First measurement of the yield of $^8$He isotopes produced in liquid scintillator by cosmic-ray muons at Daya Bay
Daya Bay Collaboration, Fengpeng An, Wei Bai, A. B. Balantekin, M. Bishai, S. Blyth, G. F. Cao, Jun Cao, J. F. Chang, Y. Chang, Hui Chen, Shao-Long Chen, Ye Chen, Z. Y. Chen, Jie Cheng, Yin Cheong Cheng, Z. K. Cheng, J. J. Cherwinka, M. C. Chu, J. P. Cummings, Olivia Dalager, F. S. Deng, X. Y. Ding, M. V. Diwan, T. Dohnal, Dmitry Dolzhikov, J. Dove, Katherine Dugas, Hongyue Duyang, D. A. Dwyer, J. P. Gallo, M. Gonchar, G. H. Gong, Haipeng Gong, W. Gu, J. Y. Guo, L. Guo, X. H. Guo, Yingjun Guo, Z. J. Guo, R. Hackenburg, Y. Han, S. Hans, M. He, K. M. Heeger, Y. K. Heng, Y. K. Hor, Y. Hsiung, Beibei Hu, Z. Hu, J. F. Hu, H. X. Huang, Jihong Huang, X. T. Huang, Y. B. Huang, Patrick Huber, D. E. Jaffe, K. L. Jen, X. L. Ji, R. A. Johnson, D. Jones, L. Kang, S. H. Kettell, S. Kohn, M. Krämer, T. J. Langford, J. Lee, R. T. Lei, R. Leitner, J. K. C. Leung, Li Fei, H. L. Li, J. J. Li, R. H. Li, S. Li, W. D. Li, X. N. Li, Yufeng Li, Z. B. Li, H. Liang, C. J. Lin, G. L. Lin, J. J. Ling, J. M. Link, L. Littenberg, B. R. Littlejohn, J. C. LiuarXiv2024 · DOI · arXiv
Daya Bay presents the first measurement of cosmogenic $^8$He isotope production in liquid scintillator, using an innovative method for identifying cascade decays of $^8$He and its child isotope, $^8$Li. We also measure the production yield of $^9$Li isotopes using well-established methodology. The results, in units of $10^{-8} \mu^{-1} g^{-1} cm^2$, are $0.307 \pm 0.042$, $0.341 \pm 0.040$, and $0.546 \pm 0.076$ for $^8$He, and $6.73 \pm 0.73$, $6.75 \pm 0.70$, and $13.74 \pm 0.82$ for $^9$Li at average muon energies of 63.9 GeV, 64.7 GeV, and 143.0 GeV, respectively. The measured production rate of $^8$He isotopes is more than an order of magnitude lower than any other measurement of cosmogenic isotope production. It replaces the results of previous attempts to determine the ratio of $^8$He to $^9$Li production that yielded a wide range of limits from 0 to 30%. The results provide future liquid-scintillator-based experiments with improved ability to predict cosmogenic backgrounds.
Introduction
In high-precision neutrino physics, identifying and mitigating background signals is paramount. Experiments like Daya Bay search for reactor antineutrinos via Inverse Beta Decay (IBD), which produces a prompt positron signal followed by a delayed neutron capture. A primary source of irreducible background is the production of cosmogenic isotopes, specifically $^9$Li and $^8$He, by cosmic-ray muons interacting with the liquid scintillator. These isotopes undergo $\beta$-$n$ decay, creating a signature that mimics IBD events. While the yield of $^9$Li is well-studied, $^8$He has remained elusive due to its low production rate and the difficulty of distinguishing it from $^9$Li, leading to significant uncertainties in background models.
Methodology: Cascade Decay Identification
To isolate the $^8$He signal, the Daya Bay collaboration developed a novel "cascade decay" identification method. This technique moves beyond standard $\beta$-$n$ detection by tracking the specific multi-stage decay chain of $^8$He:
$^8$He decays into $^8$Li (releasing a $\beta$ and a $\gamma$).
The child $^8$Li then decays into $^8$Be (releasing another $\beta$), which promptly splits into two alpha particles.
By searching for this sequence of two beta decays occurring in close spatial and temporal proximity, researchers could definitively separate $^8$He from the much more common $^9$Li background.
Distribution of the distance between prompt and delayed signals for $^8$He candidates, showing the fit components used to extract the final yield.
The analysis utilized the full Daya Bay dataset spanning 3,158 days of operation. The experiment's three experimental halls at different depths allowed for measurements at three distinct average muon energies: 63.9 GeV, 64.7 GeV, and 143.0 GeV. A two-dimensional maximum likelihood fit of the distance ($\Delta R$) and time interval ($\Delta T$) between signals was used to extract the yields.
Results and Energy Scaling
The study provides the first definitive measurement of $^8$He production yields in liquid scintillator. The results confirm that $^8$He production is approximately 20 times lower than that of $^9$Li in the 60–150 GeV energy range.
Measured cosmogenic yields of $^9$Li (blue) and $^8$He (red) as a function of average muon energy, compared with results from other experiments.
The production yields ($Y$) were fitted to a power-law function of the average muon energy ($Y \propto E^\alpha$). The fit yielded $\alpha = 0.65 \pm 0.22$ for $^8$He and $\alpha = 0.76 \pm 0.05$ for $^9$Li, providing a clear picture of how these backgrounds scale with detector depth.
Discussion and Implications
A critical finding of this research is the significant discrepancy between experimental data and standard simulation tools. Models such as GEANT4 were found to over-predict the $^8$He yield by a factor of 2 to 4. This suggests that the hadronic interaction models currently used in particle physics simulations require substantial refinement to accurately reflect low-yield cosmogenic processes.
While the $^8$He measurement is currently statistics-dominated—with approximately 90% of the uncertainty arising from the limited event count—this work establishes a benchmark for future large-scale experiments. Facilities like JUNO can leverage this cascade decay method to achieve even higher precision, further refining our understanding of the cosmic-ray induced backgrounds that limit the sensitivity of neutrino searches.
Summary updated
Abstract
Daya Bay presents the first measurement of cosmogenic $^8$He isotope production in liquid scintillator, using an innovative method for identifying cascade decays of $^8$He and its child isotope, $^8$Li. We also measure the production yield of $^9$Li isotopes using well-established methodology. The results, in units of 10$^{-8}μ^{-1}$g$^{-1}$cm$^{2}$, are 0.307$\pm$0.042, 0.341$\pm$0.040, and 0.546$\pm$0.076 for $^8$He, and 6.73$\pm$0.73, 6.75$\pm$0.70, and 13.74$\pm$0.82 for $^9$Li at average muon energies of 63.9~GeV, 64.7~GeV, and 143.0~GeV, respectively. The measured production rate of $^8$He isotopes is more than an order of magnitude lower than any other measurement of cosmogenic isotope production. It replaces the results of previous attempts to determine the ratio of $^8$He to $^9$Li production that yielded a wide range of limits from 0 to 30\%. The results provide future liquid-scintillator-based experiments with improved ability to predict cosmogenic backgrounds.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2024first,
author = {Daya Bay Collaboration and Fengpeng An and Wei Bai and A. B. Balantekin and M. Bishai and S. Blyth and G. F. Cao and Jun Cao and J. F. Chang and Y. Chang and Hui Chen and H. Y. Chen and Shao-Long Chen and Ye Chen and Y. X. Chen and Z. Y. Chen and Jie Cheng and Yin Cheong Cheng and Z. K. Cheng and J. J. Cherwinka and M. C. Chu and J. P. Cummings and Olivia Dalager and F. S. Deng and X. Y. Ding and Y. Y. Ding and M. V. Diwan and T. Dohnal and Dmitry Dolzhikov and J. Dove and Katherine Dugas and Hongyue Duyang and D. A. Dwyer and J. P. Gallo and M. Gonchar and G. H. Gong and Haipeng Gong and W. Gu and J. Y. Guo and L. Guo and X. H. Guo and Yingjun Guo and Z. J. Guo and R. Hackenburg and Y. Han and S. Hans and M. He and K. M. Heeger and Y. K. Heng and Y. K. Hor and Y. Hsiung and Beibei Hu and Z. Hu and J. F. Hu and Z. Hu and H. X. Huang and Jihong Huang and X. T. Huang and Y. B. Huang and Patrick Huber and D. E. Jaffe and K. L. Jen and X. L. Ji and X. Ji and R. A. Johnson and D. Jones and L. Kang and S. H. Kettell and S. Kohn and M. Krämer and T. J. Langford and J. Lee and J. H. C. Lee and R. T. Lei and R. Leitner and J. K. C. Leung and Li Fei and H. L. Li and J. J. Li and Q. J. Li and R. H. Li and S. Li and S. Li and S. Li and W. D. Li and X. N. Li and Xuejing Li and Yufeng Li and Z. B. Li and H. Liang and C. J. Lin and G. L. Lin and Shirley Weishi Li and J. J. Ling and J. M. Link and L. Littenberg and B. R. Littlejohn and J. C. Liu and J. L. Liu and J. X. Liu},
title = {{First measurement of the yield of $^8$He isotopes produced in liquid scintillator by cosmic-ray muons at Daya Bay}},
year = {2024},
eprint = {2402.05383},
archivePrefix = {arXiv},
url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05383},
}