Fenestration after orthodontic traction of an impacted dilacerated maxillary central incisor: a case report and 4-year follow-up

Shuhao Xu, Xiaolong Li, Yu Zhang, Wei LiFrontiers in Dental Medicine 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This case report demonstrates that orthodontic traction can successfully salvage a severely "dilacerated" (sharply bent) and impacted front tooth, even when the procedure results in the root poking through the alveolar bone (fenestration). Despite a 90-degree root bend and a four-year follow-up showing persistent fenestration, the tooth remained healthy, stable, and fully functional, suggesting that the long-term prognosis for such high-risk cases may be more favorable than previously thought.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a complex clinical challenge in orthodontics: the management of a dilacerated impacted maxillary central incisor.

Dilaceration refers to a developmental anomaly where there is a sharp, angular bend between the crown and the root of a tooth. When such a tooth is impacted (fails to erupt and remains stuck in the bone), treatment is notoriously difficult. Because the root is bent—often at a 90-degree angle—moving the tooth into its proper position (orthodontic traction) risks pushing the root tip through the thin "cortical" bone that encases the jaw. This creates a fenestration, essentially a window where the root is no longer covered by bone.

Historically, clinicians have worried that fenestration and the resulting short, distorted roots would lead to tooth loss, instability, or pulp death. This paper investigates whether a tooth can remain viable and stable over the long term (4 years) despite these complications.

Methods

As a clinical case report, the "methods" involve the diagnostic and therapeutic journey of an 11-year-old patient:

  1. Diagnosis: The team used Cone-Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT) to create a 3D map of the impaction. They identified a 90-degree crown-root angulation, which is considered a severe deformity.
  2. Surgical Exposure: Surgeons uncovered the palatal surface of the hidden tooth to allow for the attachment of orthodontic hardware.
  3. Orthodontic Traction: A "2 × 4" fixed appliance (braces on four incisors and two molars) was used. A lingual button was bonded to the impacted tooth, and light, "occlusally-directed" forces were applied to slowly pull the tooth into the dental arch.
  4. Retention and Monitoring: After 15 months of active treatment, the tooth was aligned. The patient was monitored for four years using clinical exams (checking for mobility and "pulp vitality" or nerve health) and follow-up CBCT scans.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a case report, the "data" is derived from the clinical records, photographs, and radiographic scans of a single 11-year-old male patient.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Physical Interlock" Hypothesis: One of the most interesting takeaways is why a tooth with a short, bent root stays stable. The authors suggest that the dilacerated root creates a "physical interlock" with the surrounding alveolar bone. This mechanical "hook" allows the tooth to withstand the forces of chewing even without a standard root length.
  • Physiological Relapse as Adaptation: During the follow-up, the tooth showed a slight "labial relapse" (tilting forward). Rather than seeing this as a failure, the authors suggest it might be a physiological adaptation. By tilting slightly, the root may have moved into a more stable position within the "cancellous" (spongy) bone.
  • Resilience of the Dental Pulp: Despite the significant trauma of being pulled through bone and the eventual fenestration of the root apex, the tooth maintained normal pulp vitality (the internal nerve and blood supply remained healthy) throughout the four-year period.
  • Challenging the "Optimal Window": While early intervention is usually preferred (before the root finishes forming), this case shows success in an 11-year-old whose root development was already advanced, suggesting the window for treatment may be wider than expected.

Key Results

  • Successful Alignment: The severely impacted tooth was successfully moved into the correct position in the dental arch within 15 months.
  • Long-term Stability: At the 4-year follow-up, the tooth exhibited zero abnormal mobility and positive pulp vitality.
  • Radiographic Findings: Follow-up CBCT confirmed that while the tooth was functional, the root apex remained outside the bone (fenestration), and the 90-degree bend persisted.
  • Patient Satisfaction: Despite a visible "root bulge" in the gum line due to the fenestration, the patient and parents reported high satisfaction with the aesthetic and functional outcome.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is that this is a single case report ($N=1$). While the results are encouraging, they cannot be generalized to all patients without larger, controlled clinical studies.

The authors also note a few areas for technical improvement:

  • Surgical Technique: They suggest that a "closed-eruption" surgical method (where the gum is sutured back over the tooth during traction) might have better preserved the gingival attachment compared to the method used.
  • Root Resection: In future cases, performing a minor surgery to remove the bent tip of the root (apicoectomy) after traction might allow the remaining root to sit entirely within the bone, potentially avoiding fenestration altogether.
  • Need for Longitudinal Data: More studies are needed to see if these teeth remain stable over 10 or 20 years, especially as the patient enters full adulthood.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dilacerated impacted maxillary central incisors require early detection, early diagnosis, and early treatment. Early orthodontic traction can allow the root, which is confined by the buccal or palatal cortical bone, to rotate along with the crown and enter the cancellous bone, thereby gaining an opportunity for continued development. We reported a case of an 11-year-old boy with an impacted dilacerated maxillary central incisor. Following surgical exposure combined with orthodontic traction, fenestration occurred. However, after four years of follow-up, the affected tooth exhibited normal pulp vitality and no abnormal mobility. This case might offer an indication that even for dilacerated maxillary central incisors with short roots, or those that develop fenestration after traction, the long-term outcomes of traction treatment could be quite favorable.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2026fenestration,
  author = {Shuhao Xu and Xiaolong Li and Yu Zhang and Wei Li},
  title = {{Fenestration after orthodontic traction of an impacted dilacerated maxillary central incisor: a case report and 4-year follow-up}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Dental Medicine},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.3389/fdmed.2026.1764953},
}
Figure