First Observation of a Three-Resonance Structure in $e^+e^-\rightarrow$Nonopen Charm Hadrons

Besiii Collaboration, F. De Mori, М. Н. Ачасов, P. Adlarson, X. Ai, R. Aliberti, A. Amoroso, M. R. An, Q. An, Y. Bai, O. Bakina, I. Balossino, Y. Ban, H. -r. Bao, V. Batozskaya, K. Begzsuren, N. Berger, M. Berlowski, M. Bertani, D. Bettoni, F. Bianchi, E. Bianco, A. Bortone, I. Boyko, R. A. Briere, A. Brueggemann, H. Cai, X. Z. Cai, A. Calcaterra, G. F. Cao, N. Cao, Selim Çetin, J. F. Chang, T. T. Chang, W. L. Chang, G. R. Che, G. Chelkov, C. Chen, Guihai Chen, H. S. Chen, M. L. Chen, S. J. Chen, T. Chen, X. R. Chen, Y. B. Chen, Z. J. Chen, S. K. Choi, X. Chu, G. Cibinetto, S. C. Coen, F. Cossio, J. J. Cui, H. L. Dai, J. P. Dai, A. Dbeyssi, R. E. de Boer, D. Dedovich, Z. Y. Deng, A. Denig, I. Denysenko, M. Destefanis, B. Ding, X. X. Ding, Y. Ding, J. Dong, L. Y. Dong, M. Y. Dong, X. Dong, M. C. Du, S. X. Du, Z. H. Duan, P. Egorov, Y. H. Fan, J. Fang, S. S. Fang, Wenxing Fang, Y. Fang, R. Farinelli, L. Fava, F. Feldbauer, G. Felici, C. Q. Feng, J. H. Feng, K. Fischer, M. Fritsch, C. D. Fu, J. Fu, Y. W. Fu, H. Gao, Y. N. Gao, S. GarbolinoarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We report the measurement of the inclusive cross sections for $e^+e^-\rightarrow$nOCH (where nOCH denotes non-open charm hadrons) with improved precision at center-of-mass (c.m.) energies from 3.645 to 3.871 GeV. We observe three resonances: $\mathcal R(3760)$, $\mathcal R(3780)$, and $\mathcal R(3810)$ with significances of $8.1\sigma$, $13.7\sigma$, and $8.8\sigma$, respectively. The $\mathcal R(3810)$ state is observed for the first time, while the $\mathcal R(3760)$ and $\mathcal R(3780)$ states are observed for the first time in the nOCH cross sections. Two sets of resonance parameters describe the energy-dependent line shape of the cross sections well. In set I [set II], the $\mathcal R(3810)$ state has mass $(3805.7 \pm 1.1 \pm 2.7)$ [$(3805.7 \pm 1.1 \pm 2.7)$] MeV/$c^2$, total width $(11.6 \pm 2.9 \pm 1.9)$ [$(11.5 \pm 2.8 \pm 1.9)$] MeV, and an electronic width multiplied by the nOCH decay branching fraction of $(10.9\pm 3.8\pm 2.5)$ [$(11.0\pm 3.4\pm 2.5)$] eV. In addition, we measure the branching fractions ${\mathcal B}[{\mathcal R}(3760)\rightarrow$nOCH$]=(25.2 \pm 16.1 \pm 30.4)\% [(6.4 \pm 4.8 \pm 7.7)\%]$ and ${\mathcal B}[\mathcal R(3780)\rightarrow$nOCH$]=(12.3 \pm 6.6 \pm 8.3)\% [(10.4 \pm 4.8 \pm 7.0)\%]$ for the first time. The $\mathcal R(3760)$ state can be interpreted as an open-charm (OC) molecular state, but containing a simple four-quark state component. The $\mathcal R(3810)$ state can be interpreted as a hadrocharmonium state.

Introduction

In the framework of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), quarks are bound by the strong force. For decades, research focused on "charmonium" states—particles composed of a charm quark and a charm antiquark ($c\bar{c}$). Above the "open-charm threshold," these states typically decay into $D$ meson pairs, known as open-charm (OC) decay. However, theory suggests the existence of high-energy states that prefer to remain bound as $c\bar{c}$ systems while emitting light particles, or even more exotic structures like tetraquarks and hadronic molecules. These "non-open charm" (nOCH) decays are rare and difficult to isolate, making them a key frontier for discovering new forms of matter. This study maps these resonances in the energy range just above the open-charm threshold.

Experimental Methodology

The study was conducted using the BESIII detector at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPCII), analyzing $e^+e^-$ collisions at 42 center-of-mass energies between 3.645 and 3.871 GeV. The researchers measured the inclusive cross-section for all nOCH production, employing sophisticated track and energy requirements to suppress backgrounds from electromagnetic processes (like Bhabha scattering) and dominant open-charm decays. A total integrated luminosity of 75.5 pb⁻¹ was analyzed, with Monte Carlo simulations (using KKMC, EVTGEN, BABAYAGA, and TWOGAM) used for efficiency determination and background estimation.

Observation of the Three-Resonance Structure

The primary finding of this research is that the energy-dependent cross-section data cannot be explained by standard charmonium models alone. A three-resonance fit was required to accurately describe the observed peaks and dips in the cross-section.

Fit to the $e^+e^-\rightarrow$nOCH cross sections showing the three-resonance structure.

The analysis revealed three distinct resonances with high statistical significance:

  • $\mathcal{R}(3760)$: Significance of $8.1\sigma$.
  • $\mathcal{R}(3780)$: Significance of $13.7\sigma$.
  • $\mathcal{R}(3810)$: Significance of $8.8\sigma$ (First observation).

Resonance Parameters and Interpretations

The $\mathcal{R}(3810)$ state, observed for the first time, has a mass of $3805.7 \pm 1.1 \pm 2.7$ MeV/$c^2$. Its proximity to the $h_c\pi^+\pi^-$ threshold suggests it may be a hadrocharmonium state—a compact charmonium core embedded in a cloud of lighter quarks. The $\mathcal{R}(3760)$ state, with a mass near the $D^+D^-$ threshold, is interpreted as an open-charm molecular state, potentially containing a tetraquark component.

Measured resonance parameters for the two fit results.

As shown in the table above, two mathematical solutions (Result I and Result II) describe the data equally well, leading to some ambiguity in the branching fractions and electronic widths. For instance, the branching fraction ${\mathcal B}[{\mathcal R}(3760)\rightarrow$nOCH$]$ varies significantly between the two results ($25.2\%$ vs $6.4\%$).

Conclusion

This work provides the first evidence of a three-resonance structure in the nOCH cross-section above the open-charm threshold. While the discovery of $\mathcal{R}(3810)$ and the characterization of $\mathcal{R}(3760)$ and $\mathcal{R}(3780)$ offer exciting hints of exotic matter, significant uncertainties remain. Future experiments with larger data samples will be essential to resolve the ambiguities between the two fit results and confirm the internal structures of these newly observed states.

Summary updated

Abstract

We report the measurement of the inclusive cross sections for $e^+e^-$$\rightarrow$nOCH (where nOCH denotes non-open charm hadrons) with improved precision at center-of-mass (c.m.) energies from 3.645 to 3.871 GeV. We observe three resonances: $\mathcal R(3760)$, $\mathcal R(3780)$, and $\mathcal R(3810)$ with significances of $8.1σ$, $13.7σ$, and $8.8σ$, respectively. The $\mathcal R(3810)$ state is observed for the first time, while the $\mathcal R(3760)$ and $\mathcal R(3780)$ states are observed for the first time in the nOCH cross sections. Two sets of resonance parameters describe the energy-dependent line shape of the cross sections well. In set I [set II], the $\mathcal R(3810)$ state has mass $(3805.7 \pm 1.1 \pm 2.7)$ [$(3805.7 \pm 1.1 \pm 2.7)$] MeV/$c^2$, total width $(11.6 \pm 2.9 \pm 1.9)$ [$(11.5 \pm 2.8 \pm 1.9)$] MeV, and an electronic width multiplied by the nOCH decay branching fraction of $(10.9\pm 3.8\pm 2.5)$ [$(11.0\pm 3.4\pm 2.5)$] eV. In addition, we measure the branching fractions ${\mathcal B}[{\mathcal R}(3760)$$\rightarrow$nOCH$]=(25.2 \pm 16.1 \pm 30.4)\% [(6.4 \pm 4.8 \pm 7.7)\%]$ and ${\mathcal B}[\mathcal R(3780)$$\rightarrow$nOCH$]=(12.3 \pm 6.6 \pm 8.3)\% [(10.4 \pm 4.8 \pm 7.0)\%]$ for the first time. The $\mathcal R(3760)$ state can be interpreted as an open-charm (OC) molecular state, but containing a simple four-quark state component. The $\mathcal R(3810)$ state can be interpreted as a hadrocharmonium state.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2023first,
  author = {BESIII Collaboration and F. De Mori and М. Н. Ачасов and P. Adlarson and X. Ai and R. Aliberti and A. Amoroso and M. R. An and Q. An and Y. Bai and O. Bakina and I. Balossino and Y. Ban and H. -R. Bao and V. Batozskaya and K. Begzsuren and N. Berger and M. Berlowski and M. Bertani and D. Bettoni and F. Bianchi and E. Bianco and A. Bortone and I. Boyko and R. A. Briere and A. Brueggemann and H. Cai and X. Z. Cai and A. Calcaterra and G. F. Cao and N. Cao and Selim Çetin and J. F. Chang and T. T. Chang and W. L. Chang and G. R. Che and G. Chelkov and C. Chen and Chao Chen and Guihai Chen and H. S. Chen and M. L. Chen and S. J. Chen and S. L. Chen and S. M. Chen and T. Chen and X. R. Chen and X. T. Chen and Y. B. Chen and Y. Q. Chen and Z. J. Chen and S. K. Choi and X. Chu and G. Cibinetto and S. C. Coen and F. Cossio and J. J. Cui and H. L. Dai and J. P. Dai and A. Dbeyssi and R. E. de Boer and D. Dedovich and Z. Y. Deng and A. Denig and I. Denysenko and M. Destefanis and F. De Mori and B. Ding and X. X. Ding and Y. Ding and Y. Ding and J. Dong and L. Y. Dong and M. Y. Dong and X. Dong and M. C. Du and S. X. Du and Z. H. Duan and P. Egorov and Y. H. Fan and J. Fang and S. S. Fang and Wenxing Fang and Y. Fang and Y. Q. Fang and R. Farinelli and L. Fava and F. Feldbauer and G. Felici and C. Q. Feng and J. H. Feng and K. Fischer and M. Fritsch and C. D. Fu and J. Fu and Y. W. Fu and H. Gao and Y. N. Gao and Yang Gao and S. Garbolino},
  title = {{First Observation of a Three-Resonance Structure in $e^+e^-\textbackslash\{\}rightarrow$Nonopen Charm Hadrons}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2307.10948},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10948},
}
Figure