First results of the two square meters multilayer glass composite mirror design proposed for the Cherenkov Telescope Array developed at INFN

C. Schultz, M. Doro, Luigi Lessio, M. Mariotti, R. RandoarXiv 2015 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) is a future ground-based gamma-ray astronomy detector that will consist of more than 100 Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes of different sizes. The total reflective surface of roughly 10,000 m² requires unprecedented technological efforts towards a cost-efficient production of light-weight and reliable mirror substrates at high production rate. We report on a new mirror concept proposed for CTA developed by INFN, which is based on the replication from a spherical convex mold under low pressure. The mirror substrate is an open structure design made by thin glass layers at the mirror's front and rear interspaced by steel cylinders. A first series of nominal size mirrors has been produced, for which we discuss the optical properties in terms of radius of curvature and focusing power.

Introduction

The Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) represents the next frontier in ground-based gamma-ray astronomy. To achieve its scientific goals, the array requires over 100 telescopes of varying sizes, resulting in a total reflective surface area of approximately 10,000 m². For the Large Size Telescopes (LSTs), which are designed to detect the lowest energy gamma rays, the mirror facets must adhere to strict engineering constraints. Each facet must weigh less than 50 kg to maintain the structural integrity of the massive telescope frames, achieve a reflectivity greater than 85% in the 300–550 nm range, and provide precise focusing.

Because CTA telescopes operate in open-air environments without protective domes, the mirrors are subject to constant environmental stress, including temperature fluctuations, humidity, and dust. Consequently, there is a critical need for a mirror design that is lightweight, durable, and cost-effective for mass production.

Design and Fabrication

Researchers at the National Institute for Nuclear Physics (INFN) in Italy have proposed a novel "open structure" multilayer glass composite mirror to meet these requirements. The design focuses on a sandwich-like assembly that provides high rigidity while minimizing mass.

The fabrication process begins with a convex diamond-milled aluminum mold that defines the desired spherical curvature. Thin sheets of borosilicate glass (1.8 mm thick) are placed on the mold and shaped using a low-pressure vacuum (0.8 bar) applied through dedicated channels. This replication technique allows for high-fidelity shaping at room temperature.

Exploded view of the multilayer glass composite mirror assembly showing the glass layers and internal steel cylinders.

The core of the mirror consists of 63 stainless steel cylinders, each 60 mm in height, sandwiched between the front reflective layer and a rear multilayer glass base. This "open structure" is a key innovation; it allows water and condensation to drain freely through small holes, preventing internal moisture accumulation and subsequent corrosion or weight gain. The entire assembly is joined using a two-component epoxy paste cured at room temperature. This "cold bonding" approach is advantageous as it avoids the internal stresses and potential deformations associated with traditional high-temperature glass slumping.

The final reflective surface is not a single sheet but is instead composed of six equilateral triangles made of 2.0 mm thick Schott BOROFLOAT® 33 glass. These segments are coated with a multilayer of Al + SiO₂ + HfO₂ + SiO₂ to ensure high durability and peak reflectivity.

Experimental Evaluation and Results

To validate the design, a first series of nominal-sized prototypes was produced and subjected to optical testing. The primary evaluation tool was a 2f-setup, an optical configuration where a point-like light source is placed at twice the focal length of the mirror. The reflected light is then captured by a CCD camera at the same distance, allowing researchers to calculate the Radius of Curvature (RoC) and the Point Spread Function (PSF).

The prototype mirror assembly on a test stand (left) and individual components used in construction (center/right).

The initial performance metrics for the prototype are as follows:

  • Mass: The mirror assembly weighs approximately 42 kg, successfully meeting the <50 kg requirement for LST installation.
  • Radius of Curvature: The measured RoC was 57.9 ± 0.5 m, demonstrating excellent agreement with the mold's nominal specifications.
  • Reflectivity: The optical coating met the target, achieving >85% reflectance in the critical ultraviolet-to-blue wavelength range (300–550 nm).
  • Focusing Power: The $D_{80}$ (the diameter containing 80% of the reflected light) was measured at approximately 0.75 mrad.

Conclusion and Future Work

The INFN prototype demonstrates that a lightweight, open-structure composite design is a viable candidate for the CTA. It successfully meets weight and reflectivity targets while maintaining the intended curvature through a cost-effective replication process.

However, the current focusing power of 0.75 mrad exceeds the CTA's strict specification of <0.59 mrad. The research team identifies two primary causes for this: micro-waviness inherent in the commercial-grade glass used for the front surface and potential dust contamination on the mold during the vacuum replication phase. Future iterations will utilize higher-quality glass and improved clean-room protocols. Additionally, the team plans to conduct extensive outdoor durability tests to confirm the long-term stability of the open structure under real-world environmental conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) is a future ground-based gamma-ray astronomy detector that will consist of more than 100 Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes of different sizes. The total reflective surface of roughly 10 000 m$^2$ requires unprecedented technological efforts towards a cost-efficient production of light-weight and reliable mirror substrates at high production rate. We report on a new mirror concept proposed for CTA developed by INFN, which is based on the replication from a spherical convex mold under low pressure. The mirror substrate is an open structure design made by thin glass layers at the mirror's front and rear interspaced by steel cylinders. A first series of nominal size mirrors has been produced, for which we discuss the optical properties in terms of radius of curvature and focusing power.
BibTeX
@misc{schultz2015first,
  author = {C. Schultz and M. Doro and Luigi Lessio and M. Mariotti and R. Rando},
  title = {{First results of the two square meters multilayer glass composite mirror design proposed for the Cherenkov Telescope Array developed at INFN}},
  year = {2015},
  eprint = {1509.01044},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1509.01044},
}
Figure