First observations of core-transiting seismic phases on Mars

J. C. E. Irving, V. Lekić, Cecilia Durán, M. Drilleau, Doyeon Kim, Attilio Rivoldini, Amir Khan, Henri Samuel, Daniele Antonangeli, W. B. Banerdt, Caroline Beghein, Ebru Bozdağ, Savas Ceylan, Constantinos Charalambous, John Clinton, Paul M. Davis, R. García, Domenico Giardini, Anna Horleston, Quancheng Huang, K. Hurst, Taïchi Kawamura, Scott D. King, Martin Knapmeyer, Jiaqi Li, Philippe Lognonné, Ross Maguire, M. P. Panning, Ana‐Catalina Plesa, Martín Schimmel, N. C. Schmerr, Simon C. Stähler, É. Stutzmann, Zongbo XuProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

For the first time, scientists have detected seismic waves that have traveled through the core of Mars, thanks to data from the InSight mission. These observations provide the first direct seismic constraints on the Martian core's elastic properties, suggesting it's slightly smaller and denser than previously thought, and rich in light alloying elements like sulfur, oxygen, carbon, and hydrogen.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the interior of planets is crucial for deciphering their formation and evolution. While we have a good grasp of Earth's core thanks to a global network of seismometers and numerous large earthquakes, Mars presents a significant challenge. With only one seismometer (InSight) and relatively few seismic events, probing Mars' deep interior, especially its core, has been extremely difficult. Previous studies relied on indirect methods like core-reflected waves (ScS) or the planet's tidal response, which provided estimates for the core's radius and density but offered limited insight into its elastic properties or composition. The key challenge was to detect seismic waves that actually passed through the core, as these carry direct information about its internal structure and material properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to detect and analyze core-transiting seismic waves, specifically the SKS phase.

  • Seismic Wave Detection: They utilized five different methods to identify the SKS phase in the seismograms from two farside seismic events (S0976a and S1000a). These methods included:
  • Arrival Detection Techniques (A-C): These methods focused on identifying wave packets with specific characteristics, such as polarization and frequency content, expected for SKS. Frequency-dependent polarization analysis (FDPA) was a key technique here.
  • Cross-Correlation Methods (D-E): These methods used the waveform of a mantle-traversing phase (SS) as a template to find the SKS arrival by looking for similar patterns in the seismograms.
  • Seismic Inversion: To translate the travel time measurements into physical properties, the team performed Bayesian inversions. This involved:
  • Parameterization: They described the core's thermo-elastic properties using an isentropic third-order Birch-Murnaghan equation of state, characterized by density, adiabatic bulk modulus, and its pressure derivative at the core-mantle boundary (CMB).
  • Constraints: The inversions were constrained by the measured SKS differential travel times, as well as existing geophysical data (planetary density and moment of inertia) and travel times from mantle-sensitive phases.
  • Compositional Inferences: The seismically derived models were then used to infer the abundance of light alloying elements (sulfur, oxygen, carbon, and hydrogen) by comparing the predicted core properties with equations of state for various iron alloys.

Datasets

  • InSight Mission Seismic Data: The primary dataset used was the seismic waveform data collected by the InSight mission's seismometer on Mars.
  • Mars Quake Service (MQS) Catalogue: This catalogue provided details on seismic events, including their locations and phase picks, which were crucial for identifying the target events (S0976a and S1000a).
  • Orbital Imaging Data: This data was used to confirm that one of the seismic events (S1000a) was an impact.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Direct Core Probing is Possible: The successful detection of SKS waves demonstrates that even with a single seismometer, it's possible to obtain direct seismic information about a planet's core. This opens up new avenues for planetary seismology.
  • Mars' Core is Likely Smaller and Denser: The SKS travel times suggest a slightly smaller core radius (median 1,780-1,810 km) and a denser core (6.2-6.3 g/cm³) compared to some previous estimates. This challenges models that might have assumed a larger, less dense core.
  • Light Elements are Abundant: The seismic data strongly supports the presence of a significant fraction of light alloying elements in Mars' core, estimated to be around 20-22 wt%. This is higher than what's inferred for Earth's core.
  • SKS is a Powerful Tool: The SKS phase, by traversing the core, provides crucial information that mantle-reflected phases alone cannot. Its travel time relative to mantle phases is a sensitive indicator of core properties.

Key Results

  • First SKS Observations: The paper reports the first direct observations of seismic waves (SKS) that have propagated through the Martian core.
  • Constrained Core Properties: The SKS travel times, when combined with other geophysical data, have allowed for the first seismically constrained models of Mars' core's elastic properties.
  • Median Core Radius: Models informed by SKS data favor a median core radius of 1,780 to 1,810 km.
  • Median Core Density: The inferred median core density is 6.2 to 6.3 g/cm³.
  • P-wave Velocity at CMB: The P-wave velocity at the core-mantle boundary (CMB) is estimated to be 4.9 to 5.0 km/s.
  • Light Element Abundance: Mars' core is estimated to contain a median of 20 to 22 wt% light alloying elements (sulfur, oxygen, carbon, and hydrogen).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mantle Uncertainty: The composition and structure of Mars' mantle remain a significant source of uncertainty, influencing the precise interpretation of the core properties.
  • Limited Events: The analysis is based on only two farside seismic events. More events, especially those with different epicentral distances and azimuths, would significantly improve the resolution and robustness of the models.
  • One Seismometer: The single seismometer limits the ability to resolve 3D variations within the planet.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for future geophysical missions to Mars, particularly those with a multilocation network of seismometers, to refine these models and gain a more comprehensive understanding of the Martian core and interior structure. Further analysis of existing InSight data may also help refine models. Joint investigations of the core and lowermost mantle are also highlighted as an important future step.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present the first observations of seismic waves propagating through the core of Mars. These observations, made using seismic data collected by the InSight geophysical mission, have allowed us to construct the first seismically constrained models for the elastic properties of Mars' core. We observe core-transiting seismic phase SKS from two farside seismic events detected on Mars and measure the travel times of SKS relative to mantle traversing body waves. SKS travels through the core as a compressional wave, providing information about bulk modulus and density. We perform probabilistic inversions using the core-sensitive relative travel times together with gross geophysical data and travel times from other, more proximal, seismic events to seek the equation of state parameters that best describe the liquid iron-alloy core. Our inversions provide constraints on the velocities in Mars' core and are used to develop the first seismically based estimates of its composition. We show that models informed by our SKS data favor a somewhat smaller (median core radius = 1,780 to 1,810 km) and denser (core density = 6.2 to 6.3 g/cm<sup>3</sup>) core compared to previous estimates, with a P-wave velocity of 4.9 to 5.0 km/s at the core-mantle boundary, with the composition and structure of the mantle as a dominant source of uncertainty. We infer from our models that Mars' core contains a median of 20 to 22 wt% light alloying elements when we consider sulfur, oxygen, carbon, and hydrogen. These data can be used to inform models of planetary accretion, composition, and evolution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{irving2023first,
  author = {J. C. E. Irving and V. Lekić and Cecilia Durán and M. Drilleau and Doyeon Kim and Attilio Rivoldini and Amir Khan and Henri Samuel and Daniele Antonangeli and W. B. Banerdt and Caroline Beghein and Ebru Bozdağ and Savas Ceylan and Constantinos Charalambous and John Clinton and Paul M. Davis and R. García and Domenico Giardini and Anna Horleston and Quancheng Huang and K. Hurst and Taïchi Kawamura and Scott D. King and Martin Knapmeyer and Jiaqi Li and Philippe Lognonné and Ross Maguire and M. P. Panning and Ana‐Catalina Plesa and Martín Schimmel and N. C. Schmerr and Simon C. Stähler and É. Stutzmann and Zongbo Xu},
  title = {{First observations of core-transiting seismic phases on Mars}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2217090120},
}
Figure