Abstract
This paper outlines a framework for improving the quality and standardization of meteorological and oceanographic (metocean) datasets in the wind energy sector. By explicitly defining the roles of stakeholders—including the project owner, dataset producer, and dataset user—the authors advocate for a shift toward binary file formats, rigorous uncertainty propagation, and FAIR data principles. The project owner is identified as a key driver of change, holding the contractual power to define the scope of work and requirements for measurement campaigns. This refinement ensures that the term "dataset producer" is used precisely and that accountability for data quality is shared across the project lifecycle.
Introduction: Addressing "CSV Hell"
In the wind energy industry, metocean data—such as wind speed, wave height, and temperature—is fundamental to design and operations. However, these datasets are frequently plagued by "CSV hell": inconsistent text-based formatting, ambiguous metadata, and a lack of clear information regarding measurement uncertainty.
A systemic gap exists where the dataset user receives sub-optimal data because the producer is not incentivized to exceed basic requirements, and the project owner (the funding entity) has not explicitly demanded higher standards. This paper bridges that gap by providing concrete recommendations for all three stakeholders to improve the state-of-the-art in data delivery.
The Stakeholder Framework
A core contribution of this work is the formalization of stakeholder roles:
- Project Owner: Defines the scope of work and sets the contractual requirements for the measurement campaign.
- Dataset Producer: Executes the campaign and generates the data according to the owner's specifications.
- Dataset User: Analyzes the data for engineering or research purposes.
By empowering the project owner to demand better standards, the responsibility for data quality shifts from a technical burden on the producer to a contractual deliverable.
Methodological Improvements
The authors propose a standardized workflow for processing 10-minute metocean statistics, focusing on three pillars:
1. Uncertainty and Bias Propagation
Rather than relying solely on sensor-specific models, the authors advocate for a generic uncertainty framework. This uses mathematical formulas to propagate absolute and relative uncertainties and biases through the 10-minute averaging process. This provides a high-value "sanity check" applicable to any quantity, resulting in "bias-corrected" statistics that are more reliable for engineering models.
2. Transition to Binary Formats
The paper takes a firm stance against text-based formats like CSV for large-scale analysis. The authors recommend self-describing binary formats—specifically HDF5 and netCDF4. These formats offer significant efficiency gains for modern research and commercial workflows, making data machine-readable and easier to manage.
3. Metadata and FAIR Principles
To ensure data is globally understandable, the framework integrates the EERA-JP wind energy taxonomies and CF Conventions. The authors provide metadata in both human-readable and machine-readable YAML files. Furthermore, the paper includes a qualitative assessment of datasets based on FAIR principles (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable), providing a roadmap for full compliance.
Proof of Concept: Legacy Datasets
The recommendations were applied to three prominent offshore wind measurement datasets:
- OWEZ (Offshore Windpark Egmond aan Zee)
- MMIJ (Meetmast IJmuiden)
- FINO1 (Forschungsplattformen in Nord- und Ostsee Nr. 1)
The authors developed a script bundle to convert these legacy datasets into standardized HDF5 and netCDF4 versions, demonstrating the feasibility of professionalizing existing data archives.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The evolution of this work, reflected in the updated title "How to improve the state-of-the-art in metocean measurement datasets," emphasizes a collaborative approach to data quality. While the authors acknowledge the perspective of the data user, the path forward requires project owners to adopt these recommendations as normative requirements in new measurement campaigns. Moving away from text-based formats is an essential investment in the long-term efficiency and reliability of wind energy research.
Summary updated