First-principles molecular dynamics study of deuterium diffusion in liquid tin

Xiaohui Liu, Daye Zheng, Xinguo Ren, Lixin He, Mohan ChenThe Journal of Chemical Physics 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Understanding the retention of hydrogen isotopes in liquid metals, such as lithium and tin, is of great importance in designing a liquid plasma-facing component in fusion reactors. However, experimental diffusivity data of hydrogen isotopes in liquid metals are still limited or controversial. We employ first-principles molecular dynamics simulations to predict diffusion coefficients of deuterium in liquid tin at temperatures ranging from 573 to 1673 K. Our simulations indicate faster diffusion of deuterium in liquid tin than the self-diffusivity of tin. In addition, we find that the structural and dynamic properties of tin are insensitive to the inserted deuterium at temperatures and concentrations considered. We also observe that tin and deuterium do not form stable solid compounds. These predicted results from simulations enable us to have a better understanding of the retention of hydrogen isotopes in liquid tin.

Introduction

In the development of nuclear fusion reactors, the choice of plasma-facing components (PFCs) is critical. These components must withstand extreme heat and intense particle bombardment. While solid materials often suffer from erosion and degradation, liquid metals like lithium (Li) and tin (Sn) offer a "self-healing" alternative. Liquid tin is particularly attractive due to its low vapor pressure and safety profile. However, a major challenge lies in understanding how fusion fuel isotopes, such as deuterium (D), interact with these liquid metals. Issues like fuel retention and diffusion rates can significantly impact the efficiency of the fuel cycle. Given the scarcity and inconsistency of experimental data—often due to oxygen contamination in samples—computational studies are essential to provide reliable insights.

Computational Methodology and Validation

This study utilizes First-Principles Molecular Dynamics (FPMD) based on Density Functional Theory (DFT). Simulations were performed using the ABACUS package, which employs a Linear Combination of Atomic Orbitals (LCAO) basis set. This method offers a computationally efficient alternative to standard plane-wave approaches, allowing for the simulation of larger systems over longer timescales.

To ensure the reliability of the LCAO approach, the researchers first benchmarked it against known solid phases of tin ($\alpha$, $\beta$, bct, and bcc) and compared the results with both plane-wave (PW) calculations and experimental data.

Table 1: Validation of the LCAO method against plane-wave (PW) calculations and experimental data for various solid phases of tin.

As shown in Table 1, the LCAO results for lattice constants ($a_0$), atomic volumes ($V_0$), and bulk moduli ($B_0$) are in excellent agreement with both PW calculations and experimental values. Following this validation, the team modeled a 216-atom cell of liquid tin with deuterium concentrations ranging from 0.92% to 8.47% at temperatures between 573 K and 1673 K.

Results and Discussion

Structural and Dynamic Stability

A key finding of this research is that deuterium acts as a "ghost" guest within the liquid tin melt. Unlike liquid lithium, which forms stable solid compounds (lithium deuteride) that alter the material's properties, liquid tin's structure remains largely unaffected by the presence of deuterium. Analysis of the radial distribution function showed that the tin-tin interactions are insensitive to deuterium concentrations up to 8.47%. Furthermore, Sn-D bonds were found to be extremely transient, with lifetimes of only about 0.145 ps at 573 K, suggesting that deuterium atoms primarily occupy interstitial spaces rather than forming stable chemical bonds.

Deuterium Mobility

Deuterium exhibits high mobility in liquid tin, diffusing approximately 7.3 to 7.7 times faster than the host tin atoms. The study found that while the diffusion rate is highly sensitive to temperature, it is relatively independent of deuterium concentration. At 1073 K, the diffusion coefficient for deuterium was calculated to be between 5.2 and 6.9 Ų/ps, compared to a self-diffusivity of approximately 0.8 Ų/ps for tin.

The researchers derived an Arrhenius-style equation to describe the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficient ($D$): $$D(T) = 23.30 \times \exp\left(\frac{-11980 \text{ J}\cdot\text{mol}^{-1}}{RT}\right) \text{ [\AA}^2\text{/ps]}$$

System Size Effects

The study also highlighted the importance of simulation scale. It was observed that smaller 64-atom cells tend to underestimate diffusivity due to artificial periodic interactions. The use of a 216-atom cell provided more converged and accurate results, particularly for the diffusion coefficients.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The FPMD simulations provide a clear picture of deuterium behavior in liquid tin, characterizing it as a highly mobile species that does not disrupt the host metal's structure. This predictability makes liquid tin a promising candidate for fusion reactor PFCs.

Future research should aim to address the statistical noise encountered at very low deuterium concentrations by using even larger simulation cells. Additionally, investigating the behavior of tritium and exploring complex lithium-tin alloys could help identify optimized materials that balance the benefits of both metals for fusion applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the retention of hydrogen isotopes in liquid metals, such as lithium and tin, is of great importance in designing a liquid plasma-facing component in fusion reactors. However, experimental diffusivity data of hydrogen isotopes in liquid metals are still limited or controversial. We employ first-principles molecular dynamics simulations to predict diffusion coefficients of deuterium in liquid tin at temperatures ranging from 573 to 1673 K. Our simulations indicate faster diffusion of deuterium in liquid tin than the self-diffusivity of tin. In addition, we find that the structural and dynamic properties of tin are insensitive to the inserted deuterium at temperatures and concentrations considered. We also observe that tin and deuterium do not form stable solid compounds. These predicted results from simulations enable us to have a better understanding of the retention of hydrogen isotopes in liquid tin.
BibTeX
@article{liu2017first,
  author = {Xiaohui Liu and Daye Zheng and Xinguo Ren and Lixin He and Mohan Chen},
  title = {{First-principles molecular dynamics study of deuterium diffusion in liquid tin}},
  journal = {The Journal of Chemical Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1063/1.4997635},
}
Figure