Fine particulate matter associated with monsoonal effect and the responses of biomass fire hotspots in the tropical environment

Md Firoz Khan, Mohd Talib Latif, W. H. Saw, Norhaniza Amil, Mohd Shahrul Mohd Nadzir, Maneesh Sahani, Norhayati Mohd Tahir, Jing Xiang Chung2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the sources and health risks of fine particulate matter (PM2.5) in tropical Southeast Asia, highlighting the significant influence of monsoonal patterns and biomass burning. By employing advanced source apportionment techniques, the research identifies key contributors to PM2.5 and quantifies the associated health risks, revealing a concerning cancer risk from toxic metals that warrants further investigation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Fine particulate matter (PM2.5) poses significant health risks, particularly in tropical regions like Southeast Asia, where it is heavily influenced by seasonal monsoons. Understanding the sources of PM2.5 is crucial for developing effective mitigation strategies. However, the complex interplay of local emissions, transboundary pollution, and monsoon dynamics in this region makes source identification and risk assessment challenging. This paper aims to address this by quantitatively characterizing the health risks associated with heavy metals in PM2.5, identifying the primary sources, and analyzing how monsoonal effects influence these factors.

Methods

The researchers utilized a combination of analytical techniques and modeling approaches:

  • Positive Matrix Factorization (PMF) 5.0: This is a widely used receptor model for source apportionment, which interprets source profiles based on the chemical composition of collected samples. The study employed this to identify five distinct sources of PM2.5.
  • Mass Closure Model: This model helps to account for the total mass of PM2.5 by categorizing its components into major groups (mineral matter, secondary inorganic aerosol, sea salt, trace elements, and undefined). This was used to understand the overall composition and identify major contributors.
  • Health Risk Assessment (HRA): Based on US EPA guidelines, the study calculated non-carcinogenic (Hazard Quotient - HQ) and carcinogenic risks (CR) for selected heavy metals found in PM2.5 and its identified sources. This involved estimating exposure concentrations and comparing them to reference concentrations and unit risks.

Datasets

The study utilized PM2.5 samples collected over a specific period in Peninsular Malaysia. The chemical composition of these samples was analyzed. Additionally, the study referenced data from:

  • World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines: Used for comparison of PM2.5 concentrations.
  • US EPA National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS): Also used for PM2.5 concentration comparisons.
  • ERA-Interim reanalysis data: Used for meteorological information, including wind fields and boundary layer height.
  • MODIS (Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer) fire hotspot data: Used to investigate biomass burning hotspots.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Monsoon's Dual Role: The monsoon significantly influences PM2.5 levels and air mass origins, with the SW monsoon bringing pollution from Sumatra and the NE monsoon from Southern China. This highlights the importance of considering regional transport.
  • Biomass Burning as a Major Player: Biomass burning, particularly during the dry season, is identified as a significant contributor to PM2.5, especially in conjunction with motor vehicle emissions.
  • Health Risks are Real and Vary by Source: While non-carcinogenic risks were generally found to be at a safe level, the carcinogenic risk posed by toxic metals like Arsenic (As) is a serious concern, particularly from coal burning and motor vehicle/biomass burning sources.
  • As is a Key Culprit: Arsenic (As) consistently emerged as a metal of significant concern, showing the largest lifetime cancer risk across various sources and overall PM2.5.

Key Results

  • PM2.5 Exceedances: 48% of the collected PM2.5 samples exceeded the WHO 24-hour guideline, and 19% exceeded the US EPA 24-hour NAAQS.
  • Source Contributions: The mass closure model identified mineral matter (35%), undefined fraction (45%), secondary inorganic aerosol (11%), sea salt (7%), and trace elements (2%) as major components. PMF analysis revealed five key sources, with motor vehicle emissions/biomass burning being dominant (31%), followed by marine/sulfate aerosol (20%), coal burning (19%), nitrate aerosol (17%), and mineral/road dust (13%).
  • Health Risk Ranking: The non-carcinogenic risk followed the order: PM2.5 > coal burning > motor vehicle emissions/biomass burning > mineral/road dust. The lifetime cancer risk order was As > Ni > Pb > Cd for mineral/road dust, coal burning, and overall PM2.5, and As > Pb > Ni > Cd for motor vehicle/biomass burning.
  • Cancer Risk Magnitude: The associated cancer risk from toxic metals in PM2.5 was estimated to be three to four in 1,000,000 people in the study area, indicating a significant public health concern.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Undefined Fraction: A substantial portion of the PM2.5 mass was categorized as "undefined" (45%). This is attributed to the lack of measurement for elemental and organic carbon fractions, unaccounted-for mineral oxides, and water associated with salts, suggesting potential for more detailed elemental and organic carbon analysis in future studies.
  • Need for Further Investigation: The study concludes that the significant cancer risk warrants further investigation. Future work should focus on not only the integrated mass concentration of PM2.5 but also on specific toxic elements and their release potentials from various sources to better understand exposure pathways and risk factors.
  • Seasonal Differences in EF: While the study found no seasonal differences in the enrichment factor (EF) of heavy metals, further exploration into potential subtle seasonal variations could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The health implications of PM2.5 in tropical regions of Southeast Asia are significant as PM2.5 can pose serious health concerns. PM2.5 is strongly influenced by the monsoon. We quantitatively characterize the health risks posed to human populations by selected heavy metals in PM2.5. Monsoonal effects as well as factors influencing the sources of PM2.5 were also determined. Apportionment analysis of PM2.5 was undertaken using US EPA positive matrix factorization (PMF) 5.0 and a mass closure model. Overall, 48 % of the samples exceeded the World Health Organization (WHO) 24 h guideline. The mass closure model identified four sources of PM2.5: (a) mineral matter (MIN) (35 %), (b) secondary inorganic aerosol (SIA) (11 %), (c) sea salt (SS) (7 %), (d) trace elements (TE) (2 %) and (e) undefined (UD) (45 %). PMF 5.0 identified five potential sources and motor vehicle emissions and biomass burning were dominant followed by marine and sulfate aerosol, coal burning, nitrate aerosol, and mineral and road dust. The non-carcinogenic risk level for four selected metals (Pb, As, Cd and Ni) in PM2.5 and in the identified major sources by PMF > 5.0, with respect to inhalation follows the order of PM2.5 > coal burning > motor vehicle emissions/biomass burning > mineral/road dust. The lifetime cancer risk follows the order of As > Ni > Pb > Cd for mineral/road dust, coal burning and overall of PM2.5 concentration and As > Pb > Ni > Cd for motor vehicle/biomass burning. Overall, the associated cancer risk posed by the exposure of toxic metals in PM2.5 is three to four in 1 000 000 people in this location.
BibTeX
@misc{khan2015fine,
  author = {Md Firoz Khan and Mohd Talib Latif and W. H. Saw and Norhaniza Amil and Mohd Shahrul Mohd Nadzir and Maneesh Sahani and Norhayati Mohd Tahir and Jing Xiang Chung},
  title = {{Fine particulate matter associated with monsoonal effect and the responses of biomass fire hotspots in the tropical environment}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.5194/acpd-15-22215-2015},
}

Loading related content...

Figure