Fiber Fabry-Perot Force Sensor with Small Volume and High Performance for Assessing Fretting Damage of Steam Generator Tubes

Peijian Huang, Ning Wang, Junying Li, Yong Zhu, Jie Zhang2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, miniaturized fiber Fabry-Perot (F-P) force sensor designed to measure radial collision forces between steam generator tubes (SGTs) and tube support plates (TSPs) in nuclear power plants. The sensor's small size and robust performance in harsh environments (high pressure, temperature, humidity, and vibration) make it suitable for assessing fretting damage, a critical safety concern.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Steam generator tube rupture (SGTR) is a significant safety issue in nuclear power plants, with fretting damage being a primary cause of fatigue cracks. This damage arises from the fluid motion and thermal energy transmission between SGTs and TSPs, leading to collisions. To assess this damage, it's crucial to measure the radial impact force and axial displacement between the SGT and TSP. While axial displacement is relatively easy to measure, accurately quantifying the radial impact force in the confined, high-pressure, and high-temperature environment of a steam generator is a significant challenge. Existing electric force sensors are too large for these tight spaces, necessitating the development of smaller, more robust sensing solutions.

Methods

The researchers developed a micro-machined fiber F-P force sensor. The core of the sensor is a clamped-clamped beam element that deforms under applied force, causing a change in the F-P cavity length. This change is then detected and demodulated using a non-scanning correlation method.

Key aspects of their approach include:

  • Sensor Design: A clamped-clamped beam was chosen over a cantilever beam due to its superior ability to maintain parallelism between the F-P cavity's reflective surfaces, which is critical for optical performance and measurement accuracy.
  • Material Selection: High-temperature and high-pressure resistant materials were crucial. Quartz was used for the optical fibers, and 3Cr13 stainless steel was selected for the sensing beam and packaging due to its suitable elasticity modulus, tensile strength, and heat expansion coefficient.
  • Demodulation: A non-scanning correlation demodulation method was employed to extract the F-P cavity length variation from the spectral signal. This method relies on the intensity output from the F-P cavity and is processed to determine the cavity length change.
  • Calibration: A three-point fixing device was used for calibration, establishing a linear relationship between the applied force and the sensor's output voltage.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments involved calibration using a controlled force application and testing in simulated and real-world environments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Miniaturization is Key: The paper highlights that existing sensors are too large for the critical SGT-TSP interface, underscoring the need for sensors with dimensions as small as 17 mm × 5 mm × 3 mm.
  • Clamped-Clamped Beam Advantage: While cantilever beams offer higher sensitivity, the clamped-clamped beam design was preferred for its better maintenance of optical cavity parallelism, crucial for reliable F-P interferometry.
  • Environmental Robustness: The sensor demonstrated stable performance in simulated humid, high-pressure (10 MPa), high-temperature (350 °C), and vibration (40 kHz) environments, which are representative of actual steam generator conditions.
  • Direct Measurement of Collision Force: The successful installation and operation in a 1:1 steam generator test loop validate the sensor's ability to directly measure the radial collision force, providing valuable data for fretting damage assessment.

Key Results

  • Measurement Range and Resolution: The calibrated F-P force sensor achieved a measurement range of 0–200 N with a resolution of 1 N.
  • Dimensions: The encapsulated fiber F-P sensor has overall dimensions of 17 mm × 5 mm × 3 mm.
  • Environmental Performance:
    • In humid and high-pressure (10 MPa) environments, the sensor showed stable response with a Mean Squared Error (MSE) of 5.95 × 10⁻⁴ for cavity length.
  • In a vibration environment (40 KHz), the sensor also exhibited stable performance with an MSE of 5.96 × 10⁻⁴.
  • In a high-temperature environment (350 °C), the sensor maintained its performance, with a slight decrease in F-P cavity length but no degradation in signal contrast, and an MSE of 6.02 × 10⁻⁴.
  • Test Loop Results: In the 1:1 steam generator test loop, the sensor successfully measured radial collision forces, with one test point indicating a force of approximately 22 N.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Demodulation System: The paper mentions that the corresponding optical demodulation system will be investigated in future work. This suggests that while the sensor itself is promising, optimizing the signal processing for even higher accuracy or speed might be an area for further development.
  • Long-term Performance: While the sensor performed well in various simulated environments, long-term operational stability and potential degradation over extended periods in a real nuclear power plant environment are not extensively discussed.
  • Impact of Vibration on Parallelism: The paper notes that tilt deformation of the F-P cavity must be kept small to avoid demodulation issues. While the clamped-clamped beam mitigates this, the paper acknowledges that an exerted force can reduce parallelism, especially in cantilever designs. Further analysis on how vibration might affect this parallelism in the chosen design could be beneficial.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{huang2017fiber,
  author = {Peijian Huang and Ning Wang and Junying Li and Yong Zhu and Jie Zhang},
  title = {{Fiber Fabry-Perot Force Sensor with Small Volume and High Performance for Assessing Fretting Damage of Steam Generator Tubes}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/s17122899},
}

Loading related content...

Figure