Field Measurement and Evaluation of the Passive and Active Solar Heating Systems for Residential Building Based on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau Case

Zhijian Liu, Di Wu, Miao Jiang, Hancheng Yu, Ma WenshengEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the effectiveness of passive and active solar heating systems in a residential building on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau. It demonstrates that both solar strategies significantly improve indoor temperatures compared to a reference condition, with active solar heating showing the most substantial benefits, meeting a higher percentage of heating needs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau, despite its abundant solar resources, faces challenges with traditional heating due to high altitudes and low oxygen levels, leading to inefficient fuel use and environmental concerns. While solar heating is recognized as a solution, there's a lack of quantitative evaluation for its effectiveness in residential buildings in this specific, harsh climate. This paper aims to fill that gap by comparing the performance of passive solar heating, active solar heating, and a baseline "reference" condition in a real-world residential setting.

Methods

The researchers implemented three distinct heating scenarios in a demonstration residential building:

  • Reference Condition: The building was sealed with reflectors on external doors and windows, and the heat pump system was turned off. This scenario represents the building's ability to maintain temperature solely through its inherent insulation and any residual heat.
  • Passive Solar Heating Condition: External reflectors were removed, allowing solar radiation to enter through windows and the sunspace, but the heat pump system remained off. This tests the building's passive solar gain capabilities.
  • Active Solar Heating Condition: The passive solar gains were supplemented by an active solar-air energy heat pump system.

Hourly indoor air temperatures in each room were meticulously measured using thermocouples. Outdoor temperature and solar radiation were also recorded. The heating effect was evaluated using the "ratio of indoor and outdoor degree hour," a metric designed to quantify how much of the required indoor heating effect is achieved by each strategy.

Datasets

The study utilized real-time environmental data collected from a single demonstration residential building located in Wangtun village, Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau. This building served as the sole experimental site, and the data collected over specific testing periods in January constituted the dataset for evaluation. No pre-existing datasets were used for training or comparison beyond the reference condition established within the study itself.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Core Zones Benefit Most: Living rooms and bedrooms consistently showed the highest indoor temperatures under both passive and active solar heating, highlighting the importance of direct solar gain and strategic room placement.
  • Passive Solar's Contribution: Even without active systems, passive solar heating significantly boosted indoor temperatures in core zones by 2-5°C compared to the reference condition, demonstrating the value of direct gain windows and sunspaces.
  • Active Solar's Superiority: The active solar heating system provided the most substantial improvement, raising average core zone temperatures by approximately 8°C and 6°C compared to the reference and passive conditions, respectively, and maintaining temperatures significantly above the outdoor ambient.
  • Degree Hour as a Performance Metric: The "ratio of indoor and outdoor degree hour" proved to be a useful metric for quantifying the effectiveness of different heating strategies, allowing for a comparative analysis of their contribution to meeting heating demands.
  • Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau Potential: The findings strongly support the viability of solar heating solutions for this challenging climate, offering a sustainable alternative to conventional fuels.

Key Results

  • Reference Condition: Average indoor temperatures in core zones were low, around 3-4°C, with significant drops at night.
  • Passive Solar Heating: Core zone temperatures increased by 2-5°C compared to the reference. The sunspace experienced the highest temperatures (around 20°C) but also significant fluctuations. However, passive solar alone did not consistently meet the technical specification's requirement of 14°C for passive solar houses.
  • Active Solar Heating: Core zone temperatures were significantly higher, averaging around 13-14°C, which is about 17°C higher than the outdoor temperature. This strategy achieved a 75% degree hour ratio with a reference temperature of 18°C, indicating it could satisfy a substantial portion of the heating energy requirements.
  • Degree Hour Ratios:
    • Reference condition (14°C reference temp): 38.3%
    • Passive solar heating (14°C reference temp): 49.8%
    • Active solar heating (18°C reference temp): 75%

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Building Study: The findings are based on a single demonstration building, which may not be representative of all residential structures in the region.
  • Short Testing Period: The tests were conducted over a limited period in January, the coldest month. Longer-term studies would provide a more comprehensive understanding of performance across different weather conditions.
  • Data Interruption: The active solar heating test experienced a data interruption due to a local power supply breakdown, requiring some trend speculation.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that these findings can serve as a reference for the design and application of solar heating in similar climate areas. Further research could explore optimization of system design, integration with other renewable energy sources, and long-term performance monitoring.

Summary updated

Abstract

Passive and active solar heating systems have drawn much attention and are widely used in residence buildings in the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau due to its high radiation intensity. In fact, there is still lack of quantitative evaluation of the passive and active heating effect, especially for residential building in the Qinghai-Tibetan plateau areas. In this study, three kinds of heating strategies, including reference condition, passive solar heating condition and active solar heating condition, were tested in one demonstration residential building. The hourly air temperatures of each room under different conditions were obtained and analyzed. The results show the indoor air temperature in the living room and bedrooms (core zones) was much higher than that of other rooms under both passive and active solar heating conditions. In addition, the heating effect with different strategies for core zones of the building was evaluated by the ratio of indoor and outdoor degree hour, which indicates that solar heating could effectively reduce the traditional energy consumption and improve the indoor thermal environment. The passive solar heating could undertake 49.8% degree hours for heating under an evaluation criterion of 14 °C and the active solar heating could undertake 75% degree hours for heating under evaluation criterion of 18 °C, which indicated that solar heating could effectively reduce the traditional energy consumption and improve the indoor thermal environment in this area. These findings could provide reference for the design and application of solar heating in similar climate areas.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2017field,
  author = {Zhijian Liu and Di Wu and Miao Jiang and Hancheng Yu and Ma Wensheng},
  title = {{Field Measurement and Evaluation of the Passive and Active Solar Heating Systems for Residential Building Based on the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau Case}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10111706},
}
Figure