Feedback Mechanism Construction of Problem-based Learning Teaching Approach in Cartography Course

Chang Jiang, Yunsong Shi, Jun Wang2013 · DOI

Abstract

Teaching systems are fundamentally based on feedback; the internal function of a logical teaching system is monitored and regulated by this return signal. Constructing a robust feedback mechanism to improve teaching effectiveness is an urgent challenge in modern cartography education. This paper proposes a construction method based on the feedback principles of automatic control theory, implemented within a Problem-Based Learning (PBL) framework. The results demonstrate that this mechanism effectively identifies both positive and negative feedback, providing a quantitative basis for iterative pedagogical improvement.

Introduction: The Feedback Gap in Cartography

Cartography has undergone a radical transformation since the 1990s, evolving from manual drafting to a complex information science. However, traditional "teacher-centered" instruction has often failed to keep pace, leaving students theoretically proficient but practically limited. While Problem-Based Learning (PBL) offers a student-centered alternative, it frequently lacks a systematic way to measure and adjust its effectiveness.

Teachers often rely on anecdotal evidence to modify their courses. Without a formal feedback loop, it is difficult to distinguish between "positive feedback" (elements that reinforce learning) and "negative feedback" (elements that hinder it), making systematic improvement nearly impossible. This study addresses this "feedback gap" by applying principles from automatic control theory to the classroom.

The Closed-Loop Teaching Model

The core of this approach is a "closed-loop" teaching system. By viewing student feedback as a "return signal" to the input end (the teacher), teaching becomes a self-regulating system rather than a one-way broadcast.

The proposed closed-loop teaching system based on automatic control theory.

In this model:

  • Controller: The teacher, who adjusts inputs based on feedback.
  • Actuator: The teaching method (PBL).
  • Controlled Object: The student.
  • Detector: A multi-dimensioned assessment index and questionnaire (the feedback mechanism).

The PBL cycle itself follows a four-step process: raising a problem, collecting data, discussion, and finally, summarization and reflection.

Methodology and Data Analysis

The study surveyed 81 students from the Grades of 2008 and 2010 at the Nanjing University of Posts and Communications. The feedback mechanism captured data across several dimensions, including approach preference (PBL vs. traditional), level of help received, perceived pressure, and preferred quantity of projects.

To ensure statistical rigor, the researchers employed the Chi-square ($\chi^2$) test to determine if differences in student responses were statistically significant based on their grade level or their teaching style preferences.

Key Results and Statistical Significance

The transition to PBL was generally well-received, with median scores for "Level of Help," "Pressure," and "Attitude" all reaching 3.00 on the study's scale. However, the most critical finding was that a student’s preference for a teaching style is a much stronger predictor of their struggles than their actual grade level.

Chi-square test results showing the significant relationship between teaching approach preference and student perception.

As shown in the statistical analysis, there are highly significant differences ($p < 0.01$) in how students perceived the "Level of Help" and "Percentage of Results" based on their teaching preference. Interestingly, there was no significant difference between the 2008 and 2010 grades, suggesting the PBL model's robustness across different year groups.

Insights into Student Friction

The feedback revealed distinct pain points based on student orientation:

  • The Inertia Barrier: Nearly 68% of the 2008 cohort cited "inertia and less motive in self-study" as a primary hurdle, highlighting the difficulty of overcoming passivity inherited from traditional schooling.
  • Preference Divergence: Students preferring PBL struggled most with the volume of knowledge and demanding requirements (47.7%). Conversely, those preferring traditional methods found literature searching to be the greatest difficulty (46.7%).
  • Assessment Preferences: PBL-leaning students preferred individual outputs like reports, while traditional-leaning students favored group discussions and mutual assessments.

Conclusion

Applying control theory to PBL creates a systematic framework for pedagogical evolution. While the feedback loop is theoretically sound, it requires teachers to transition from "knowledge transmitters" to active "listeners." Future work should focus on making this feedback retrieval more dynamic throughout the semester to allow for real-time course corrections, further perfecting the self-regulating classroom.

Summary updated

Abstract

Teaching system is based on the feedback. The internal function of a logical teaching system is monitored and regulated by the feedback. Constructing the feedback mechanism of teaching approach and making use of the feedback information to improve teaching effect are urgent problems of cartography course. Construction method is proposed and implemented based on feedback principle of automatic control theory in Problembased Learning (PBL) cartography course teaching for improving teaching approach. The results show that the feedback mechanism is helpful for finding the positive feedback and negative feedback from teaching approach to provide the basis for improving teaching approach.
BibTeX
@misc{jiang2013feedback,
  author = {Chang Jiang and Yunsong Shi and Jun Wang},
  title = {{Feedback Mechanism Construction of Problem-based Learning Teaching Approach in Cartography Course}},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.2991/icaicte.2013.71},
}
Figure