Female philopatry in coastal basins and male dispersion across the North Atlantic in a highly mobile marine species, the sperm whale (Physeter macrocephalus)

Daniel Engelhaupt, A. Rus Hoelzel, Colin Nicholson, Alexandros Frantzis, Sarah L. Mesnick, Shane Gero, Hal Whitehead, Luke Rendell, Patrick J. O. Miller, Renaud De Stefanis, Ana Cañadas, Sabina Airoldi, Antonio A. Mignucci‐GiannoniMolecular 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that female sperm whales exhibit strong fidelity to specific coastal regions like the Gulf of Mexico and the Mediterranean Sea, while males are highly mobile and disperse across the North Atlantic. This sex-biased dispersal pattern is crucial for understanding sperm whale population structure and has significant implications for their conservation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how highly mobile marine species maintain distinct populations is a significant challenge in evolutionary biology and conservation. Unlike terrestrial species, marine environments often lack obvious physical barriers, making it difficult to pinpoint the factors that drive population structure. This paper specifically investigates the sperm whale, a highly mobile and widely distributed marine mammal, to uncover the mechanisms behind its population structuring. The researchers aim to determine if factors like geographic distance, oceanic currents, or habitat specialization are responsible, and crucially, whether there are differences in movement patterns between males and females, a phenomenon observed in other species.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of molecular genetic techniques to analyze sperm whale populations.

  • Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) Control Region Sequencing: They sequenced a portion of the mtDNA control region from 293 sperm whale samples. mtDNA is maternally inherited, making it a powerful tool for tracking female lineages and their movements.
  • Microsatellite DNA Analysis: They analyzed 16 polymorphic microsatellite loci from the nuclear DNA of sperm whales. Microsatellites are highly variable regions of DNA inherited from both parents, providing insights into overall population structure and gene flow.
  • Statistical Analyses: A suite of statistical methods was used to analyze the genetic data:
  • Diversity Measures: Haplotype and nucleotide diversity were calculated to assess genetic variation within populations.
  • Differentiation Tests: Exact tests, AMOVA (Analysis of Molecular Variance), Fst, and OST were used to quantify genetic differentiation between populations.
  • Sex-Biased Dispersal Tests: Specific analyses (e.g., using FSTAT) were conducted to compare genetic patterns between sexes and infer differential dispersal.
  • Population Bottleneck Tests: Programs like Bottleneck were used to detect evidence of recent population size reductions.
  • Population Structure Analysis: The STRUCTURE program was employed to infer the number of distinct genetic clusters within the sampled populations.
  • Kinship Control: To mitigate potential biases from sampling related individuals, two datasets were created: an "all" dataset and a "restricted" dataset where highly related individuals were removed.

Datasets

The study utilized tissue samples collected from sperm whales across four geographical regions:

  • Gulf of Mexico (GOM): 153 samples
  • Western North Atlantic Ocean (WNAO): 84 samples
  • Mediterranean Sea (MED): 44 samples
  • North Sea (NSEA): 20 samples

These samples were obtained through biopsy, sloughed skin retrieval, and from stranded whales. The data generated from these samples formed the basis for all analyses. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, existing genetic markers and analytical tools were applied to these specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Female Philopatry is Strong: The most striking finding is the clear evidence of female sperm whales being "philopatric," meaning they return to or remain in the same coastal areas for breeding and potentially other life stages. This was particularly evident in the Gulf of Mexico and the Mediterranean Sea.
  • Males are the Dispersers: In stark contrast to females, male sperm whales appear to be highly mobile, facilitating gene flow across vast oceanic distances, specifically across the North Atlantic.
  • mtDNA vs. Microsatellites Tell Different Stories: The study highlights how different types of genetic markers can reveal distinct patterns. mtDNA showed significant differentiation between most populations, reflecting female movements, while microsatellites, inherited from both parents, showed much less differentiation, supporting the idea of male-mediated gene flow homogenizing genetic variation across broader scales.
  • Coastal Basins as Refugia/Breeding Grounds: The research suggests that specific coastal basins, like the GOM and MED, act as important, relatively isolated units for female sperm whales, potentially due to resource availability or social structures.
  • Conservation Implications: The identified distinct female populations underscore the need for geographically specific conservation strategies, treating these basins as separate management units.

Key Results

  • mtDNA Differentiation: Mitochondrial DNA analyses revealed significant genetic differentiation between nearly all sampled populations, including between the Gulf of Mexico and the Western North Atlantic, despite their proximity. The Mediterranean Sea population showed particularly low, and in some cases, no detectable mtDNA diversity.
  • Microsatellite Differentiation: Microsatellite DNA analyses showed significant differentiation only when comparing the Mediterranean Sea population to others. Differentiation between other North Atlantic populations was minimal or non-existent.
  • Sex-Biased Dispersal: Statistical tests specifically designed to detect sex-biased dispersal indicated that males are the more dispersing sex, consistent with the observed patterns in mtDNA and microsatellite data.
  • Low mtDNA Diversity: Sperm whales in general, and particularly those in the Mediterranean Sea, exhibited very low levels of mtDNA diversity, suggesting a potential bottleneck or a long history of isolation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Sample Size for North Sea: The North Sea sample size (n=20) was relatively small, which may limit the power of some analyses for this specific population.
  • Potential for Kinship Bias: While efforts were made to control for kinship bias, the authors acknowledge that it can be challenging to completely eliminate, especially in studies of social species.
  • Bottleneck Ambiguity: The results for population bottleneck tests were somewhat equivocal, with some evidence for historical expansion but less clear signals for recent bottlenecks.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this study provides a framework for understanding sex-biased dispersal in other highly mobile marine species. Further research could explore the specific environmental or social factors driving female philopatry in these coastal basins and investigate the fine-scale movement patterns of males across the North Atlantic. The findings also highlight the importance of considering these distinct populations for effective conservation management in the face of increasing anthropogenic pressures.

Summary updated

Abstract

The mechanisms that determine population structure in highly mobile marine species are poorly understood, but useful towards understanding the evolution of diversity, and essential for effective conservation and management. In this study, we compare putative sperm whale populations located in the Gulf of Mexico, western North Atlantic, Mediterranean Sea and North Sea using mtDNA control region sequence data and 16 polymorphic microsatellite loci. The Gulf of Mexico, western North Atlantic and North Sea populations each possessed similar low levels of haplotype and nucleotide diversity at the mtDNA locus, while the Mediterranean Sea population showed no detectable mtDNA diversity. Mitochondrial DNA results showed significant differentiation between all populations, while microsatellites showed significant differentiation only for comparisons with the Mediterranean Sea, and at a much lower level than seen for mtDNA. Samples from either side of the North Atlantic in coastal waters showed no differentiation for mtDNA, while North Atlantic samples from just outside the Gulf of Mexico (the western North Atlantic sample) were highly differentiated from samples within the Gulf at this locus. Our analyses indicate a previously unknown fidelity of females to coastal basins either side of the North Atlantic, and suggest the movement of males among these populations for breeding.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{engelhaupt2009female,
  author = {Daniel Engelhaupt and A. Rus Hoelzel and Colin Nicholson and Alexandros Frantzis and Sarah L. Mesnick and Shane Gero and Hal Whitehead and Luke Rendell and Patrick J. O. Miller and Renaud De Stefanis and Ana Cañadas and Sabina Airoldi and Antonio A. Mignucci‐Giannoni},
  title = {{Female philopatry in coastal basins and male dispersion across the North Atlantic in a highly mobile marine species, the sperm whale (<i>Physeter macrocephalus</i>)}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1111/j.1365-294x.2009.04355.x},
}
Figure