Finite-Time Error Analysis of Online Model-Based Q-Learning with a Relaxed Sampling Model

Han-Dong Lim, HyeAnn Lee, Donghwan LeearXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Model-based reinforcement learning (RL) is recognized for its superior sample efficiency compared to model-free methods. However, theoretical guarantees often rely on the existence of a "generative model" or simulator, which is frequently unavailable in real-world applications. This paper presents SyncMBQ, an online model-based Q-learning algorithm that operates under a relaxed sampling model. By simultaneously updating environment estimates and Q-values, SyncMBQ achieves near-optimal sample complexity. We provide a finite-time error analysis using switched system theory, demonstrating the algorithm's robustness to step-size selection and its empirical superiority over standard Q-learning in both deterministic and stochastic environments.

Introduction

Reinforcement Learning (RL) algorithms are generally categorized as either model-free or model-based. Model-free methods, such as standard Q-learning, learn directly from experience, while model-based methods first learn a transition and reward model of the environment to facilitate planning. While model-based RL is theoretically more sample-efficient, most existing proofs for this efficiency assume access to a "sampling oracle" or generative model that allows an agent to query any state-action pair arbitrarily.

In practical scenarios, agents must learn online from a stream of data collected through interaction, without the ability to "teleport" to specific states. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the finite-time convergence behavior of model-based Q-learning when the model is learned online from a relaxed sampling distribution rather than a perfect simulator.

SyncMBQ: Synchronous Model-Based Q-Learning

The authors propose SyncMBQ, an algorithm designed to bridge the gap between theoretical efficiency and practical online learning. The algorithm operates in two distinct phases:

  1. Data Collection: A brief initial phase ensures that every state-action pair in the environment is visited at least once to initialize the model.
  2. Online Learning: Upon observing a transition $(s, a, r, s')$, the agent immediately updates its internal estimates of the reward function ($\hat{R}$) and transition probabilities ($\hat{P}$) using simple averaging.

Unlike standard Q-learning, which only updates the Q-value for the specific state-action pair visited, SyncMBQ performs a synchronous update. It uses the current model estimate to update the Q-values for all state-action pairs simultaneously. This approach allows the agent to propagate information throughout the state space more rapidly than model-free alternatives.

Theoretical Analysis via Switched Systems

To analyze the convergence of SyncMBQ, the authors employ Switched System Theory from control engineering. The Q-learning update is modeled as a dynamical system that "switches" between different linear modes based on the agent's current greedy policy. This framework allows for a rigorous tracking of the error between the estimated Q-values ($Q_k$) and the optimal Q-values ($Q^*$) over time.

Convergence of the infinity norm of the Q-value error over training steps, demonstrating the stability of the learning process across multiple runs.

The analysis yields a sample complexity of $\tilde{O}\left(\frac{|S||A|}{(1-\gamma)^4 \epsilon^2}\right)$, which matches known lower bounds for Q-learning. This proves that SyncMBQ is near-optimal even without the idealized generative model assumption. Furthermore, the algorithm is shown to be stable under a wide range of constant step sizes ($\alpha \in (0, 1)$), a significant improvement over the fragile step-size requirements of many model-free proofs.

Empirical Evaluation

The algorithm was benchmarked against standard Q-learning on two OpenAI Gymnasium environments: Taxi-v3 (a deterministic task with 500 states) and FrozenLake8x8-v1 (a stochastic task with 64 states).

Comprehensive performance comparison showing success rates for Taxi and FrozenLake across various learning rates (α). SyncMBQ consistently outperforms standard Q-learning in both speed and final success rate.

Key Results

  • Efficiency in Taxi-v3: SyncMBQ achieved a 100% success rate almost immediately, whereas standard Q-learning required hundreds of episodes to reach comparable performance.
  • Robustness in FrozenLake: In the stochastic FrozenLake environment, SyncMBQ maintained a stable success rate of approximately 71%. In contrast, standard Q-learning exhibited high sensitivity to the learning rate $\alpha$; when the step size was too high, its success rate often plummeted below 20%.
  • Effective Horizon: The results confirm that incorporating a learned model effectively extends the agent's "look ahead" capability, allowing it to navigate complex dependencies more efficiently than model-free methods.

Conclusion and Future Work

SyncMBQ demonstrates that model-based RL can be both theoretically robust and practically superior without requiring unrealistic sampling oracles. The use of switched system theory provides a powerful tool for finite-time error analysis in RL.

Future research directions include relaxing the assumption of a fixed sampling distribution to accommodate truly Markovian sampling (single continuous trajectories) and integrating SyncMBQ with sophisticated exploration strategies like Upper Confidence Bound (UCB). Additionally, extending these tabular results to high-dimensional state spaces via function approximation remains a critical challenge for scaling these benefits to complex real-world tasks.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{lim2024finite,
  author = {Han-Dong Lim and HyeAnn Lee and Donghwan Lee},
  title = {{Finite-Time Error Analysis of Online Model-Based Q-Learning with a Relaxed Sampling Model}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2402.11877},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.11877},
}
Figure