Finite Element Analysis of Occupant Risk in Vehicular Impacts into Cluster Mailboxes

Emre Palta, Lukasz Pachocki, Dawid Bruski, Qian Wang, Christopher Jaus, Howie FangComput 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses finite element analysis to simulate vehicle impacts with cluster mailboxes (CMs), finding that current designs pose a marginal risk of occupant injury under MASH TL-1 conditions. The research provides valuable insights into CM crashworthiness and occupant safety, informing future design and safety standards.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cluster mailboxes (CMs) are becoming increasingly common in residential areas, raising concerns about passenger safety in the event of a vehicular collision. While previous research has examined mailbox crashworthiness, there's a need for detailed analysis of occupant risk, especially considering modern vehicle safety features and standardized testing protocols. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the crashworthiness of two types of CMs under MASH (Manual for Assessing Safety Hardware) Test Level 1 (TL-1) conditions, focusing on occupant injury potential.

Methods

The researchers employed nonlinear finite element (FE) simulations using LS-DYNA to model the complex interactions during vehicle-CM impacts. Key aspects of their methodology include:

  • MASH-Compliant Vehicle Models: Detailed FE models of a 2010 Toyota Yaris and a 2006 Ford F250 were used, incorporating airbags, seatbelt restraint systems, and a Hybrid III 50th percentile adult male dummy. These models were validated against existing crash test data.
  • Cluster Mailbox (CM) Models: Two types of CMs (Type I and Type IV) were modeled, considering both single- and dual-unit configurations. These models included detailed representations of the aluminum alloy construction, pedestals, and mounting hardware.
  • Impact Scenarios: A comprehensive matrix of 32 simulation scenarios was developed, covering various combinations of CM types, vehicle types, road surfaces (flat and with a curb), impact angles (0° and 25°), and impact locations (side, corner, and midpoint for dual-unit CMs). All simulations were conducted at the MASH TL-1 speed of 50 km/h.
  • Occupant Risk Assessment: Occupant safety was evaluated using established MASH criteria, including occupant impact velocities (OIVs), occupant ride-down accelerations (ORAs), and the Head Injury Criterion (HIC15) to assess the likelihood of skull fracture.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on existing validated FE models of vehicles and standard material property data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Marginal Occupant Risk: The most significant finding is that under the simulated MASH TL-1 conditions, the risk of serious occupant injury from CM impacts is marginal.
  • Primary Failure Mode: For both single and dual-unit CMs, the primary failure mechanism observed was the detachment of the upper mailbox unit from its pedestal.
  • No Intrusion: Crucially, no components of the mailboxes were found to intrude into the vehicle's occupant compartment across all tested scenarios. This is a critical safety outcome.
  • Curb Influence: The presence of a curb slightly altered impact dynamics, sometimes leading to increased roll and pitch angles but generally not significantly increasing occupant injury risk.
  • Vehicle Mass Impact: The heavier Ford F250 generally caused more severe damage to the CMs and vehicles compared to the lighter Toyota Yaris, but occupant safety factors remained within acceptable limits for both.

Key Results

  • Occupant Safety Factors: Across all 32 simulation cases, the calculated occupant safety factors (OIV, ORA, HIC15) remained well below the MASH limiting values.
  • HIC15 Values: HIC15 values were consistently low, resulting in a 0% probability of skull fracture in most scenarios. Even in cases with higher HIC15 values, they were still well within safe limits.
  • Vehicle Damage: While vehicles sustained damage, particularly to the front hood and bumper, this damage was generally localized and did not compromise the occupant compartment.
  • CM Component Integrity: The upper units of the CMs often sustained significant deformation, but they generally maintained structural integrity and did not break apart into dangerous fragments.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Dummy Type: The study exclusively used a 50th percentile male Hybrid III dummy. Future work could include simulations with 50th percentile female dummies or child dummies to assess their responses and risk profiles, considering body mass variations.
  • Vehicle Models: The study focused on two specific vehicle models. Expanding the analysis to include other vehicle types, especially those with lower profiles or different hood designs (e.g., USPS delivery trucks), could reveal significant deviations in safety evaluation results.
  • Impact Speed: The research was limited to MASH TL-1 conditions (50 km/h). Further investigations at higher impact speeds would be valuable to understand performance under more severe crash scenarios.
  • Numerical vs. Experimental: The findings are based on numerical simulations. Experimental testing is recommended to validate these simulation results and confirm the predicted safety outcomes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{palta2024finite,
  author = {Emre Palta and Lukasz Pachocki and Dawid Bruski and Qian Wang and Christopher Jaus and Howie Fang},
  title = {{Finite Element Analysis of Occupant Risk in Vehicular Impacts into Cluster Mailboxes}},
  journal = {Comput.},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/computation13010012},
}

Loading related content...

Figure