First-order control of basaltic sources on the diversity of Archean TTG magmatism

Denggang Lu, Shuwen Liu, Peter A. Cawood, Lei Gao, Guozheng Sun, Jiachen Yao, Xin He, Wei WangResearch Square 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Tonalite-trondhjemite-granodiorite (TTG) gneisses are the primary components of Archean continental crust. While their chemical diversity has long been attributed to varying melting pressures, this study demonstrates that the composition of the basaltic source is the first-order control. Using geochemical analysis and thermodynamic modeling of late Neoarchean TTGs from the Jiaobei terrane, North China Craton, researchers show that $TiO_2$ and heavy rare earth element (HREE) contents in the source basalt dictate the resulting TTG chemistry. This finding suggests that previous estimates of early crustal thickness may be inaccurate. A new source-based classification is proposed, with a significant shift toward low-Ti-HREE TTGs around 3.2 Ga marking the global development of thickened continental crust.

Introduction

The Archean eon (4.0 to 2.5 billion years ago) was the era of continental birth, characterized by the formation of Tonalite-Trondhjemite-Granodiorite (TTG) gneisses. To reconstruct the tectonic architecture of the early Earth, geologists analyze the chemistry of these rocks to infer the pressure and temperature (P-T) conditions of their parent basaltic melts. Historically, researchers have assumed a uniform "average" Archean basalt as the source. However, Archean basalts are geochemically diverse. This study addresses whether TTG diversity is inherited from these varying sources rather than solely from melting depth, a distinction that could fundamentally change our understanding of early crustal thickness.

Methodology

The research focused on the Jiaobei terrane in the North China Craton, which contains a suite of late Neoarchean TTGs representative of the global compositional spectrum. The team utilized:

  • Geochemical Fingerprinting: Whole-rock major and trace element analysis combined with Zircon U-Pb-Lu-Hf isotopes to link TTG subgroups to specific basaltic "parents."
  • Thermodynamic Modeling: Using Perple_X software to calculate phase diagrams (P-T pseudosections) for three distinct basaltic sources (S1, S2, and S3).
  • Trace Element Modeling: Batch partial melting equations were applied to determine if modeled melts from these sources could reproduce observed TTG chemistry.
  • Global Meta-analysis: A compilation of over 1,500 basalts and 2,400 TTGs from the GEOROC database and previous landmark studies was analyzed to validate local findings on a global scale.

Results and Discussion

The Primacy of Source Composition

The study reveals that the chemical diversity of TTGs is primarily determined by the $TiO_2$ and heavy rare earth element (HREE) content of their basaltic sources. Crucially, a "high-pressure" signature in a TTG—often used to infer deep crustal roots—might instead result from melting a specific type of low-Ti basalt at only moderate pressures.

The "Pressure Trap" and Crustal Estimates

The authors demonstrate a "pressure trap": if a standard basaltic source is assumed when the actual source was lower in $TiO_2$ and HREEs, the inferred melting pressure can be overestimated by several kilobars. This suggests that many previous reconstructions of early Earth's tectonic depth may need recalibration.

A New Classification and the 3.2 Ga Shift

The researchers propose a source-based twofold classification: low-Ti-HREE and high-Ti-HREE TTGs. Global data indicates a synchronized drop in $TiO_2$ and HREEs in both basalts and TTGs around 3.2 billion years ago. This "outburst" of low-Ti-HREE TTGs likely marks a transition toward globally thickened continental crust (up to ~60 km), potentially driven by horizontal crustal thrusting or magmatic thickening as the mantle cooled.

Conclusion

This study shifts the paradigm of TTG formation from a pressure-dominated model to one where source composition is the first-order control. By accounting for the specific "flavor" of the starting basaltic rock, geologists can more accurately determine the geothermal gradients and crustal thicknesses of the early Earth. The identified shift at 3.2 Ga provides a critical temporal marker for the development of stable, thickened continental lithosphere.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Tonalite-trondhjemite-granodiorite (TTG) gneisses, the major components of Archean continental crust, show a broad compositional range. Most were viewed as crust-derived, and the inferred melting P-T conditions shaped our knowledge about the origin of early continental crust. While one single basaltic source (e.g., median of Archean tholeiites) was commonly invoked for different TTG gneisses, the potential influences of wide-ranging basaltic sources remain not well constrained. Late Neoarchean tonalitic to trondhjemitic gneisses, covering the compositional spectrum of global database, were identified from the Jiaobei terrane, North China Craton. Thermodynamic and trace element modeling demonstrates that (1) their chemical diversity is primarily determined by different basaltic sources with variable TiO2 and heavy rare earth element (HREE) contents; and (2) the inferred melting pressures of most tonalitic to trondhjemitic gneisses would reduce dramatically if a different basaltic source with slightly lower TiO2 and HREE contents was assumed. Integrated with synchronous chemical changes of global Archean TTG and basaltic rocks, a source-based twofold classification of TTG gneisses (i.e., low- and high-Ti-HREE types) is put forward. The low-Ti-HREE TTG gneisses necessitate both low-Ti-HREE basaltic sources and high melting pressures (~1.8 GPa), and their outburst after ~3.2 Ga may mark the development of thickened continental crust globally.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2023first,
  author = {Denggang Lu and Shuwen Liu and Peter A. Cawood and Lei Gao and Guozheng Sun and Jiachen Yao and Xin He and Wei Wang},
  title = {{First-order control of basaltic sources on the diversity of Archean TTG magmatism}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-2986195/v1},
}
Figure