensional euclidean space; enabling effective learning on the data. As a whole, we refer to our framework as Fisher Information Nonparametric Embedding (FINE) and illustrate its uses on practical problems, including a biomedical application and document classification.
BibTeX
@misc{carter2009fisher,
  author = {Kevin M. Carter and Raviv Raich and William G. Finn and Alfred O. Hero},
  title = {{Fisher Information Nonparametric Embedding}},
  year = {2009},
}
Figure