First and Second Language Reading Difficulty Among Chinese–English Bilingual Children: The Prevalence and Influences From Demographic Characteristics

Yue Gao, Lifen Zheng, Xin Liu, Emily S. Nichols, Manli Zhang, Linlin Shang, Guosheng Ding, Xiangzhi Meng, Liu LiFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Learning to read a second language (L2) can pose a significant challenge for children already struggling with their first language (L1). This study investigated Chinese (L1) and English (L2) reading skills in a representative sample of 1,824 bilingual children in Grades 4 and 5 from urban and rural schools in Beijing. We examined the prevalence of reading difficulty in Chinese only (PC), English only (PE), and both languages (PB), calculating a stable 36% co-occurrence rate. Multinomial logistic regression revealed that boys and rural students face a disproportionately higher risk of reading difficulties. These findings suggest that despite structural differences between logographic and alphabetic systems, L1 and L2 reading skills are interdependent, likely sharing universal meta-linguistic foundations.

Introduction

Learning to read a second language is a monumental task, particularly for children already struggling with their native tongue. While research has established links between reading difficulties in two alphabetic languages (e.g., Spanish and English), the relationship is less clear when writing systems are fundamentally different.

Chinese is logographic, using characters to represent meaning and sound through radicals, whereas English is alphabetic, using letters to represent phonemes. This study sought to determine if reading difficulty "transfers" across these disparate systems and how demographic factors—specifically sex, grade level, and the urban-rural divide—influence the prevalence of these struggles.

Methods

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional study in Beijing, assessing 1,824 bilingual children in Grades 4 and 5. To isolate reading difficulty from general cognitive impairment, only children with a non-verbal IQ above the 40th percentile (measured via Raven’s Standard Progressive Matrices) were included.

Participants were categorized into four groups based on a 25th percentile cutoff on Chinese character recognition and English word spelling tests:

  • PC (Poor Chinese readers): Struggled only in Chinese.
  • PE (Poor English readers): Struggled only in English.
  • PB (Poor Bilingual readers): Struggled in both.
  • NR (Normal readers): Proficient in both.

Key Results and Demographic Influences

Across the sample, 8.20% were PC, 14.22% were PE, and 4.60% were PB. Boys were significantly more likely to fall into all three "poor reader" categories, being roughly 1.9 to 2.2 times more likely than girls to struggle. Additionally, 4th graders showed a higher risk of Chinese and bilingual reading difficulty than 5th graders, suggesting a developmental "catch-up" as children transition from "learning to read" to "reading to learn."

Figure 4: PB (Poor Bilingual) prevalence by grade and sex, showing higher risk for boys and a decrease from Grade 4 to Grade 5.

The Rural-Urban L2 Gap

While L1 (Chinese) reading difficulty was relatively similar across locations, a stark divide emerged in English proficiency. Rural students were 2.17 times more likely to be poor English readers (PE) than their urban peers. This suggests a "resource gap," where urban students benefit from greater English exposure and extracurricular support that helps them overcome potential reading hurdles.

Figure 6: PE (Poor English) prevalence by grade and location, highlighting the significantly higher risk for rural students compared to urban students.

The "Shared Core" of Reading

Despite the visual differences between Chinese characters and English words, the study found a stable 36% co-occurrence rate: if a child was a poor reader in Chinese, their chance of also being a poor reader in English was 36%. This rate remained remarkably stable regardless of sex or location, supporting the hypothesis that "meta-linguistic" skills—the ability to reflect on and manipulate language—are universal and transcend specific writing systems.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study demonstrates that L1 reading difficulty significantly increases the risk of L2 reading difficulty, even across logographic and alphabetic scripts. The findings highlight the importance of understanding the interdependent relationship between different writing systems. Furthermore, the identified male disadvantage and the urban-rural gap in L2 prevalence call for targeted educational interventions for disadvantaged populations.

While the study used English spelling as a proxy for reading and relied on a specific 25th percentile cutoff, the large-scale data provides a robust foundation for future research into the specific cognitive skills, such as phonological or orthographic awareness, that drive this 36% co-occurrence of reading failure.

Summary updated

Abstract

Learning to read a second language (L2) can pose a great challenge for children who have already been struggling to read in their first language (L1). Moreover, it is not clear whether, to what extent, and under what circumstances L1 reading difficulty increases the risk of L2 reading difficulty. This study investigated Chinese (L1) and English (L2) reading skills in a large representative sample of 1,824 Chinese-English bilingual children in Grades 4 and 5 from both urban and rural schools in Beijing. We examined the prevalence of reading difficulty in Chinese only (poor Chinese readers, PC), English only (poor English readers, PE), and both Chinese and English (poor bilingual readers, PB) and calculated the co-occurrence, that is, the chances of becoming a poor reader in English given that the child was already a poor reader in Chinese. We then conducted a multinomial logistic regression analysis and compared the prevalence of PC, PE, and PB between children in Grade 4 versus Grade 5, in urban versus rural areas, and in boys versus girls. Results showed that compared to girls, boys demonstrated significantly higher risk of PC, PE, and PB. Meanwhile, compared to the 5th graders, the 4th graders demonstrated significantly higher risk of PC and PB. In addition, children enrolled in the urban schools were more likely to become better second language readers, thus leading to a concerning rural-urban gap in the prevalence of L2 reading difficulty. Finally, among these Chinese-English bilingual children, regardless of sex and school location, poor reading skill in Chinese significantly increased the risk of also being a poor English reader, with a considerable and stable co-occurrence of approximately 36%. In sum, this study suggests that despite striking differences between alphabetic and logographic writing systems, L1 reading difficulty still significantly increases the risk of L2 reading difficulty. This indicates the shared meta-linguistic skills in reading different writing systems and the importance of understanding the universality and the interdependent relationship of reading between different writing systems. Furthermore, the male disadvantage (in both L1 and L2) and the urban-rural gap (in L2) found in the prevalence of reading difficulty calls for special attention to disadvantaged populations in educational practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2019first,
  author = {Yue Gao and Lifen Zheng and Xin Liu and Emily S. Nichols and Manli Zhang and Linlin Shang and Guosheng Ding and Xiangzhi Meng and Liu Li},
  title = {{First and Second Language Reading Difficulty Among Chinese–English Bilingual Children: The Prevalence and Influences From Demographic Characteristics}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02544},
}
Figure