Female career interruption and social integration: An interaction between human capital and new media use

Chunyan Li, Yong‐Jin Liu, Weiming LiFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Promoting the social integration of various groups provides a significant guarantee for China to achieve high-quality development. However, female workers, as the main force of the service industry, had suffered a greater occupational impact due to COVID-19 and loosened China's fertility policy in 2021. After female career interruption, the change in women's social roles and networks has aroused concern about their social integration. However, limited attention had been paid to female career interruption in existing studies about social integration. Therefore, this study developed a theoretical model to explore the relationship between female career interruption and social integration. An empirical test using data from the fourth Chinese Women's Social Status Survey of Hainan Province was applied to evaluate the hypotheses. The results indicate that there is a significantly negative correlation between female career interruption and social integration. And there is a difference among female career interrupters with different quantiles of social integration. Furthermore, the impact of human capital on the link between female career interruption and social integration depended on the type of new media use. When female career interrupters who use strong learning-oriented new media (such as learning about news, working/business, studying online, and investing/financial management) encounter human capital, the relationship between female career interruption and social integration is minimal. In contrast, this relationship is enhanced when female career interrupters who use strong amusing-oriented new media (such as online consumption, chatting, entertainment, and games) are confronted with human capital. Meanwhile, the results of quantile regression show that the secondary moderating effect of learning-oriented new media use gradually weakens with the rise of the quantile of female social integration. And so does amusing-oriented new media use. However, a moderating effect of human capital alone is not found.

Introduction

In the wake of COVID-19 and China’s shift toward a "three-child policy," female workers in the service industry face unprecedented risks of career interruption. When a woman leaves the workforce for an extended period, she doesn't just lose a paycheck; she often loses her professional network, social status, and sense of psychological belonging—a process defined as a decline in social integration.

While previous research has focused on the social integration of migrants, this paper tackles a neglected demographic: female career interrupters. The authors set out to determine if human capital (education, health, and training) acts as a buffer against social isolation and how the "double-edged sword" of new media use (the internet and social platforms) influences this dynamic.

Methods and Data

The study utilized the Hainan database of the Fourth Chinese Women’s Social Status Survey (2020), focusing on a final sample of 381 valid female responses within the legal working age. The researchers developed a theoretical model evaluating social integration across four dimensions: economic, cultural, psychological, and institutional.

To construct the social integration score, the researchers employed Factor Analysis to synthesize 10 distinct indicators, ranging from income level to social insurance participation.

Table 1: Indicator measurements used to define the dimensions of social integration.

The analysis further utilized Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) Regression to identify average relationships and Quantile Regression to observe how impacts differ across various levels of integration. A moderating analysis was also conducted to explore the three-way interaction between career interruption, human capital, and the specific type of new media use.

Table 2: Descriptive statistics for the dependent, independent, moderating, and control variables.

Key Insights

The "Motherhood Penalty" is Multi-Dimensional

Career interruption is not merely an economic setback; it significantly lowers psychological confidence and cultural participation. The data shows a significantly negative correlation between career interruption and social integration ($\beta = -0.037, p < 0.05$). For every standard deviation increase in interruption duration, social integration scores drop.

Human Capital and the Digital Buffer

Surprisingly, human capital alone does not significantly moderate the link between career interruption and social integration. However, digital behavior dictates the effectiveness of human capital:

  • Learning-oriented use: For women using media for news, business, or online study, the three-way interaction was significantly positive ($\beta = 0.247, p < 0.01$). This suggests that digital learning empowers women to leverage their human capital to maintain social ties.
  • Amusing-oriented use: Conversely, for those focused on entertainment, chatting, and games, the interaction was significantly negative ($\beta = -0.245, p < 0.05$). Leisure-heavy internet use can lead to social withdrawal, hindering the reintegration process even for women with high human capital.

Conclusion

The negative impact of career interruption is most severe for women already at the lower end of the social integration spectrum. While human capital is a vital asset, its ability to facilitate social reintegration is heavily dependent on how women engage with new media. Policy-makers should focus on "fertility-friendly" workplace regulations and digital literacy programs that emphasize learning-oriented media use to minimize the long-term social costs of career interruptions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Promoting the social integration of various groups provides a significant guarantee for China to achieve high-quality development. However, female workers, as the main force of the service industry, had suffered a greater occupational impact due to COVID-19 and loosened China's fertility policy in 2021. After female career interruption, the change in women's social roles and networks has aroused concern about their social integration. However, limited attention had been paid to female career interruption in existing studies about social integration. Therefore, this study developed a theoretical model to explore the relationship between female career interruption and social integration. An empirical test using data from the fourth Chinese Women's Social Status Survey of Hainan Province was applied to evaluate the hypotheses. The results indicate that there is a significantly negative correlation between female career interruption and social integration. And there is a difference among female career interrupters with different quantiles of social integration. Furthermore, the impact of human capital on the link between female career interruption and social integration depended on the type of new media use. When female career interrupters who use strong learning-oriented new media (such as learning about news, working/business, studying online, and investing/financial management) encounter human capital, the relationship between female career interruption and social integration is minimal. In contrast, this relationship is enhanced when female career interrupters who use strong amusing-oriented new media (such as online consumption, chatting, entertainment, and games) are confronted with human capital. Meanwhile, the results of quantile regression show that the secondary moderating effect of learning-oriented new media use gradually weakens with the rise of the quantile of female social integration. And so does amusing-oriented new media use. However, a moderating effect of human capital alone is not found.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022female,
  author = {Chunyan Li and Yong‐Jin Liu and Weiming Li},
  title = {{Female career interruption and social integration: An interaction between human capital and new media use}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.917582},
}
Figure