Fine-Scale Spatiotemporal Air Pollution Analysis Using Mobile Monitors on Google Street View Vehicles

Yawen Guan, Margaret C. Johnson, Matthias Katzfuß, Elizabeth Mannshardt, Kyle P. Messier, Brian J. Reich, Joon Jin SongFigshare 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel spatiotemporal modeling framework to generate high-resolution, real-time air pollution maps and forecasts using data from mobile sensors, specifically Google Street View vehicles. The approach offers a more nuanced understanding of localized air quality compared to traditional fixed-location monitoring, with significant implications for public health and environmental awareness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding personal exposure to air pollutants is crucial for informed daily decisions, yet current air quality information is often limited in its spatial and temporal resolution. Traditional monitoring relies on fixed stations, which can miss localized "hot spots" and microenvironmental variations caused by traffic, urban structures, and weather. The increasing availability of fine-scale data from mobile sensors, like those mounted on Google Street View cars, presents an opportunity to bridge this gap, but requires sophisticated methods to handle the complex spatiotemporal nature of this data. This paper aims to develop such a methodology to leverage this rich data for real-time air quality mapping and forecasting.

Methods

The authors propose a computationally efficient spatiotemporal model that combines a land-use regression (LUR) component for large-scale variations with a Gaussian process (GP) for capturing fine-scale, localized pollution patterns. Key methodological contributions include:

  • Spatiotemporal Land-Use Regression (STLR) Model: This model decomposes air pollution into a large-scale component explained by covariates (like land use, traffic patterns) and a small-scale, spatially and temporally correlated residual.
  • Anisotropic, Nonstationary Covariance Function: The GP uses a covariance function that accounts for spatial distance, temporal distance, and the similarity of covariates, allowing it to capture complex dependencies and extrapolate to unobserved areas.
  • Vecchia Approximation for Likelihood: To handle the large volume of data, the authors employ the Vecchia approximation, a computationally efficient method for approximating the Gaussian process likelihood, enabling scalability to large spatiotemporal datasets.
  • Two-Step Estimation Procedure: A practical approach is used where regression coefficients are estimated first, followed by estimation of the GP parameters using the residuals.
  • Temporal Aggregation: To mitigate the impact of noisy, high-frequency (1-second) data, the study explores using block medians (15-second, 1-minute) to create more stable datasets.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is:

  • Google Street View Air Quality Data (Oakland, CA): This dataset consists of one-second measurements of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) collected by Google Street View vehicles equipped with fast-response pollution sensors. Data was collected between June 30, 2015, and May 13, 2016. This dataset is unique due to its high spatial and temporal resolution, covering extensive road networks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mobile Sensors Offer Nuanced Information: The study demonstrates that mobile sensor networks can provide more detailed and localized air quality insights than equally sized fixed-location networks, especially in urban environments.
  • Spatiotemporal Dependence is Crucial: Capturing both spatial and temporal correlations in air pollution is essential for accurate forecasting and mapping, especially for short-term predictions.
  • Vecchia Approximation Scales to Big Data: The use of the Vecchia approximation is key to making sophisticated spatiotemporal modeling computationally feasible for large, high-frequency datasets like those from mobile sensors.
  • Temporal Aggregation Improves Stability: Smoothing raw 1-second data into block medians (e.g., 1-minute) leads to more stable parameter estimates and improved prediction performance, though it sacrifices some spatial fidelity.
  • Non-zero Lag in Conditioning Sets Improves Forecasts: Using a conditioning set that includes observations from a short period before the current time (l > 0) rather than just the immediate past (l = 0) significantly improves temporal prediction accuracy, suggesting that excluding highly correlated recent observations can lead to better long-range predictions.

Key Results

  • Improved Forecasting and Mapping: The proposed spatiotemporal model (ST and STx) outperforms static models (X-only, S) in terms of prediction accuracy (lower Root Mean Squared Prediction Error - RMSPE) for both short-term forecasts and spatial interpolation.
  • Efficiency of Mobile Networks: An experiment showed that as few as 3-4 mobile monitors can provide comparable prediction performance to 15 fixed-location monitors, especially for forecasting. The reduction in prediction variance is significantly faster with mobile monitors.
  • Parameter Stability: Parameter estimates for the ST model are more stable when using smoothed block median data (15-second, 1-minute) compared to raw 1-second data.
  • Covariates Enhance Spatial Extrapolation: Including covariates in the covariance function (STx model) shows slight improvements in correlation for certain scenarios, suggesting their utility in explaining long-range relationships.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The Google Street View data, while rich, has limited spatial and temporal coverage on any given day. The measurements are also inherently noisy and variable.
  • Assumption of Equal Quality: The experiment comparing mobile and fixed-location monitors assumed data quality was equal, which may not hold in practice. Future work should account for potential differences in bias and variance between data sources.
  • Future Extensions:
    • Jointly modeling data from mobile and stationary monitors.
  • Extending the methodology to incorporate data from a larger number of mobile sensors, potentially from individuals' smartwatches.
  • Developing more sophisticated space-time ordering schemes for the Vecchia approximation with a larger number of concurrently deployed mobile sensors.
  • Further calibration of forecast maps with other data sources.

Summary updated

Abstract

People are increasingly concerned with understanding their personal environment, including possible exposure to harmful air pollutants. To make informed decisions on their day-to-day activities, they are interested in real-time information on a localized scale. Publicly available, fine-scale, high-quality air pollution measurements acquired using mobile monitors represent a paradigm shift in measurement technologies. A methodological framework utilizing these increasingly fine-scale measurements to provide real-time air pollution maps and short-term air quality forecasts on a fine-resolution spatial scale could prove to be instrumental in increasing public awareness and understanding. The Google Street View study provides a unique source of data with spatial and temporal complexities, with the potential to provide information about commuter exposure and hot spots within city streets with high traffic. We develop a computationally efficient spatiotemporal model for these data and use the model to make short-term forecasts and high-resolution maps of current air pollution levels. We also show via an experiment that mobile networks can provide more nuanced information than an equally sized fixed-location network. This modeling framework has important real-world implications in understanding citizens’ personal environments, as data production and real-time availability continue to be driven by the ongoing development and improvement of mobile measurement technologies. Supplementary materials for this article, including a standardized description of the materials available for reproducing the work, are available as an online supplement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guan2021fine,
  author = {Yawen Guan and Margaret C. Johnson and Matthias Katzfuß and Elizabeth Mannshardt and Kyle P. Messier and Brian J. Reich and Joon Jin Song},
  title = {{Fine-Scale Spatiotemporal Air Pollution Analysis Using Mobile Monitors on Google Street View Vehicles}},
  booktitle = {Figshare},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.6084/m9.figshare.10113239.v3},
}
Figure