Finding the Missing Baryons Using CMB as a Backlight

Shirley Ho, Simon DeDeo, David N. SpergelarXiv 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We present a new method for detecting the missing baryons by generating a template for the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (kSZ) effect. The template is computed from the product of a reconstructed velocity field with a galaxy field; we find that the combination of a galaxy redshift survey such as SDSS and a CMB survey such as ACT and PLANCK can detect the kSZ, and thus the ionized gas, at significant signal-to-noise. Unlike other techniques that look for hot gas or metals, this approach directly detects the electrons in the IGM through their signature on the CMB. The estimated signal-to-noise for detecting the galaxy-momentum kSZ cross-correlation is 4, 9, and 12 for ACT (with survey area of 2000 $\mathrm{deg}^2$) with SDSS-DR4, SDSS3 and ADEPT respectively. The estimated signal-to-noise for PLANCK with SDSS-DR4, SDSS3 and ADEPT is 11, 23, and 32. Our method provides a new mean for determining properties of the ionized gas in the Universe.

Introduction: The Missing Baryon Problem

Cosmologists face a persistent "missing baryon" problem. While observations of the early universe via the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and primordial Deuterium abundance precisely determine the total amount of baryonic (normal) matter, local observations of stars and cold gas only account for roughly half of this total. The remaining baryons are hypothesized to reside in the Intergalactic Medium (IGM) as diffuse, ionized gas within the filaments of the cosmic web. This gas is notoriously difficult to detect: it is too hot for Lyman-$\alpha$ absorption but too low-density for typical X-ray emission. This research proposes using the CMB as a "backlight" to directly probe these missing electrons.

Methodology: Reconstructing the Momentum Template

The proposed method utilizes the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel’dovich (kSZ) effect, where CMB photons are Doppler-shifted by the bulk motion of ionized gas. This effect scales linearly with electron density ($n_e$), making it uniquely sensitive to diffuse gas compared to X-ray emission ($n_e^2$).

To extract this subtle signal, we reconstruct a 3D momentum field from galaxy redshift surveys to serve as a cross-correlation template. The reconstruction follows a multi-step process:

  1. Density Mapping: Mapping the 3D distribution of galaxies from redshift surveys.
  2. Real-Space Conversion: Correcting for redshift-space distortions.
  3. Wiener Filtering: Suppressing noise and non-linearities.
  4. Velocity Reconstruction: Deriving the 3D velocity field $\mathbf{v}(\mathbf{k})$ from the density field using the continuity equation.
  5. Momentum Calculation: Combining the density and velocity fields.
  6. Projection: Creating a 2D kSZ template for cross-correlation with CMB maps.
Visualizing the reconstruction pipeline: (top) the initial galaxy density field, (middle) the reconstructed velocity field, and (bottom) the resulting projected momentum template used for kSZ detection.

Validation via Simulations

The accuracy of this reconstruction method was validated using N-body simulations with $256^3$ particles. By comparing the reconstructed momentum field to the "ground truth" from the simulation, we confirmed that the linear theory approximation holds well on large scales.

The cross-correlation power spectrum $C_l^{P\Theta}$ comparing results from simulations (red) and analytical calculations (green). The strong agreement validates the reconstruction methodology across a wide range of multipoles.

Key Results and Signal-to-Noise Estimates

By cross-correlating reconstructed templates from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) with CMB data from the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) and the Planck satellite, significant detections are achievable. The use of phase information (the direction of gas flow) significantly boosts the signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) and provides robustness against common foreground contaminants like dust or the thermal SZ effect.

Galaxy Survey CMB Experiment Estimated S/N
SDSS-DR4 ACT 4.1
SDSS-DR4 PLANCK 11.2
SDSS3 PLANCK 22.5
ADEPT (Future) PLANCK 32.2

Discussion and Limitations

While the method is robust, it relies on linear perturbation theory, which breaks down on small, non-linear scales (<10 Mpc) where complex cluster dynamics dominate. Additionally, uncertainties in the galaxy bias parameter $b$ translate into uncertainties in gas density estimates. Despite these limitations, the high predicted S/N for upcoming surveys suggests we are entering an era where we can map the profiles and evolution of the "missing" baryons.

The authors have made their momentum templates publicly available, inviting the community to cross-correlate them with the latest CMB data to finally complete our cosmic inventory.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a new method for detecting the missing baryons by generating a template for the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect. The template is computed from the product of a reconstructed velocity field with a galaxy field; we find that the combination of a galaxy redshift survey such as SDSS and a CMB survey such as ACT and PLANCK can detect the kSZ, and thus the ionized gas, at significant signal-to-noise. Unlike other techniques that look for hot gas or metals, this approach directly detects the electrons in the IGM through their signature on the CMB. The estimated signal-to-noise for detecting the galaxy-momentum kSZ cross-correlation is 4, 9, and 12 for ACT (with survey area of 2000 $\mathrm{deg}^2$) with SDSS-DR4, SDSS3 and ADEPT respectively. The estimated signal-to-noise for PLANCK with SDSS-DR4, SDSS3 and ADEPT is 11, 23, and 32. Our method provides a new mean for determining properties of the ionized gas in the Universe. We provide galaxy momentum templates constructed from Sloan Digital Sky Survey online at our website at http://www.astro.princeton.edu/~shirley/SZ/SZ.html. The predicted correlation coefficients are provided along with the momentum maps. One can download the momentum templates and cross-correlate directly with CMB maps from ACT and PLANCK to detect the missing baryons.
BibTeX
@misc{ho2009finding,
  author = {Shirley Ho and Simon DeDeo and David N. Spergel},
  title = {{Finding the Missing Baryons Using CMB as a Backlight}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0903.2845},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0903.2845},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure