Fetal cranial growth trajectories are associated with growth and neurodevelopment at 2 years of age: INTERBIO-21st Fetal Study

José Villar, Robert B. Gunier, Chrystelle O.o. Tshivuila-Matala, Stephen Rauch, François Nosten, Roseline Ochieng, María Clara Restrepo–Méndez, Rose McGready, Fernando C. Barros, Michelle Fernandes, Verena I. Carrara, César G. Victora, Shama Munim, Rachel Craik, Hellen C. Barsosio, Maria Carvalho, James A. Berkley, Leila Cheikh Ismail, Shane A. Norris, Eric O. Ohuma, Alan Stein, Ann Lambert, Adele Winsey, Ricardo Uauy, Brenda Eskenazi, Zulfiqar A Bhutta, Aris T. Papageorghiou, Stephen KennedyNature Medicine 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study identifies distinct patterns of fetal head growth, or "trajectories," that are linked to a child's neurodevelopment, vision, and overall growth at age two. These findings highlight a critical window during pregnancy (20-25 weeks gestation) where fetal head growth may serve as a proxy for neurodevelopmental potential, suggesting opportunities for early intervention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how events during pregnancy impact a child's long-term health and development is crucial for improving child outcomes. While many studies link fetal insults or interventions to later development, they often suffer from limitations like imprecise gestational age estimation, difficulty in quantifying fetal growth restriction, and reliance on retrospective data. This paper aims to address these by using precise ultrasound measurements to track fetal head growth longitudinally and link these patterns to detailed neurodevelopmental and growth assessments in early childhood. The goal is to identify specific fetal growth trajectories that predict later outcomes, potentially revealing critical periods for intervention.

Methods

The researchers employed a finite mixture model approach to identify distinct fetal cranial growth trajectories. This statistical method allows for the modeling of longitudinal data and the identification of latent classes (groups) with similar growth patterns. They used serial ultrasound measurements of fetal head circumference (HC) from less than 14 weeks gestation up to 37 weeks. These trajectories were then analyzed in relation to a comprehensive set of neurodevelopmental assessments (cognitive, language, motor skills, behavior, vision) and anthropometric measures at age two, using adjusted linear regression and Poisson regression models.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the INTERBIO-21st Fetal Study, a prospective, multinational cohort of 3,598 pregnant women followed from early pregnancy until their children reached two years of age. Data collection was standardized across six international sites. The study also referenced existing international standards for fetal growth (INTERGROWTH-21st) and child growth (WHO Child Growth Standards) for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fetal Head Growth as a Proxy for Neurodevelopment: The study strongly suggests that fetal head growth trajectories, particularly between 20-25 weeks gestation, can serve as a reliable proxy for neurodevelopmental potential. This is a significant conceptual advance, moving beyond simple size measurements.
  • Critical Window for Intervention: The identification of a critical window (20-25 weeks) where fetal head growth patterns diverge and become predictive of later outcomes highlights a crucial period for potential interventions to improve neurodevelopment.
  • Mirror Pattern of Outcomes: The observed associations between fetal growth trajectories and neurodevelopmental outcomes showed a consistent "mirror" pattern, where certain trajectories were associated with better outcomes, while others were linked to poorer ones, across multiple domains.
  • Independence of Associations: The study's findings on fetal head circumference growth remained significant even after adjusting for other factors like abdominal circumference growth, birth size, and postnatal morbidity, suggesting a direct link between fetal head growth and later development.

Key Results

The study identified five distinct fetal cranial growth trajectories.

  • The "Early Faltering" (EF) trajectory was associated with significantly poorer outcomes in cognitive, language, and fine motor domains at age two, as well as a higher risk of poor vision.
  • The "Accelerating Growth" (AG) and "Late Median Growth" (LMGT) trajectories were associated with better language development and improved visual acuity.
  • Children in the EF trajectory also showed diminished growth (height, weight, head circumference) at age two.
  • These associations were robust and remained statistically significant after accounting for multiple confounding factors.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Exploration of Early Etiological Factors: The study did not explore early pregnancy risk factors (e.g., maternal nutritional status) that might influence fetal growth.
  • Parental and Sibling Data: The absence of parental and sibling developmental profiles limits the ability to fully account for genetic influences or family-level developmental risks.
  • Screening Tool Potential: While the findings are promising, further research is needed to determine if these trajectories can be effectively used as a population-level or individual-level screening tool.

Future work should focus on translating these biological findings into clinical and public health actions, emphasizing the importance of early antenatal care and exploring interventions that target the identified critical window of opportunity.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{villar2021fetal,
  author = {José Villar and Robert B. Gunier and Chrystelle O.O. Tshivuila-Matala and Stephen Rauch and François Nosten and Roseline Ochieng and María Clara Restrepo–Méndez and Rose McGready and Fernando C. Barros and Michelle Fernandes and Verena I. Carrara and César G. Victora and Shama Munim and Rachel Craik and Hellen C. Barsosio and Maria Carvalho and James A. Berkley and Leila Cheikh Ismail and Shane A. Norris and Eric O. Ohuma and Alan Stein and Ann Lambert and Adele Winsey and Ricardo Uauy and Brenda Eskenazi and Zulfiqar A Bhutta and Aris T. Papageorghiou and Stephen Kennedy},
  title = {{Fetal cranial growth trajectories are associated with growth and neurodevelopment at 2 years of age: INTERBIO-21st Fetal Study}},
  booktitle = {Nature Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41591-021-01280-2},
}
Figure