TL;DR
This paper explores how interactive surfaces and multi-space games can be used to support scientific outreach events. The authors developed two games for an Institute for Quantum Computing (IQC) open house, demonstrating how gamification and novel technologies can engage the public with complex scientific concepts and institutional research.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Scientific institutions often struggle to effectively communicate complex research to the general public, especially during events like open houses. Traditional outreach methods can be dry and fail to capture the attention of a diverse audience. While interactive technologies like large displays and mobile devices offer promising avenues for engagement, there's a lack of guidance on how to design and deploy these effectively for scientific outreach. This paper addresses this gap by detailing the design, development, and deployment of two games aimed at making quantum computing research accessible and engaging, while also promoting the IQC itself.
Methods
The authors employed a collaborative, iterative design process involving an 11-member team of academics and practitioners, along with IQC staff and students. This process spanned approximately one year and included:
- Requirements Gathering: Understanding past outreach efforts and identifying design goals.
- Design Criteria Development: Establishing six key goals: Educational Value (D1), Personal/Local Information (D2), Approachable and Accessible (D3), Engaging (D4), Integrated (D5), and Logistical Constraints (D6).
- Game Design and Development:
- Quantum Cats: An "Angry Birds-like" game developed using Unity, designed for large multi-touch displays. It incorporates quantum mechanics concepts (superposition, tunnelling, uncertainty) into the game mechanics.
- Alice and Schrödinger's Excellent Adventure: A locative, augmented reality game also developed in Unity, utilizing NFC-enabled posters and personal mobile devices (Android) to guide visitors through the IQC facilities and introduce its research and staff.
- Deployment and Evaluation: The games were deployed at the IQC open house. Evaluation relied on observations, field notes, and post-event usage data (downloads, in-game metrics).
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The "datasets" in this context would be the usage data collected from the games during the open house and post-event downloads, rather than traditional datasets for training models.
Key Insights and Ideas
- "Honey Pot" Effect: Large interactive displays (like those used for Quantum Cats) are effective at attracting attention and drawing people in, acting as a "honey pot" for engagement.
- "Pollination" Effect: A key question remains whether this "honey pot" effect can lead to broader engagement with other exhibits or research ("pollination"). The authors suggest this is an area for future work.
- Gamification for Engagement: Leveraging familiar game mechanics (like Angry Birds) can make complex scientific topics more approachable and engaging, even for short-lived interactions.
- Balancing Education and Engagement: A tension exists between providing deep educational value and creating an engaging, accessible experience. For short outreach events, a "superficially educational" approach that sparks curiosity is often more effective.
- Logistical Challenges of Locative Games: Deploying locative games on personal devices faces significant hurdles, including the need for large downloads, NFC functionality (which isn't universally available or enabled), and device compatibility.
- Technology Maturity: The technologies for creating interactive spaces (like NFC for location detection) are still maturing, posing practical challenges for developers.
- Extending Reach Beyond the Event: Mobile apps can extend the reach of outreach activities beyond the physical event, allowing for continued engagement and learning.
Key Results
- Quantum Cats:
- Played extensively on the three large displays during the open house, with over 2,400 "cats launched" in-game.
- Downloaded over 5,000 times on Google Play Store in the week following the event, significantly exceeding the event's attendance.
- Featured on scientific media outlets, contributing to its widespread adoption.
- Considered a success by IQC staff, leading to plans for further development.
- Alice and Schrödinger's Excellent Adventure:
- Had significantly lower adoption rates, with only 12 personal device installations and 38 visitors using provided tablets.
- Attributed to logistical issues: large download size, NFC limitations (iOS incompatibility, Android enablement), and limited availability of loaner devices.
- Usability issue identified: in-game poster numbering was inefficient for a "completionist" player.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- Formal Evaluation: Traditional evaluation methods like video recording and on-site interviews were not feasible.
- Locative Game Adoption: Alice and Schrödinger's Excellent Adventure faced significant challenges due to technical and logistical barriers, limiting its reach.
- WiFi Constraints: Poor WiFi reception at the IQC limited data collection for the locative game.
- NFC Limitations: The reliance on NFC restricted the locative game to Android devices and users with NFC enabled.
- Future Work:
- "Pollination" Effect: Further research is needed to determine if "honey pot" displays lead to increased engagement with other exhibits.
- Quantum Cats Development: Plans are underway to introduce more educational content into Quantum Cats, particularly for the downloadable version.
- Improving Locative Game Deployment: Research into more robust and accessible technologies for creating interactive spaces and locative experiences is needed.
- Addressing Logistical Barriers: Developing strategies to overcome download size, device compatibility, and NFC issues for locative games.
Summary updated