TL;DR
China's "three-child policy" has done little to boost fertility intentions, with only 7.6% of childbearing-age individuals wanting a third child and 12.7% willing to have another child. Key factors influencing these low rates include age, sex, education, income, and pension coverage, highlighting the need for comprehensive policy interventions beyond just family size recommendations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
China is facing a significant demographic challenge: a rapidly declining fertility rate leading to population contraction and an aging society. Despite policy shifts, including the introduction of the three-child policy in 2021, the birth rate remains critically low. Understanding the fertility intentions of the childbearing-age population and the factors influencing these intentions is crucial for developing effective policies to address this demographic crisis. Previous research has been fragmented, with many local surveys yielding inconsistent results. This paper aims to provide a unified, systematic overview of fertility intentions and their determinants in China following the three-child policy.
Methods
The researchers conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of 37 cross-sectional studies published between May 2021 and May 2025, involving over 113,000 participants. They searched multiple databases (PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, and Chinese databases like CNKI and Wanfang) using a comprehensive set of keywords related to fertility intention and China. Studies were assessed for quality using the Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal Checklist. The analysis focused on two primary outcomes: third-child fertility intention (TCFI) and willingness to have another child (WHAC) among those with two children. Random-effects models were used to estimate pooled prevalence and odds ratios (ORs) for associated factors, with heterogeneity assessed using Cochran's Q test and the I² statistic. Subgroup and sensitivity analyses were performed to explore sources of heterogeneity and assess the robustness of the findings.
Datasets
The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it synthesized data from 37 existing cross-sectional studies conducted in China. These studies were collected through a systematic search of various academic databases.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Policy Impact is Limited: The three-child policy, while a significant shift, has not demonstrably increased fertility intentions among the general childbearing population. The low rates of TCFI and WHAC suggest deeper societal and economic factors are at play.
- Economic Burdens are Paramount: The paper strongly suggests that the high financial costs associated with raising children in China are a major deterrent. This is reflected in the finding that higher personal income is linked to a greater willingness to have a third child, implying that financial relief could be a key policy lever.
- Beyond Procreation: Social and Personal Factors Matter: Fertility decisions are not solely about having children but are influenced by a complex interplay of age, gender roles, educational aspirations, and social security. The findings highlight that addressing these multifaceted aspects is essential for any successful fertility promotion strategy.
- Regional Disparities are Stark: Significant regional differences in fertility intentions were observed, with higher rates in the Northeast and lower rates in the East. This underscores the need for localized policy approaches that consider regional economic and social contexts.
Key Results
- Pooled Prevalence:
- Third-child fertility intention (TCFI): 7.6% (95% CI=5.4–10.6%)
- Willingness to have another child (WHAC): 12.7% (95% CI=9.6–16.8%)
- Significant Predictors of TCFI:
- Age: Individuals aged >35 years were twice as likely to report TCFI (OR=1.968).
- Sex: Men were more than twice as likely as women to report a willingness for a third child (OR=2.356).
- Education: Those with high school education or below were significantly more likely to report TCFI (OR=2.274).
- Income: Monthly personal income > CNY 2000 was associated with higher TCFI (OR=1.661).
- Ethnicity: Minority groups were more likely to express TCFI (OR=1.305).
- Family Structure: Couples where at least one spouse was not an only child had higher intention for a third birth (OR=1.289).
- Pension Coverage: Individuals without pension insurance had higher TCFI (OR=2.159).
- Significant Predictors of WHAC:
- Marital Status: Remarried individuals were more likely to plan another child (OR=2.143).
- Health Status: Those reporting good health had higher WHAC (OR=1.341).
- High Heterogeneity: The study noted extremely high statistical heterogeneity across the included studies, suggesting that findings should be interpreted as general trends.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Geographical Concentration: Most included studies were conducted in eastern and central China, potentially limiting the generalizability of findings to other regions.
- Varied Measurement Instruments: Differences in survey instruments and definitions across studies may have influenced the results' robustness.
- Confounding Factors: While multivariate logistic regression was used, direct pooling of adjusted ORs was not always feasible due to grouping criteria variations, potentially overlooking some confounding effects.
- Limited Subgroup Analysis: The limited number of studies made it difficult to explore heterogeneity sources through extensive subgroup analysis.
Future work should focus on addressing these limitations by conducting studies with standardized methodologies across diverse regions and exploring the impact of specific policy interventions more deeply. The authors also suggest prioritizing policies that strengthen childcare subsidies, improve healthcare support, and tackle fundamental socioeconomic barriers like housing and education to promote sustainable fertility intentions.
Summary updated