Financing Climate-Friendly Cooling at City Scale

Bo Shen, Yun Zhou, Jie Zhou2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes an integrated "city-scale" model to overcome the financial barriers preventing the deployment of climate-friendly cooling in developing Asian cities. By bundling fragmented projects into large portfolios managed by a Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) and utilizing hybrid de-risking tools, the authors provide a blueprint for making green refrigeration and air-conditioning (RAC) bankable and scalable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cooling is a "triple threat" to the climate: it relies on high-global-warming-potential refrigerants (HFCs), consumes massive amounts of electricity (often from fossil fuels), and drives extreme peak demand on power grids. While "green cooling" technologies exist, their adoption in developing countries is stalled by a "valley of death" of financing.

Individual projects—like retrofitting a single supermarket or office building—are often too small and scattered to attract major investors. Furthermore, equipment buyers (often SMEs) lack collateral, while financiers lack the data to trust projected energy savings. This paper tackles the challenge of how to aggregate these "micro-opportunities" into an investment-grade asset class.

Methods

The authors synthesize international best practices in energy efficiency financing to design a novel Integrated Implementation Model. The methodology is a policy and financial framework design rather than an algorithmic approach. Key components include:

  • Aggregation: Using an SPV to bundle projects across industrial, commercial, and residential sectors.
  • Financial Engineering: Combining multilateral development bank (MDB) sovereign loans with government incentives to leverage private commercial capital.
  • Risk Stratification: Comparing and combining credit guarantees (which cover default) with energy savings insurance (which covers technical performance) to lower the risk premium for lenders.

Datasets

The paper draws on two rounds of customer surveys conducted in Ningbo, People’s Republic of China (PRC), targeting institutional customers in the industrial, commercial, and public sectors. It also references historical performance data from established programs, such as:

  • Thailand’s Energy Efficiency Revolving Fund (EERF).
  • The Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) programs in the US.
  • Energy savings insurance programs in Colombia and Mexico.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • From "Project" to "Portfolio": The most critical insight is that the city, not the individual building, is the correct scale for intervention. A city-wide approach reduces transaction costs and allows for "bulk procurement" of high-efficiency equipment.
  • The Hybrid De-risking Edge: The authors argue that neither insurance nor guarantees are sufficient alone. A hybrid approach—where insurance covers the technical "performance risk" and a guarantee covers the "credit risk"—is the most cost-effective way to lower interest rates for borrowers.
  • Cooling as a Service (CaaS): The paper highlights CaaS as a transformative business model. Instead of buying a chiller, a customer pays for "units of cooling." This shifts the burden of maintenance and energy efficiency to the provider, who has a direct financial incentive to optimize the system.
  • Digitalization as a Financial Tool: Real-time IoT monitoring isn't just for engineering; it’s for "Measurement and Verification" (M&V). Reliable data streams reduce the "information asymmetry" that makes banks nervous about green investments.

Key Results

While the paper is a framework proposal, it highlights the potential impact of its components:

  • Efficiency Gains: In the PRC, revised standards for indoor AC are expected to increase efficiency by 14% and remove 45% of inefficient models from the market.
  • Financial Leverage: Thailand’s EERF successfully funded 294 projects with $235 million in total financing, demonstrating that government-backed revolving funds can effectively "prime the pump" for commercial lending.
  • Default Rates: The paper notes that on-bill financing (repaying loans via utility bills) in the US has a default rate under 3%, significantly lower than traditional unsecured loans, proving the effectiveness of the mechanism.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Policy Dependency: The model relies heavily on supportive local government building codes and energy labeling systems. Without a "floor" of regulation, the financial incentives may not be enough to shift the market.
  • Data Gaps: The authors acknowledge that many municipal authorities currently lack the capability to track equipment-level energy consumption, which is a prerequisite for the digital platform proposed in the model.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests further research into "value-stacking," where green cooling is bundled with distributed solar and thermal storage to provide grid-balancing services, creating additional revenue streams for investors.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper explores how greener refrigeration and air-conditioning could be provided at city scale. Refrigeration and air-conditioning are major contributors to climate change, and demand for them is growing. Crucial obstacles to climate-friendly cooling solutions in developing countries in Asia are the lack of accessible and affordable financing and insufficient project scale. This paper discusses a variety of financing instruments and business models and presents an integrated model for financing city-scale green cooling. The model could help roll out green cooling solutions at a scale large enough to attract investors and to reduce transaction costs through standardized implementation.
BibTeX
@misc{shen2023financing,
  author = {Bo Shen and Yun Zhou and Jie Zhou},
  title = {{Financing Climate-Friendly Cooling at City Scale}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.22617/wps230089-2},
}

Loading related content...

Figure