First-Order Modular Logic Programs and their Conservative Extensions (Extended Abstract)

Amelia Harrison, Yuliya LierlerIJCAI 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "first-order modular logic programs" to break down complex logic programs into smaller, independently meaningful "modules." They also define "conservative extensions" to formally reason about how these modules can be rewritten or replaced without altering the overall program's stable models, providing a theoretical basis for common optimization techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Answer Set Programming (ASP) is a powerful paradigm for knowledge representation and combinatorial search. However, large and complex ASP programs can become difficult to understand, manage, and optimize. This paper addresses the challenge of modularizing these programs, allowing them to be viewed as collections of smaller, self-contained units with clear interfaces. Furthermore, it tackles the problem of formally justifying program rewritings, which are often used to improve performance but lack a rigorous theoretical foundation for ensuring they don't change the program's meaning (its stable models).

Methods

The core contribution is the introduction of first-order modular logic programs. These programs are collections of "def-modules," which are essentially first-order sentences wrapped with the SMp operator. The SMp operator, introduced by Ferraris et al., provides a semantics for first-order logic programs that operates directly on sentences without grounding and allows for a distinction between "extensional" (input) and "intensional" (output/auxiliary) predicates. This operator is key to defining modules that have a more intuitive meaning than traditional logic programs when considered in isolation.

The paper also introduces the concept of conservative extensions. A program P' is a conservative extension of P if their models correspond one-to-one, even if P' has a larger signature (more predicates/functions). This concept is crucial for reasoning about rewritings. The authors show that replacing def-modules with their conservative extensions results in a conservative extension of the original modular program. This provides a formal mechanism to prove that certain rewritings preserve the program's stable models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modularization for Clarity: The paper argues that breaking down large programs into modules with well-defined interfaces (using "intensional" and "extensional" predicates) leads to a more intuitive understanding of program components and facilitates incremental development.
  • Formalizing Rewriting: The concept of conservative extensions provides a rigorous mathematical framework to justify program transformations, moving beyond ad-hoc methods. This is particularly relevant for techniques like "projection rewriting," which aims to simplify programs by removing redundant variables.
  • SM Operator as a Foundation: The SM operator is presented as a powerful tool for defining semantics of modular programs, enabling a distinction between input and output predicates and avoiding the complexities of grounding.
  • Connecting Theory and Practice: The paper demonstrates how these theoretical concepts can be applied to real-world problems, using the Hamiltonian Cycle problem as a running example to illustrate the benefits of modularization and conservative extensions.

Key Results

The paper introduces the formal definitions of first-order modular logic programs and conservative extensions. It demonstrates how these concepts can be used to justify common program rewriting techniques, specifically projection rewriting. While no quantitative performance improvements are presented in this extended abstract, the theoretical framework is established to enable such optimizations. The authors show that conservative extensions allow reasoning about rewritings even when signatures differ, offering a generalization of strong equivalence.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper is presented as an extended abstract, suggesting that a more detailed exposition and empirical evaluation might exist elsewhere. A key limitation acknowledged is that current performance-enhancing rewritings are often done manually. The authors express their expectation that the theory of conservative extensions will provide a platform for automating such rewritings in the future. They also note that while their work relates to knowledge forgetting in propositional programs, their approach applies to first-order programs. Future work would likely involve exploring the application of these concepts to a wider range of ASP optimization techniques and developing automated tools for modular program construction and rewriting.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{harrison2017first,
  author = {Amelia Harrison and Yuliya Lierler},
  title = {{First-Order Modular Logic Programs and their Conservative Extensions (Extended Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2017/682},
}
Figure