First Measurement of the Clustering Evolution of Photometrically Classified Quasars

Adam D. Myers, Robert J. Brunner, Gordon T. Richards, R. C. Nichol, Donald P. Schneider, D. E. vanden Berk, Ryan Scranton, Alexander Gray, J. BrinkmannThe Astrophysical Journal 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the first measurement of quasar clustering evolution using a large sample of photometrically classified quasars from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. The findings suggest that quasars evolve significantly in their clustering behavior with redshift, implying they reside in increasingly dense environments at higher redshifts and that their active phase is likely short-lived.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the distribution of matter in the Universe is a cornerstone of cosmology. While galaxies and quasars serve as tracers of this matter, their distribution is not uniform and is biased relative to the underlying dark matter. This bias, and how it evolves with cosmic time (redshift), is crucial for accurately inferring the Universe's structure. Previous studies relied heavily on spectroscopically confirmed quasars, which are rare and expensive to obtain. This paper tackles the challenge of using a much larger, but less precisely characterized, sample of photometrically classified quasars to study their clustering evolution and infer their bias. A key difficulty is distinguishing quasars from stars in photometric data, which can introduce significant contamination.

Methods

The authors employ the angular autocorrelation function, $\omega(\theta)$, to quantify the clustering of quasars. They use the Landy & Szalay (1993) estimator for this calculation. To estimate errors, they utilize jackknife resampling, a robust method for assessing statistical uncertainties. A novel aspect of this work is the development of a method to quantify and mitigate stellar contamination in photometrically classified quasar catalogs using the correlation function itself. They also explore different models for quasar clustering evolution, including power-law models and those incorporating redshift-space distortions.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) First Data Release (DR1), specifically the photometrically classified quasar catalog (KDE catalog) developed by Richards et al. (2004). This catalog contains approximately 80,000 quasar candidates. They also utilize spectroscopic data from the 2dF QSO Redshift Survey (2QZ) and other SDSS spectroscopic quasar catalogs for comparison and validation. A random catalog, mimicking the selection function of the KDE data, is also constructed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Quasars are not simple progenitors of local galaxies: The rapid increase in quasar bias with redshift suggests that quasars at high redshift (z~2) are not simply the ancestors of today's bright galaxies. Instead, they likely reside in much denser environments.
  • The quasar phase is likely short-lived: The observed clustering evolution is best explained by a model where quasars inhabit halos of similar mass at all redshifts, implying that the active quasar phase is transient and occurs when halos reach a specific mass.
  • Bias evolution is key: The study highlights that the evolution of quasar bias with redshift is a more significant factor in their clustering than any potential evolution in their intrinsic luminosity.
  • Photometric redshifts are powerful: This work demonstrates the utility of photometrically classified quasars and their photometric redshifts for large-scale structure studies, opening up new avenues for research with vast datasets.
  • Stellar contamination can be quantified: The paper presents a method to assess and account for stellar contamination in photometric quasar samples, a crucial step for reliable clustering measurements.

Key Results

  • The angular autocorrelation function is best-fit by a power-law: $\omega(\theta) = (0.066\pm^{0.026}_{0.024})\theta^{-(0.98\pm0.15)}$.
  • Quasar bias ($b_Q$) is found to evolve rapidly with redshift, changing from approximately $b_Q \sim 3$ at $z=2.2$ to $b_Q \sim 1.2-1.3$ at $z=0.75$.
  • Models with little or no evolution in quasar clustering in comoving coordinates are required to match the scale-length of local galaxies and AGNs.
  • No significant evidence for luminosity-dependent quasar clustering was found; redshift evolution appears to be the dominant factor.
  • The KDE catalog is found to be contaminated by stars at only a 5% level, which is sufficiently low for meaningful clustering studies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Photometric redshift precision: While useful, photometric redshifts have inherent dispersion ($\Delta z \sim 0.1-0.2$), which can scatter objects between redshift bins and introduce noise. The authors suggest that improving QSO photometric redshift estimation is a key area for future work.
  • Sample size for luminosity dependence: While the study attempted to investigate luminosity dependence, the errors on these measurements are still large, making definitive conclusions difficult. Larger samples are needed to constrain this effect.
  • Future work: The authors are actively working on producing a larger catalog of photometrically classified quasars using improved techniques, aiming for around 500,000 quasars. This will allow for more precise measurements, improved angular binning resolution, and a more robust investigation of quasar clustering as a function of luminosity and redshift.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present new measurements of the quasar autocorrelation from a sample of \~80,000 photometrically-classified quasars taken from SDSS DR1. We find a best-fit model of $\omega(\theta) = (0.066\pm^{0.026}_{0.024})\theta^{-(0.98\pm0.15)}$ for the angular autocorrelation, consistent with estimates from spectroscopic quasar surveys. We show that only models with little or no evolution in the clustering of quasars in comoving coordinates since z~1.4 can recover a scale-length consistent with local galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs). A model with little evolution of quasar clustering in comoving coordinates is best explained in the current cosmological paradigm by rapid evolution in quasar bias. We show that quasar biasing must have changed from b_Q~3 at a (photometric) redshift of z=2.2 to b_Q~1.2-1.3 by z=0.75. Such a rapid increase with redshift in biasing implies that quasars at z~2 cannot be the progenitors of modern L* objects, rather they must now reside in dense environments, such as clusters. Similarly, the duration of the UVX quasar phase must be short enough to explain why local UVX quasars reside in essentially unbiased structures. Our estimates of b_Q are in good agreement with recent spectroscopic results, which demonstrate the implied evolution in b_Q is consistent with quasars inhabiting halos of similar mass at every redshift. Treating quasar clustering as a function of both redshift and luminosity, we find no evidence for luminosity dependence in quasar clustering, and that redshift evolution thus affects quasar clustering more than changes in quasars' luminosity. We provide a new method for quantifying stellar contamination in photometrically-classified quasar catalogs via the correlation function.
BibTeX
@article{myers2006first,
  author = {Adam D. Myers and Robert J. Brunner and Gordon T. Richards and R. C. Nichol and Donald P. Schneider and D. E. vanden Berk and Ryan Scranton and Alexander Gray and J. Brinkmann},
  title = {{First Measurement of the Clustering Evolution of Photometrically Classified Quasars}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1086/499093},
}
Figure