Fine-scale computations for adaptive processing in the human brain

Elisa Zamboni, Valentin G. Kemper, Nuno Reis Goncalves, Ke Jia, Vasilis M Karlaftis, Samuel J. Bell, Joseph Giorgio, Reuben Rideaux, Rainer Goebel, Zoe KourtzieLife 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses ultra-high field fMRI to investigate how the human brain adapts to repetitive sensory information by examining neural activity across different cortical layers. They found that adaptation is layer-specific in visual cortex and involves a complex interplay of feedforward and feedback connections, suggesting a sophisticated neural circuit for rapid learning and efficient processing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Our brains are constantly bombarded with sensory information. To process this efficiently, the brain learns to reduce its response to familiar or repetitive stimuli – a phenomenon known as sensory adaptation. While we know this adaptation is crucial for perception and involves changes in neural selectivity, the precise neural circuits and mechanisms underlying this process, especially at a fine-grained level within the human brain, have remained largely unknown. Standard fMRI, with its relatively lower resolution, struggles to differentiate between signals originating from different cortical layers, making it difficult to distinguish between feedforward (bottom-up) and feedback (top-down) processing pathways. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using advanced fMRI techniques to probe these mechanisms across cortical depth.

Methods

The researchers leveraged ultra-high field (UHF) 7 Tesla (7T) fMRI to achieve sub-millimeter resolution, allowing them to distinguish neural signals from different cortical layers (superficial, middle, and deeper). They employed an orientation adaptation paradigm: participants viewed gratings of the same orientation repeatedly (adaptation condition) or gratings of varying orientations (non-adaptation condition).

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Laminar fMRI: Analyzing fMRI signals across distinct cortical depths within visual areas (V1, V2, V3, V4) and posterior parietal cortex (IPS1, IPS2).
  • Vascular Contribution Correction: Implementing sophisticated image processing techniques to mitigate the influence of blood vessels, which can disproportionately affect signals from superficial cortical layers in standard fMRI. This involved identifying and removing voxels confounded by vasculature effects and using a 3D GRASE sequence (less susceptible to large veins) for validation.
  • Functional Connectivity Analysis: Using Independent Component Analysis (ICA) and Finite Impulse Response (FIR) functions to estimate connectivity between different cortical regions and layers. They specifically investigated feedforward (e.g., V1 superficial to higher areas middle layers) and feedback (e.g., V1 deeper to higher areas deeper layers) pathways.
  • Behavioral Correlation: Linking fMRI adaptation measures to perceptual biases (tilt-aftereffect) to understand the behavioral relevance of the observed neural adaptation.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 17 participants for the main experiment and 5 participants for a control experiment using a different fMRI sequence. No new benchmarks or datasets were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing brain activity with novel high-resolution techniques.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Layer-Specific Adaptation: The brain doesn't adapt uniformly across its cortical layers. Superficial and middle layers of the visual cortex show stronger adaptation (larger BOLD signal decrease) than deeper layers. This suggests that different layers play distinct roles in processing repeated stimuli.
  • Feedforward and Feedback Dance: Adaptation isn't solely a bottom-up process. The study reveals enhanced feedforward connectivity from early visual areas (V1) to higher visual areas, but also crucial short-range feedback from V2 to V1 and long-range feedback from the posterior parietal cortex (IPS1) to V1. This highlights a dynamic interplay between incoming sensory information and top-down expectations.
  • Top-Down Control is Key: The significant feedback from the posterior parietal cortex to deeper layers of V1 is particularly interesting. This region is known for its role in expectation and prediction, suggesting that our anticipation of a repeated stimulus actively shapes how the brain processes it, even in early visual areas.
  • Behavioral Relevance: The layer-specific fMRI adaptation in superficial layers correlated with perceptual biases, directly linking neural adaptation to how we perceive the world.

Key Results

  • fMRI Adaptation: A significant condition × cortical depth interaction showed stronger fMRI adaptation in superficial and middle layers compared to deeper layers across visual areas (V1-V4).
  • Functional Connectivity:
    • Feedforward: Significantly enhanced connectivity from V1 superficial layers to higher visual areas' middle layers during adaptation.
  • Feedback: Enhanced short-range feedback connectivity between V2 and V1 deeper layers, and significantly stronger long-range feedback connectivity from V1 deeper layers to IPS1 during adaptation.
  • Posterior Parietal Cortex: Adaptation in IPS1 and IPS2 was not layer-specific, but connectivity analysis revealed a specific role for deeper layers of IPS1 in providing feedback to V1.
  • Behavioral Correlation: Superficial layer fMRI adaptation showed a significant positive correlation with perceptual adaptation (tilt-aftereffect).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Resolution Limits: While UHF fMRI offers unprecedented resolution, the paper acknowledges that MRI-defined layers are approximations and don't perfectly map to cytoarchitectonically defined cortical layers.
  • Vascular Confounds: Despite rigorous correction methods, the potential for residual vascular contributions, especially in deeper layers, is an ongoing challenge in laminar fMRI.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest combining laminar fMRI with electrophysiology to better understand the temporal dynamics of these circuits. They also highlight the potential of newer techniques like cerebral blood volume (CBV) imaging for enhanced spatial specificity. Further research could explore how these adaptive mechanisms extend to other sensory modalities and cognitive functions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Adapting to the environment statistics by reducing brain responses to repetitive sensory information is key for efficient information processing. Yet, the fine-scale computations that support this adaptive processing in the human brain remain largely unknown. Here, we capitalise on the sub-millimetre resolution of ultra-high field imaging to examine functional magnetic resonance imaging signals across cortical depth and discern competing hypotheses about the brain mechanisms (feedforward vs. feedback) that mediate adaptive processing. We demonstrate layer-specific suppressive processing within visual cortex, as indicated by stronger BOLD decrease in superficial and middle than deeper layers for gratings that were repeatedly presented at the same orientation. Further, we show altered functional connectivity for adaptation: enhanced feedforward connectivity from V1 to higher visual areas, short-range feedback connectivity between V1 and V2, and long-range feedback occipito-parietal connectivity. Our findings provide evidence for a circuit of local recurrent and feedback interactions that mediate rapid brain plasticity for adaptive information processing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zamboni2020fine,
  author = {Elisa Zamboni and Valentin G. Kemper and Nuno Reis Goncalves and Ke Jia and Vasilis M Karlaftis and Samuel J. Bell and Joseph Giorgio and Reuben Rideaux and Rainer Goebel and Zoe Kourtzi},
  title = {{Fine-scale computations for adaptive processing in the human brain}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.57637},
}
Figure